Effects of biochar addition on N<Subscript>2</Subscript>O and CO<Subscript>2</Subscript> emissions from two paddy soils

Impacts of biochar addition on nitrous oxide (N₂O) and carbon dioxide (CO₂) emissions from paddy soils are not well documented. Here, we have hypothesized that N₂O emissions from paddy soils could be depressed by biochar incorporation during the upland crop season without any effect on CO₂ emissions. Therefore, we have carried out the 60-day aerobic incubation experiment to investigate the influences of rice husk biochar incorporation (50 t ha⁻¹) into two typical paddy soils with or without nitrogen (N) fertilizer on N₂O and CO₂ evolution from soil. Biochar addition significantly decreased N₂O emissions during the 60-day period by 73.1% as an average value while the inhibition ranged from 51.4% to 93.5% (P < 0.05–0.01) in terms of cumulative emissions. Significant interactions were observed between biochar, N fertilizer, and soil type indicating that the effect of biochar addition on N₂O emissions was influenced by soil type. Moreover, biochar addition did not increase CO₂ emissions from both paddy soils (P > 0.05) in terms of cumulative emissions. Therefore, biochar can be added to paddy fields during the upland crop growing season to mitigate N₂O evolution and thus global warming.     

Soil N<Subscript>2</Subscript>O emissions and N<Subscript>2</Subscript>O/(N<Subscript>2</Subscript>O+N<Subscript>2</Subscript>) ratio as affected by different fertilization practices and soil moisture

The objective of this work was to evaluate the effect of the chemical nature and application frequency of N fertilizers at different moisture contents on soil N₂O emissions and N₂O/(N₂O+N₂) ratio. The research was based on five fertilization treatments: unfertilized control, a single application of 80 kg ha⁻¹ N-urea, five split applications of 16 kg ha⁻¹ N-urea, a single application of 80 kg ha⁻¹ N–KNO₃, five split applications of 16 kg ha⁻¹ N–KNO₃. Cumulative N₂O emissions for 22 days were unaffected by fertilization treatments at 32% water-filled pore space (WFPS). At 100% and 120% WFPS, cumulative N₂O emissions were highest from soil fertilized with KNO₃. The split application of N fertilizers decreased N₂O emissions compared to a single initial application only when KNO₃ was applied to a saturated soil, at 100% WFPS. Emissions of N₂O were very low after the application of urea, similar to those found at unfertilized soil. Average N₂O/(N₂O+N₂) ratio values were significantly affected by moisture levels (p = 0.015), being the lowest at 120% WFPS. The N₂O/(N₂O+N₂) ratio averaged 0.2 in unfertilized soil and 0.5 in fertilized soil, although these differences were not statistically significant.     

Nitrous oxide (N<Subscript>2</Subscript>O)-reducing denitrifier-inoculated organic fertilizer mitigates N<Subscript>2</Subscript>O emissions from agricultural soils

The only known sink for nitrous oxide (N₂O) is biochemical reduction to dinitrogen (N₂) by N₂O reductase (N₂OR). We hypothesized that the application of N₂O-reducing denitrifier-inoculated organic fertilizer could enhance soil N₂O consumption while the disruption of nosZ genes could result in inactivation of N₂O consumption. To test such hypotheses, a denitrifier-inoculated granular organic fertilizer was applied to both soil microcosms and fields. Of 41 denitrifier strains, 38 generated ³⁰N₂ in the end products of denitrification (³⁰N₂ and ⁴⁶N₂O) after the addition of Na¹⁵NO₃ in culture condition, indicating their high N₂O reductase activities. Of these 41 strains, 18 were screened in soil microcosms after their inoculation into the organic fertilizer, most of which were affiliated with Azospirillum and Herbaspirillum. These 18 strains were nutritionally starved to improve their survival in soil, and 14 starved and/or non-starved strains significantly decreased N₂O emissions in soil microcosms. However, the N₂O emission had not been decreased in soil microcosms after inoculating with a nosZ gene-disruptive strain, suggesting that N₂O reductase activity might be essential for N₂O consumption. Although the decrease of N₂O was not significant at field scales, the application of organic fertilizer inoculated with Azospirillum sp. TSH100 and Herbaspirillum sp. UKPF54 had decreased the N₂O emissions by 36.7% in Fluvisol and 23.4% in Andosol in 2014, but by 21.6% in Andosol in 2015 (H. sp. UKPF54 only). These results suggest that the application of N₂O-reducing denitrifier-inoculated organic fertilizer may enhance N₂O consumption or decrease N₂O emissions in agricultural soils.     

