Effects of host and pathogen genotypes on inducibility of resistance in tomato (Solanum lycopersicum) to Phytophthora infestans

Thirteen tomato (Solanum lycopersicum) accessions were tested for inducibility of resistance against two isolates of Phytophthora infestans using BABA (dl ‐3‐amino butyric acid) as the inducing agent. In a more detailed trial, six of the accessions were assessed for inducibility of resistance to six P. infestans isolates on three leaves of different age per plant. Plants were inoculated 1 week after treatment with BABA. Area under the disease progress curve (AUDPC), sporulation capacity (SC) and infection efficiency (IE) were all affected by treatment with BABA. On leaves of all ages AUDPC was most affected by induction (43–100% reduction on the youngest leaves) followed by SC (14–100%) and IE (0–100% reduction). Tomato genotypes varied significantly in inducibility of resistance against P. infestans and the degree of induction generally decreased with increasing leaf age, whilst the absolute susceptibility with respect to AUDPC and SC rarely changed. The level of induction was not always related to the resistance level of the tomato accession and it was significantly influenced by the pathogen isolate used for challenge inoculation. The results show that inducibility of resistance is a selectable trait that is, however, isolate‐specific.     

番茄抗晚疫病Ph-3基因RAPD标记 的克隆与CAPS标记的建立

目前,番茄晚疫病(Phytophthora infestans)在世界各番茄主产区普遍发生,并造成严重的经济损失,已经成为番茄生产的主要障碍之一.防御番茄晚疫病最有效的方法是培育抗病品种.依靠常规方法耗时、耗力,同时由于人为鉴定标准的差异,会直接影响鉴定结果,延长育种周期,分子标记技术的发展为解决此问题提供了可能.分子标记可被用于在苗期进行大量的抗病鉴定,不受时间、地域的限制,从而加速育种工作进程[1].Qiu等[2]已找到1条与抗晚疫病Ph-3基因连锁的RAPD标记,本研究旨在将此RAPD标记转化为稳定的CAPS标记,为抗晚疫病分子辅助选择育种(MAS)奠定良好的基础.     

一个与稻瘟病菌无毒基因AVR-Pik~m连锁的SCAR标记的分离

 本研究将以前在稻瘟病菌菌株S1522获得的与决定对水稻品种梅雨明无毒性的基因(AVR-Pik^m)相连锁的1个RAPD标记OPO12₁₀₀₀进行了克隆和鉴定。核苷酸序列测定与分析结果表明:OPO12₁₀₀₀的大小为946个碱基,不含有与已报道的稻瘟病菌Mg-SINE、Fosburry、Magyy、Grasshopper、Pot2以及Pot3等同源的重复序列。根据OPO12₁₀₀₀的核苷酸序列,设计了1对24个核苷酸的特异引物,对无毒表型亲本S1522和毒性表型亲本S159、无毒表型群体基因池、毒性表型基因池以及有性杂交后代108个菌株进行了PCR扩增,所有无毒表型的菌株均能特异性地扩增出1条与OPO12₁₀₀₀大小相同的DNA条带,而毒性表型的菌株除5个重组个体外,均不能扩增出这条特异带。此结果表明,与稻瘟病菌无毒基因AVR-Pik^m连锁的RAPD标记OPO12₁₀₀₀被成功地转化为SCAR标记,为进一步通过染色体步移克隆该无毒基因奠定了基础。     

Genetics and molecular mechanisms of resistance to powdery mildews in tomato (Solanum lycopersicum) and its wild relatives

Powdery mildews (PMs) cause disease in a wide range of plant species including important crops. Taking tomato as an example, here we review findings on the genetic basis and mechanisms of plant resistance to PMs. First, we present a summary of our research on tomato resistance to two PM species, with the focus on Oidium neolycopersici. We discuss the genetics of resistance to this pathogen in tomato. Then, we compare different forms of resistance mediated by different resistance genes based on molecular and cytological data. Also, we provide a comparison between these resistance genes in tomato with those in barley, Arabidopsis and wheat, in order to present a model for the genetic basis of resistance to PMs in plants. We try to accommodate these resistance mechanisms in the current model of plant innate immunity. At the end we discuss possibilities to translate these findings to practical approaches in breeding for resistance to PMs in crops.     

