Evaluating quantitative screening methods for manganese toxicity in cotton genotypes 1

Identification of cotton genotypes more tolerant of toxic concentrations of soil solution manganese (Mn²⁺) would integrate well with soil ameliorations of that problem. Several quantitative and semi‐quantitative methods to determine the amount of Mn toxicity were evaluated on three genotypes of Gossypium hirsutum (LaDSIS 12513, LaDASS 5175, and Coker gl 79–501) and one genotype of Gossypium barbadense (Pitnas S‐5). Specific leaf weight (SLW) and the semi‐quantitative, ‘percentage of leaves that were damaged’ (PLD) correlated the least with other methods of Mn toxicity determination. Neither SLW or PLD provided more separation between genotypes than area/leaf (AL), peroxidase (POD) activity, and indole‐3‐acetic acid oxidase (IAAO) activity. Similar genotype separations occurred for AL, POD, and IAAO at 10 mg/L Mn in solution, but POD and IAAO produced more genotype separations than AL at 5 mg/L of Mn. There were differences in enzyme activity between genotypes at control (0.25 mg/L) Mn solution concentration, making assessment difficult, especially between species. Barring this caveat, the relatively fast POD activity assay was considered to be the best method since it paralleled activity of IAAO, the functional enzyme of Mn toxicity, which had a relatively slow assay method.