The effect of moisture on nitrous oxide emissions from soil and the N<Subscript>2</Subscript>O/(N<Subscript>2</Subscript>O+N<Subscript>2</Subscript>) ratio under laboratory conditions

Nitrous oxide (N₂O) contributes to greenhouse effect; however, little information on the consequences of different moisture levels on N₂O/(N₂O+N₂) ratio is available. The aim of this work was to analyze the influence of different soil moisture values and thus of redox conditions on absolute and relative emissions of N₂O and N₂ at intact soil cores from a Vertic Argiudoll. For this reason, the effect of water-filled porosity space (WFPS) values of soil cores of 40, 80,100, and 120% (the last one with a 2-cm surface water layer) was investigated. The greatest N₂O emission occurred at 80% WFPS treatment where conditions were not reductive enough to allow the complete reduction to N₂. The N₂O/(N₂O+N₂) ratio was lowest (0–0.051) under 120% WFPS and increased with decreasing soil moisture content. N₂O/(N₂O+N₂) ratio values significantly correlated with soil Eh; redox conditions seemed to control the proportion of N gases emitted as N₂O. N₂O emissions did not correlate satisfactorily with N₂O/(N₂O+N₂) ratio values, whereas they were significantly explained by the amount of total N₂O+N₂ emissions.     

Seasonal variations in indirect N<Subscript>2</Subscript>O emissions from an agricultural headwater ditch

Agricultural headwater ditches are an important source of indirect agricultural nitrous oxide (N₂O) emissions, but their contribution is difficult to quantify. In the present study, the static chamber-gas chromatography technique was used for measurement of N₂O emissions from vegetated (V, the whole ditch ecosystem) and non-vegetated (NV, the sediment-water interface only) zones in an agricultural headwater ditch in the Central Sichuan Basin in Southwestern China during 2014–2015. Annual N₂O emissions from the agricultural headwater ditch were similar to direct N₂O emissions from an adjacent N-fertilized purple soil cropland, suggesting nitrogen (N)-enriched ditches are important anthropogenic N₂O sources. Mean cumulative N₂O emissions during summer and autumn were higher than those in spring and winter. Overlying water nitrate (NO₃ ^?-N) concentration and sediment-water interface temperature were primary factors affecting seasonal N₂O emissions. Heavy precipitation transported NO₃ ^?-N from cropland and increase NO₃ ^?-N in the agricultural headwater ditch water, and subsequently stimulate N₂O emissions. A literature review of EF_5r (the indirect N₂O emission factor for rivers) revealed a mean value of 0.23%, similar to our values (0.27%), and also the default value (0.25%) proposed by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. The number of studies on indirect N₂O emissions remains limited, and more in situ measurements are needed to have more accurate values of EF_5r.     

N<Subscript>2</Subscript>O,CO<Subscript>2</Subscript>, Production,and C Sequestration in Vineyards: a Review

Even if it is less polluting than other farm sectors, grape growing management has to adopt measures to mitigate greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions and to preserve the quality of grapevine by-products. In viticulture, by land and crop management, GHG emissions can be reduced through adjusting methods of tillage, fertilizing, harvesting, irrigation, vineyard maintenance, electricity, natural gas, and transport until wine marketing, etc. Besides CO₂, nitrous oxide (N₂O) and methane (CH₄), released from fertilizers and waste/wastewater management are produced in vineyards. As the main GHG in vineyards, N₂O can have the same harmful action like large quantities of CO₂. Carbon can be found in grape leaves, shoots, and even in fruit pulp, roots, canes, trunk, or soil organic matter. C sequestration in soil by using less tillage and tractor passing is one of the efficient methods to reduce GHG in vineyards, with the inconvenience that many years are needed for detectable changes. In the last decades, among other methods, cover crops have been used as one of the most efficient way to reduce GHG emissions and increase fertility in vineyards. Even if we analyze many references, there are still limited information on practical methods in reducing emissions of greenhouse gases in viticulture. The aim of the paper is to review the main GHG emissions produced in vineyards and the approached methods for their reduction, in order to maintain the quality of grapes and other by-products.     

