N2O emissions and product ratios of nitrification and denitrification as affected by freezing and thawing

Agricultural soils contribute significantly to atmospheric nitrous oxide (N₂O). A considerable part of the annual N₂O emission may occur during the cold season, possibly supported by high product ratios in denitrification (N₂O/(N₂+N₂O)) and nitrification (N₂O-N/(NO₃⁻-N+NO₂⁻-N)) at low temperatures and/or in response to freeze-thaw perturbation. Water-soluble organic materials released from frost-sensitive catch crops and green manure may further increase winter emissions. We conducted short-term laboratory incubations under standardized moisture and oxygen (O₂) conditions, using nitrogen (N) tracers (¹⁵N) to determine process rates and sources of emitted N₂O after freeze-thaw treatment of soil or after addition of freeze-thaw extract from clover. Soil respiration and N₂O production was stimulated by freeze-thaw or addition of plant extract. The N₂O emission response was inversely related to O₂ concentration, indicating denitrification as the quantitatively prevailing process. Denitrification product ratios in the two studied soils (pH 4.5 and 7.0) remained largely unaltered by freeze-thaw or freeze-thaw-released plant material, refuting the hypothesis that high winter emissions are due to frost damage of N₂O reductase activity. Nitrification rates estimated by nitrate (NO₃⁻) pool enrichment were 1.5-1.8 μg NO₃-N g⁻¹ dw soil d⁻¹ in freeze-thaw-treated soil when incubated at O₂ concentrations above 2.3 vol% and one order of magnitude lower at 0.8 vol% O₂. Thus, the experiments captured a situation with severely O₂-limited nitrification. As expected, the O₂ stress at 0.8 vol% resulted in a high nitrification product ratio (0.3 g g⁻¹). Despite this high product ratio, only 4.4% of the measured N₂O accumulation originated from nitrification, reaffirming that denitrification was the main N₂O source at the various tested O₂ concentrations in freeze-thaw-affected soil. N₂O emission response to both freeze-thaw and plant extract addition appeared strongly linked to stimulation of carbon (C) respiration, suggesting that freeze-thaw-induced release of decomposable organic C was the major driving force for N₂O emissions in our soils, both by fuelling denitrifiers and by depleting O₂. The soluble C (applied as plant extract) necessary to induce a CO₂ and N₂O production rate comparable with that of freeze-thaw was 20-30 μg C g⁻¹ soil dw. This is in the range of estimates for over-winter soluble C loss from catch crops and green manure plots reported in the literature. Thus, freeze-thaw-released organic C from plants may play a significant role in freeze-thaw-related N₂O emissions.