Soil Testing Bray-1 Phosphorus with Non-Reagent Grade Hydrochloric and Sulfuric Acids

Portable instruments have reduced on-site testing costs for soil pH and potassium in isolated locations. Acids could not be shipped to a remote Africa field laboratory. Bray-1 phosphorus (P) testing is difficult because hydrochloric (HCl) is required in the extraction solution and sulfuric acid (H₂SO₄) is used in color development stock solutions. Muriatic HCl acid and battery H₂SO₄ were available in a local stores. The objectives of this study were to evaluate the accuracy of P soil testing using diluted, non-reagent HCl for making modified Bray1-P extractant and non-reagent H₂SO₄ for color development. Experiment 1 was conducted with soil samples from fields using Sunnyside? and Klean Strip? HCl muriatic acids. Soil samples extracted with diluted reagent HCl were closely related to P results using diluted Klean Strip (R² = 0.96) and Sunnyside (R² = 0.84) HCl. In Experiment 2, two commercial brands of H₂SO₄ acid used to refill car battery cells were evaluated. Test results suggested that the battery H₂SO₄ acids are not suitable for making color development solution. In Experiment 3, a small battery powered spectrometer for P testing aquarium water was calibrated for soils. Samples from the Soil Science Society of America –North American Proficiency Testing program (NAPT) were tested with the meter and non-reagent HCl. Fiske-Subbarrow reducing agent and HCl were used in a variation procedure which does not require H₂SO₄ for color development. Eight of 10 samples tested proficient based on NAPT limits (2.5 x Median Absolute Deviation).