The influence of crop residues with different C: N ratios on the N<Subscript>2</Subscript>O emission from a loamy sand soddy-podzolic soil

The influence of crop residues with different C: N ratios on the N₂O emission from differently managed loamy sand soddy-podzolic soils was studied in a 50-day laboratory experiment. The application of crop residues into the soil increased the N₂O emission from the soil. The N₂O emission was lower from the poorly managed soil as compared to the soil with the high degree of cultivation. The crop residues form the following decreasing sequence in terms of their effect on the cumulative N₂O flow: cabbage > red clover > perennial grasses > straw of spring wheat. The composting of crop residues with a wide C: N ratio for 50 days did not exceed the critical value of the emission factor (1.25%), whereas, in the composting of crop residues with a narrow C: N ratio, the critical value of the emission factor was 1.3–2.0 times higher.     

Increases in soil CO<Subscript>2</Subscript> and N<Subscript>2</Subscript>O emissions with warming depend on plant species in restored alpine meadows of Wugong Mountain,China

Purpose

Ecosystem restorations can impact carbon dioxide (CO₂) and nitrous oxide (N₂O) emissions which are important greenhouse gasses. Alpine meadows are degraded worldwide, but restorations are increasing. Because their soils represent large carbon (C) and nitrogen (N) pools, they may produce significant amounts of CO₂ and N₂O depending on the plant species used in restorations. In addition, warming and N deposition may impact soil CO₂ and N₂O emissions from restored meadows.

Materials and methods

We collected soils from degraded meadows and plots restored using three different plant species at Wugong Mountain (Jiangxi, China). We measured CO₂ and N₂O emissions when soils were incubated at different temperatures (15, 25 or 35 °C) and levels of N addition (control vs. 4 g m^?2) to understand their responses to warming and N deposition.

Results and discussion

Dissolved organic C was higher in restored plots (especially with Fimbristylis dichotoma) compared to non-restored bare soils, and their soil inorganic N was lower. CO₂ emission rates were increased by vegetation restorations, decreased by N deposition, and increased by warming. CO₂ emission rates were similar for the three grass species at 15 and 25 °C, but they were lower with Miscanthus floridulus at 35 °C. Soils from F. dichotoma and Carex chinensis plots had higher N₂O emissions than degraded or M. floridulus plots, especially at 25 °C.

Conclusions

These results show that the effects of restorations on soil greenhouse gas emissions depended on plant species. In addition, these differences varied with temperature suggesting that future climate should be considered when choosing plant species in restorations to predict soil CO₂ and N₂O emissions and global warming potential.

     

N<Subscript>2</Subscript>O emission from conventional and minimum-tilled soils

In this study, we investigated N₂O emissions from two fields under minimum tillage, cropped with maize (MT maize) and summer oats (MT oats), and a conventionally tilled field cropped with maize (CT maize). Nitrous oxide losses from the MT maize and MT oats fields (5.27 and 3.64 kg N₂O-N ha⁻¹, respectively) were significantly higher than those from the CT maize field (0.27 kg N₂O-N ha⁻¹) over a period of 1 year. The lower moisture content in CT maize (43% water-filled pore space [WFPS] compared to 60–65%) probably caused the difference in total N₂O emissions. Denitrification was found to be the major source of N₂O loss. Emission factors calculated from the MT field data were high (0.04) compared to the CT field (0.001). All data were simulated with the denitrification decomposition model (DNDC). For the CT field, N₂O and N₂O + N₂ emissions were largely overestimated. For the MT fields, there was a better agreement with the total N₂O and N₂O + N₂ emissions, although the N₂O emissions from the MT maize field were underestimated. The simulated N₂O emissions were particularly influenced by fertilization, but several other measured N₂O emission peaks associated with other management practices at higher WFPS were not captured by the model. Several mismatches between simulated and measured \textNH₄⁺ {\text{NH}}_4^ + , \textNO₃^- {\text{NO}}_3^ - and WFPS for all fields were observed. These mismatches together with the insensitivity of the DNDC model for increased N₂O emissions at the management practices different from fertilizer application explain the limited similarity between the simulated and measured N₂O emissions pattern from the MT fields.     

