Effect of calcium carbonate as determined by lime requirement buffer pH methods on soil characteristics and yield of sorghum plants

Abstract

A primary limit to crop production in extended regions of northern Greece is the infertility of acid soils, especially nutrient element unavailability or toxicity. An experiment was conducted to determine under greenhouse conditions which buffer pH method selected in a previous laboratory experiment is best suited to predict the lime requirement (LR) of acid soils which is most appropriate in relation to plant growth and nutrient element uptake of sorghum plants. The lime needs of three naturally occurring acid soils were estimated by three methods: Adams‐Evans (AE), Shoemaker‐McLean‐Pratt single buffer (SMP‐SB), New Woodruff (NWOOD), and the calcium hydroxide Ca(OH)₂] equilibration procedure. Two greenhouse experiments were conducted: (i) Experiment I during the 1996 season with ORESTIAS a sandy loam soil, and (ii) Experiment II during 1997 and 1998 season with XANTHI a loam sandy soil and DRAMA a sandy clay loam soil, respectively. The following results were obtained. Differences were noticed between the soils as well as within the LR methods. The ORESTIAS soil needed 63% more calcium carbonate (CaCO₃) than the XANTHI soil and 70% more than DRAMA soil to achieve the target pH. Among the three LR methods, results showed that in two of the three soils the highest LRs were determined by the NWOOD and the lowest by the Ca(OH)₂ methods. After six weeks of incubation, no one method gave exactly the needed amounts of CaCO to achieve the target pH, the estimated amounts being mostly higher than tiiat needed except for the DRAMA soil. Among the methods, in general the SMP‐SB method predicted lime rates that raised the soil pH nearest to the target pH and the NWOOD soil seemed to be the more consistent for the three soils. The smallest LRs were predicted by the Ca(OH) method. Based upon plant production and nitrogen (N) uptake in the 1996 season, the shoot yields were significantly higher using the SMP‐SB method and lower with the NWOOD method. Similar results were obtained for the XANTHI and DRAMA soils during the 1997 season. On the contrary in the 1998 season (2nd experimental year), the highest yields were obtained with the NWOOD buffer method. For the 1996 and 1997 seasons, tissue N concentrations were partly significantly higher using the SMP‐SB method. In the 1998 vegetation period, the N concentrations were low and the control plants had significantly higher N contents.