Physiological recovery of freezer-stored white and Engelmann spruce seedlings planted following different thawing regimes

Logistic problems of large-scale reforestation necessitate freezer-storage of conifer seedlings. Frozen stock is typically thawed slowly at low temperatures for up to several weeks before shipping to the plantation site, but the necessity of this practice is questionable. Experiments were conducted to study effects of different thawing regimes on photosynthetic recovery, frost hardiness, water relations and growth initiation in interior spruce (white spruce (Picea glauca (Moench) Voss) and Engelmann spruce (Picea engelmannii Parry) hybrid complex). One year-old container-grown seedlings were planted after 9 days post-storage thawing at 5–15 °C or still frozen, directly from the freezer. During a 29 day observation period after planting, both groups showed changes in xylem water potential (_w), carbon fixation (A), stomatal conductance (g _s ), chlorophyll a fluorescence and xanthophyll cycle pigments. Treatment differences in fluorescence and pigments peaked within one hour after planting. All differences in _w, A, g _s , ratio of internal to external CO₂ concentration (C_i/C_a), fluorescence, pigments and root number disappeared after 5 to 8 days. Terminal bud burst occurred 2.6 days earlier in the pre-thawed seedlings. When seedlings were rapidly thawed in the dark at 21 °C they achieved maximum _w (–0.2 MPa) in 3–4 hour. When evaluated 45 min after planting, A, g _s , C_i/C_a and fluorescence values of rapidly thawed seedlings were intermediate between those for seedlings planted frozen or after 9 days slow thawing, showing that the recovery process was well underway a few hours after removal from the freezer. These results suggested that a suitable on-site operational protocol for rapid thawing might be to lay frozen bundles on the ground at ambient temperature overnight. In field trials of this method, rapidly thawed seedlings broke bud 3.3 days later than slowly thawed stock and also had greater frost hardiness at time of planting. Height, shoot and root mass did not differ after 3 months growth.