马铃薯晚疫病菌抗甲霜灵的SCAR标记

建立马铃薯晚疫病菌抗甲霜灵SCAR(sequenced characterized amplified region,序列特征扩增区域)标记,以马铃薯晚疫病菌对甲霜灵高抗菌株HD01-3和对甲霜灵高感菌株DK98-1为亲本,通过无性单游动孢子分离和有性杂交获得菌株HD01-3无性后代群体、菌株DK98-1无性后代群体以及F1代分离群体,以此为试验材料,利用BSA法(bulked segregant analysis,分离群体分组分析法)构建抗感基因池对后代菌系的甲霜灵抗性进行RAPD(random amplified polymorphic DNA,随机扩增多态性DNA)分析。从178条RAPD随机引物中找到一条特异性引物S2054,其可以扩增出一个与晚疫病菌对甲霜灵抗性相关的遗传标记,将该特异条带回收、克隆、测序,发现此标记大小为457bp,根据测序结果设计特异PCR引物,用于扩增抗感基因池,成功地将特异RAPD标记转化为SCAR标记。初步建立了马铃薯晚疫病菌抗甲霜灵SCAR标记,辅助监测晚疫病菌对甲霜灵的抗性。     

The effect of the presence of R-genes for resistance to late blight (Phytophthora infestans) of potato (Solanum tuberosum) on the underlying level of field resistance

The differential genotypes R₁, R₁₀ and R₁₁, as originally defined by Black, were crossed with R-gene-free cultivars and the progenies divided into two subpopulations comprising those which had inherited the R-gene and those which had not. The underlying level of field resistance of the two groups was compared in a field trial in which they were inoculated with an isolate that could overcome the relevant R-genes. The R-gene-bearing group was significantly ( P  < 0·001) more resistant than the R-gene-free group, with mean scores over four dates in 2000 of 4·86 and 4·09, respectively, on a 1–9 scale of increasing resistance, and of 4·10 and 2·35 on one date in 2001. However, the magnitude of the effect depended on the R-gene and the year of the trial. Data from a progeny of cv. Stirling (with an R-gene and a high level of field resistance) were examined and the same effect of an R-gene found. Fewer of the R-gene-bearing group of clones were highly susceptible, and more were resistant. The most resistant clones always bore the R-gene. It is concluded that increased resistance is conferred by the defeated R-gene or linked genes for field resistance.     

Transcriptome profile of acibenzolar-S-methyl-induced genes in tomato suggests a complex polygenic effect on resistance to Phytophthora infestans

Induced resistance by chemicals such as acibenzolar-S-methyl -ASM (commercialized as Actigard by Syngenta Inc) mimics the biological activation of systemic acquired resistance (SAR). ASM takes the place of salicylic acid (SA) in the SAR signal pathway inducing the same molecular markers and range of resistance. The goal of our work was to understand the downstream molecular events by which ASM confers resistance to Phytophthora infestans in tomatoes. To accomplish this goal we assayed gene expression in ASM-treated plants using a microarray with more than 12,000 tomato ESTs. As many as 300 genes were responsive to ASM. Of these, 117 were detected in most of the biological replications. Basal defense associated genes as well as SAR and disease resistance genes (R-like) involved in induced resistance and effector-triggered immunity were highly expressed. We attempted to determine the phenotype of 13 of these genes by virus induced gene silencing (VIGS). These 13 genes were selected on the basis of previous implication in plant defense response and by reliability of induction by ASM. VIGS was partially successful for three of the 13 genes, but this partial silencing did not lead to a significant reduction in the effect of ASM. The ethylene pathway was also activated in response to ASM, but a tomato mutant not responsive to ethylene remained responsive to ASM. It seems most likely that the ASM effect is complex and polygenic, depending on the effect of several genes.     

Intensity of infection of tomato by Phytophthora infestans in central Ukraine in relation to varietal resistance

Phytophthora infestans is widespread in the central part of Ukraine, infecting tomatoes everywhere but not to the same extent in different years. The disease can completely destroy the crop in epiphytotic years. We have studied commercial cultivars and hybrids of tomato with different degrees of resistance to P. infestans. The degree of disease development and the date of its appearance were found to depend on the resistance group of the genotype investigated. In weakly resistant tomato cultivars and hybrids, first disease symptoms were noticed 3–4 days earlier than in more resistant ones. The degree of disease development reached 40–80% on weakly resistant genotypes at the end of the growing season, but only 5–40% on resistant ones (depending on the suitability of conditions for development of P. infestans ). The development of P. infestans on fruits also depended on the degree of resistance. Differences between moderately and weakly resistant tomatoes in the degree of disease development and the date of its appearance were not significant. The data was corroborated in the laboratory conditions in the way of artificial inoculation.     

