Comparison of NH4 pool dilution techniques to measure gross N fluxes in a coarse textured soil

We compared gross N fluxes by ¹⁵N pool dilution in a coarse-textured agricultural soil when ¹⁵N was applied to the soil NH₄⁺ pool by either: (i) mixing a ¹⁵NH₄NO₃ solution into disturbed soil or (ii) injection of ¹⁵NH₃ gas into intact soil cores. The two techniques produced similar results for gross N mineralization rates indicating that NH₄⁺ production in soil was not altered by soil disturbance, method of application (gas vs. solution), or amount of N applied. This was not the case for immobilization rates, which were twofold higher when ¹⁵N label was applied to the soil NH₄⁺ pool with the mixing technique compared to the injection technique. This was attributed to the fact that more NH₄⁺ was applied with the mixing technique. Estimates of gross nitrification were accompanied by large error terms meaning differences between ¹⁵N labeling methods could not be accurately assessed for this process rate.