Suppression of NH<Subscript>3</Subscript> and N<Subscript>2</Subscript>O emissions by massive urea intercalation in montmorillonite

Purpose  

A large amount of nitrogen (N) fertilizers has been broadcasted over soil surface for reliable crop production. Unfortunately, the broadcasted N vulnerable to volatilization and leaching can lead to serious environmental problems. As a new approach to mitigate N loss of broadcasted fertilizers, massive intercalation of urea into montmorillonite (MMT) was recently proposed to innovatively enhance the urea use efficiency. This study focuses on demonstrating the behaviors of the urea intercalated into MMT in soils.     

Spatial variability and biophysicochemical controls on N<Subscript>2</Subscript>O emissions from differently tilled arable soils

Nitrous oxide (N₂O) emissions, soil microbial community structure, bulk density, total pore volume, total C and N, aggregate mean weight diameter and stability index were determined in arable soils under three different types of tillage: reduced tillage (RT), no tillage (NT) and conventional tillage (CT). Thirty intact soil cores, each in a 25 × 25-m² grid, were collected to a depth of 10 cm at the seedling stage of winter wheat in February 2008 from Maulde (50°3′ N, 3°43′ W), Belgium. Two additional soil samples adjacent to each soil core were taken to measure the spatial variance in biotic and physicochemical conditions. The microbial community structure was evaluated by means of phospholipid fatty acids analysis. Soil cores were amended with 15 kg NO₃⁻-N ha⁻¹, 15 kg NH₄⁺-N ha⁻¹ and 30 kg ha⁻¹ urea-N ha⁻¹ and then brought to 65% water-filled pore space and incubated for 21 days at 15°C, with regular monitoring of N₂O emissions. The N₂O fluxes showed a log-normal distribution with mean coefficients of variance (CV) of 122%, 78% and 90% in RT, NT and CT, respectively, indicating a high spatial variation. However, this variability of N₂O emissions did not show plot scale spatial dependence. The N₂O emissions from RT were higher (p < 0.01) than from CT and NT. Multivariate analysis of soil properties showed that PC1 of principal component analysis had highest loadings for aggregate mean weight diameter, total C and fungi/bacteria ratio. Stepwise multiple regression based on soil properties explained 72% (p < 0.01) of the variance of N₂O emissions. Spatial distributions of soil properties controlling N₂O emissions were different in three different tillages with CV ranked as RT > CT > NT.     

Reducing CH<Subscript>4</Subscript> and CO<Subscript>2</Subscript> emissions from waterlogged paddy soil with biochar

Purpose  

A potential means to diminish increasing levels of CO₂ in the atmosphere is the use of pyrolysis to convert biomass into biochar, which stabilizes the carbon (C) that is then applied to soil. Before biochar can be used on a large scale, especially in agricultural soils, its effects on the soil system need to be assessed. This is especially important in rice paddy soils that release large amounts of greenhouse gases to the atmosphere.     

Effect of Stover Management and Nitrogen Fertilization on N<Subscript>2</Subscript>O and CO<Subscript>2</Subscript> Emissions from Irrigated Maize in a High Nitrate Mediterranean Soil

A high soil nitrogen (N) content in irrigated areas quite often results in environmental problems. Improving the management practices of intensive agriculture can mitigate greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. This study compared the effect of maize stover incorporation or removal together with different mineral N fertilizer rates (0, 200 and 300 kg N ha^?1) on the emission of nitrous oxide (N₂O) and carbon dioxide (CO₂) on a sprinkler-irrigated maize (Zea mays L.). The trail was conducted in the Ebro Valley (NE Spain) in a high nitrate-N soil (i.e. 200 g NO₃–N kg^?1). Nitrous oxide and CO₂ emissions were sampled weekly using a semi-static closed chamber and quantified using the photoacoustic technique in 2011 and 2012. Applying sidedress N fertilizer tended to increase N₂O emissions whereas stover incorporation did not have any clear effect. Nitrification was probably the main process leading to N₂O. Denitrification was limited by the low soil moisture content (WFPS <?54%), due to an adequate irrigation management. Emissions ranged from ??0.11 to 0.36% of the N applied, below the IPCC (2007) values. Nitrogen fertilization tended to reduce CO₂ emission, but only in 2011. Stover incorporation increased CO₂ emission. Nitrogen use efficiency decreased with increasing mineral fertilizer supply. The application of N in high N soils of the Ebro Valley is not necessary until the soil restores a normal mineral N content, regardless of stover management. This will combine productivity with keeping N₂O and CO₂ emissions under control provided irrigation is adequately managed. Testing soil NO₃ ^?–N contents before fertilizing would improve N fertilizer recommendations.     