Use of ELISA for assessing major gene resistance of potato leaves to Phytophthora infestans

Hypersensitivity and susceptibility of potato leaflets of different genotypes to Phytophthora infestans were distinguished using ELISA. Estimates of pathogen growth indicated that an intermediate reaction sometimes occurred. Visual symptoms of disease were not always closely related to the pathogen content (mycelium, μg fresh weight) of leaflets estimated by ELISA. Leaflets inoculated with 1000 zoospores in a droplet had to be incubated for at least 6-8 days at 15 C before reliable estimates of the reaction by ELISA could be determined. Increasing the inoculum load improved the differentiation between hypersensitivity and susceptibility.     

A SCAR marker specific for rapid detection of the avirulence gene Avr1c in Phytophthora sojae

The F₂ population derived from a cross between isolates pR_x (Avr1c-Avr1c) and ps₁ (avr1c-avr1c) of Phytophthora sojae, fungal agent of soybean stem and root rot, was used to determine the genetic basis of avirulence towards Rps1c gene in soybean. The results indicated that this avirulence is dominant and controlled by a single locus, as expected for a simple gene-for-gene model. Segregation of Avr1c in the F₂ progeny of this cross fits a 3:1 ratio. Four of 80 AFLP primers effectively distinguished the avirulent pR_x from the virulent ps₁. Among the 5 specific markers, band C was amplified from the avirulent pR_x by primer set EGC/MAT, then recovered and cloned. This AFLP marker was successfully transfered to a SCAR marker through sequencing, primer design and specific amplication of the DNA of the avirulent pR_x. Results of validity and specificity experiments with 50 individuals of the F₂ progeny and 50 field isolates demonstrated that this SCAR marker (a 616-bp fragment) can be successfully and specifically amplified from the P. sojae isolates that have Avr1c gene.     

Components of resistance to late blight (Phytophthora infestans) in eight South AmericanSolanum species

Four components of partial resistance toPhytophthora infestans were measured after inoculation in the greenhouse and in the field ofSolanum arnezii x hondelmannii, S. berthaultii, S. circaeifolium, S. leptophyes, S. microdontum, S. sparsipilum, S. sucrense andS. vernei, and four hybrid progenies ofS. microdontum withS. tuberosum. The four components were infection efficiency, lesion growth rate, generation time and sporulation capacity. The results were compared with resistance ratings derived from field experiments, and with observations made on the potato cultivars Bintje, Bildstar, Libertas and Pimpernel. Genetic variation for all components was found, while the relative importance of the components of partial resistance appeared to vary between the species. InS. microdontum, generation time, infection efficiency and lesion growth rate, and inS. tuberosum infection efficiency, lesion growth rate and sporulation capacity appeared positively associated, but in other species no such association was found. A strong hypersensitive reaction, the expression of which appeared to depend on environmental conditions, was found inS. microdontum. ForS. berthaultii, infection efficiency appeared to be the main resistance component.Abbreviations ADPC area under the disease progress curve - IE infection efficiency - LGR lesion growth rate - GT generation time - SC sporulation capacity     

Physiological and histopathological assessments of the susceptibility of different tomato (Solanum lycopersicum) cultivars to early blight disease

European Journal of Plant Pathology - The current research aims to evaluate the susceptibility of the tomato of the tomato (Solanum lycopersicum) cultivars 65,015 (CV1), Basma (CV2), Dalia (CV3),...     

Studies on the inheritance of resistance to metalaxyl in Phytophthora infestans

Single-oospore progeny from matings between field isolates of Phytophthora infestans either highly resistant or sensitive to metalaxyl were analysed for fungicide sensitivity in vitro, mating type and, in some cases, allozyme variation at the locus for glucosephosphate isomerase ( GPI-1. ) In each cross the majority of first-generation (F₁) progeny showed intermediate sensitivity to metalaxyl. Frequency distributions were skewed towards sensitivity and a few progeny were either wholly sensitive or resistant phenotypes. Allozyme analysis of F₁ progeny from a cross between parents of Dutch and Mexican origin showed that c. 10% were selfs of both parents and of parental phenotype for metalaxyl sensitivity. The selfs of the A2 but not the Al parent segregated for mating type. Two backcross generations to the metalaxyl-resistant Dutch parent gave unexpected phenotypic frequency distributions and aberrant ratios for genotypes at the GPI-I locus.
Progeny of another backcross between an F₁ isolate of intermediate sensitivity and its sensitive Egyptian parent gave a 1:1 ratio for sensitive: intermediate phenotypes. F₂ progeny from a related sibmating between intermediate phenotypes segregated in a ratio close to 1:2:1 for sensitive: intermediate: resistant phenotypes. Segregation was also observed among sexual progeny of an intermediate self-fertile isolate from the backcross generation but not among progeny of a resistant self-fertile phenotype. Mating type segregated in both cases.
These data are consistent with resistance to metalaxyl in P. infestans being governed by a single nuclear locus exhibiting incomplete dominance. This hypothesis is discussed in relation to the incidence of resistance to metalaxyl in natural populations of P. infestans.     