The fungal and bacterial biomass (selective inhibition) and the production of CO<Subscript>2</Subscript> and N<Subscript>2</Subscript>O by soddy-podzolic soils of postagrogenic biogeocenoses

In the humus horizon of soddy-podzolic soils of postagrogenic cenoses and primary forests, the contributions of the fungi and bacteria were determined by the selective inhibition of the substrate-induced respiration (SIR) by antibiotics; the basal (microbial) respiration and the net-produced nitrous oxide (N₂O) were also determined. The procedure of the SIR separation using antibiotics (cycloheximide and streptomycin) into the fungal and bacterial components was optimized. It was shown that the fungi: bacteria ratio was 1.58, 2.04, 1.55, 1.39, 2.09, and 1.86 for the cropland, fallow, and different-aged forests (20, 45, 90, and 450 years), respectively. The fungal and bacterial production of CO₂ in the primary forest soil was higher than in the cropland by 6.3 and 11.4 times, respectively. The production of N₂O in the soils of the primary and secondary (90-year-old) forests (3 and 7 ng N-N₂O/g soil per hour, respectively) was 2–13 times lower than in the postagrogenic cenoses, where low values were also found for the microbial biomass carbon (C_mic), its components (the C_mic-bacteria and C_mic-fungi), and the portion of C_mic in the organic carbon of the soil. A conclusion was drawn about the misbalance of the microbial processes in the overgrown cropland accompanied by the increased production of N₂O by the soil during its enrichment with an organic substrate (glucose).     

Long-term animal impact modifies potential production of N<Subscript>2</Subscript>O from pasture soil

At cattle overwintering areas, inputs of nutrients in animal excrements create conditions favourable for intensive microbial activity in soil. During nitrogen transformations, significant amounts of N₂O are released, which makes overwintering areas important sources of N₂O emission. In previous studies, however, increasing intensity of long-term cattle impact did not always increase emissions of N₂O from the soil: in some cases, N₂O emissions from the soil were lower at the most impacted area than at the moderately impacted one. Thus, the relationships between the level of long-term animal impact and potential production of N₂O from soil by denitrification were investigated in field and laboratory experiments. Field measurements indicated that the production of N₂O after glucose and nitrate amendments was greater in severely and moderately impacted locations than in an unimpacted location, while differences between the severely and moderately impacted locations were not significant. In laboratory experiments, the potential production of N₂O (measured as anaerobic production of N₂O after addition of glucose and nitrate) was highest in the moderately impacted soil. Surprisingly, potential N₂O production was lower in the most impacted than in the moderately impacted soil, and the net N₂O production in the highly impacted soil was further decreased by a significant reduction of N₂O to N₂. The expected stimulating effect of an increasing ratio of glucose C to nitrate N on the reduction of N₂O to N₂ during denitrification was not confirmed. The results show that cattle increase the denitrification potential of the soil but suggest that the denitrification potential does not increase indefinitely with increasing cattle impact.     

Seasonal Dynamics of Soil CO<Subscript>2</Subscript> Concentration and CO<Subscript>2</Subscript> Fluxes from the Soil of the Former Lake Texcoco,Mexico

Seasonal changes of the soil CO₂ concentration and the rate of CO₂ fluxes emission from the soil formed on the sediments of the former Lake Texcoco, which occupied a significant part of the Mexico Valley until the mid-17th century, were studied. The soils (Fluvic Endogleyic Phaeozems) were characterized by a low CO₂ fluxes rate, which is related to their high alkalinity. The mean values of soil respiration were 6.0–14.1 mg C/(m² h) depending on vegetation type, which corresponds to 60–157 g C/(m² yr). The contribution of plants to the CO₂ fluxes insignificantly varied by seasons and depended on the species composition of vegetation. The soil CO₂ concentration and soil respiration in eucalypt (Eucalyptus globulus Labill.) plantation were two times higher than those in the grass–subshrub area, the ground cover of which consisted of Distichlis spicata (L.) Greene and Suaeda nigra (Raf.) J.F. Macbr. species. This can be related to the significant volumes of gas production during the respiration of eucalypt roots and associated rhizosphere community. The contribution of the root systems of grass cover to the soil CO₂ fluxes in eucalypt plantation slightly varied within the year and was equal to 24% on the average. In the grass–subshrub area, its value varied from 41% in the cold season to 60% in the warm season. The spatial variability of soil CO₂ concentration and its flux rate to the atmosphere was due to the differences in plant species composition and hydrothermal conditions, and their temporal trend was closely related to the seasonal accumulation of plant biomass and soil temperature.     