一个新的与稻瘟病菌无毒基因AVR-Pikm紧密连锁的SCAR标记

 无毒基因是病原物中决定寄主抗病性表达的功能基因,其功能的丧失导致毒性小种的产生。本研究利用随机引物扩增DNA多态性技术,从稻瘟病菌菌株S1522中新筛选到1个与无毒基因AVR-Pik^m紧密连锁的DNA标记OPE12₁₄₀₀。根据OPE12₁₄₀₀的核苷酸序列,设计了1对含有17个核苷酸的特异性SCAR引物,并利用该引物对无毒表型亲本S1522和毒性表型亲本S159及其有性杂交后代的108个菌株进行了PCR扩增。结果表明:所有无毒表型的菌株均能特异性扩增出1条与OPE12₁₄₀₀大小相近的DNA片段,而毒性表型的菌株除2个重组体外,均不能扩增出此片段。根据计算,这一SCAR标记与目标无毒基因AVR-Pik^m之间的遗传距离为1.89 cM,与本研究小组先前报道的另一个标记OPO12₁₀₀₀位于目标基因的同一侧,但与OPO12₁₀₀₀相比,距目标基因近了2.86 cM。本标记的获得将有助于确定AVR-Pik^m在染色体上的位置,有助于确定用于进一步筛选位于相反一侧的连锁标记的重叠群区域。     

马铃薯晚疫病菌对甲霜灵抗性机制的初步研究

 选取对甲霜灵敏感、中抗和高抗的马铃薯晚疫病菌(Phytophthora infestans)菌株各2株,采用电导率法和同位素掺入法,研究了甲霜灵对马铃薯晚疫病菌不同抗药性水平菌株细胞膜通透性和RNA聚合酶活性的影响,借助液相色谱分析方法检测了不同抗药性水平菌株对甲霜灵的降解作用。结果表明:甲霜灵对马铃薯晚疫病菌不同抗药性水平菌株的细胞膜通透性没有明显影响;随着甲霜灵浓度提高,敏感菌株的RNA聚合酶活性受到显著抑制,10μg/mL甲霜灵对敏感菌株RNA聚合酶活性的抑制率达到40%以上,而10和100μg/mL甲霜灵对高抗菌株的RNA聚合酶活性只表现轻微的抑制作用,抑制作用分别小于8%和21%,甲霜灵对中抗菌株RNA聚合酶活性的抑制作用介于对敏感菌株和高抗菌株的抑制作用之间。抗性菌株对甲霜灵有一定的降解作用,培养30d后高抗菌株HL105和SC1的降解率分别达到13.46%和16.14%。     

Correction to: Physiological and histopathological assessments of the susceptibility of different tomato (Solanum lycopersicum) cultivars to early blight disease

European Journal of Plant Pathology - A Correction to this paper has been published: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10658-021-02275-y     

A Laboratory Assay for Phytophthora infestans Resistance in Various Solanum Species Reflects the Field Situation

Physiological and molecular research on resistance responses of Solanum tuberosum cultivars and partially resistant Solanum species to Phytophthora infestans requires a reliable resistance test that can be used in the laboratory. Laboratory tests performed on detached leaves and intact plants were compared with field tests for similarity of late blight reactions. Detached leaves from field-grown plants were as resistant as detached leaves from climate chamber-grown plants when challenged with P. infestans. However, detached leaves incubated in covered trays at high relative humidity were more susceptible than detached leaves kept in open trays or leaves on intact plants. The incubation conditions of detached leaves in covered trays rather than detachment itself appeared to affect the resistance expression. Detached leaves of some wild Solanum genotypes became partially infected, whereas intact plants were completely resistant when inoculated. Inoculation of leaves on intact plants, however, resulted in lower infection efficiencies. These limitations should be taken into account when choosing the appropriate inoculation method for specific purposes. For resistance screening, laboratory tests proved to be a good alternative for field tests. The ranking of resistance levels for twenty plant genotypes was similar under laboratory and field conditions.