Abundance of transcripts of functional gene reflects the inverse relationship between CH<Subscript>4</Subscript> and N<Subscript>2</Subscript>O emissions during mid-season drainage in acidic paddy soil

Agricultural management significantly affects methane (CH₄) and nitrous oxide (N₂O) emissions from paddy fields. However, little is known about the underlying microbiological mechanism. Field experiment was conducted to investigate the effect of the water regime and straw incorporation on CH₄ and N₂O emissions and soil properties. Quantitative PCR was applied to measure the abundance of soil methanogens, methane-oxidising bacteria, nitrifiers, and denitrifiers according to DNA and mRNA expression levels of microbial genes, including mcrA, pmoA, amoA, and nirK/nirS/nosZ. Field trials showed that the CH₄ and N₂O flux rates were negatively correlated with each other, and N₂O emissions were far lower than CH₄ emissions. Drainage and straw incorporation affected functional gene abundance through altered soil environment. The present (DNA-level) gene abundances of amoA, nosZ, and mcrA were higher with straw incorporation than those without straw incorporation, and they were positively correlated with high concentrations of soil exchangeable NH₄⁺ and dissolved organic carbon. The active (mRNA-level) gene abundance of mcrA was lower in the drainage treatment than in continuous flooding, which was negatively correlated with soil redox potential (Eh). The CH₄ flux rate was significantly and positively correlated with active mcrA abundance but negatively correlated with Eh. The N₂O flux rate was significantly and positively correlated with present and active nirS abundance and positively correlated with soil Eh. Thus, we demonstrated that active gene abundance, such as of mcrA for CH₄ and nirS for N₂O, reflects the contradictory relationship between CH₄ and N₂O emissions regulated by soil Eh in acidic paddy soils.     

Effect of soil water status and mulching on N<Subscript>2</Subscript>O and CH<Subscript>4</Subscript> emission from lowland rice field in China

Cultivation of rice in unsaturated soils covered with mulch is receiving more attention in China because of increasingly serious water shortage; however, greenhouse gas emission from this cultivation system is still poorly understood. A field experiment was conducted in 2001 to compare nitrous oxide (N₂O) and methane (CH₄) emission from rice cultivated in unsaturated soil covered with plastic or straw mulch and the traditional waterlogged production system. Trace gas fluxes from the soil were measured weekly throughout the entire growth period using a closed chamber method. Nitrous oxide emissions from unsaturated rice fields were large and varied considerably during the rice season. They were significantly affected by N fertilizer application rate. In contrast, N₂O emission from the waterlogged system was very low with a maximum of 0.28 mg N₂O m^–2 h^–1. However, CH₄ emission from the waterlogged system was significantly higher than from the unsaturated system, with a maximum emission rate of 5.01 mg CH₄ m^–2 h^–1. Our results suggested that unsaturated rice cultivation with straw mulch reduce greenhouse gas emissions.     

Effect of the temperature and moisture on the N<Subscript>2</Subscript>O emission from some arable soils

The effect of the temperature and moisture on the emission of N₂O from arable soils was studied in model experiments with arable soils at three contrasting levels of wetting and in a wide temperature range (from −5 to +25°C), including freeze-thaw cycles. It was shown that the losses of fertilizer nitrogen from the soils with water contents corresponding to 60 and 75% of the total water capacity (TWC) did not exceed 0.01–0.09% in the entire temperature range. In the soils with an elevated water content (90% of the TWC) at 25°C, the loss of fertilizer nitrogen in the form of N₂O reached 2.35% because of the active denitrification. The extra N₂O flux initiated by the freeze-thaw processes made up 88–98% of the total nitrous oxide flux during the entire experiment.