Somaclonal selection in potato for resistance to common scab provides concurrent resistance to powdery scab

Variant somaclones of potato cultivar Russet Burbank, selected for resistance to common scab using in vitro cell selection techniques, were tested for resistance to powdery scab, another important disease of potato caused by Spongospora subterranea. This pathogen also invades roots, producing root galls. Most variants consistently showed increased resistance to powdery scab, both in field and glasshouse challenge, when compared to the parental cultivar, several significantly so. On average, the best variant reduced powdery scab incidence by 51% and severity (tuber surface coverage) by 64%. In contrast, no improvement in the extent of root infection and root galling was seen. These results suggest host interactions during root and tuber infection are distinct. Correlation analyses of disease indices amongst the selected variants showed no association between Sp. subterranea root infection and gall scores, nor between root infection and tuber disease severity. However, a weak positive association was found between root gall score and tuber disease, and a strong correlation between tuber disease incidence and severity scores. Interestingly, positive correlations were also found between the extent of powdery and common scab resistance expressed and both incidence and severity of these diseases within the variants, suggesting a common defence mechanism. The role of thaxtomin A in selecting for concurrent resistance to both diseases is discussed.     

Spongospora subterranea root infection assessed in two potato cultivars differing in susceptibility to tuber powdery scab

Infection by Spongospora subterranea of roots of two potato (Solanum tuberosum) cultivars, either very resistant or very susceptible to powdery scab on their tubers, was studied in a glasshouse experiment. Plants grown in sand/nutrient solution culture were inoculated with S. subterranea sporosori 2 weeks after planting. Plant parameters, the intensity of zoosporangium infection in roots, numbers of Spongospora root galls and amounts of Spongospora DNA in roots, measured using quantitative PCR (qPCR), were assessed at sequential harvests. Inoculation with S. subterranea reduced water use (56 days after planting) by 26% in the tuber resistant cultivar compared with uninoculated plants, and by 60% in the susceptible cultivar. Inoculation did not affect growth of the resistant cultivar, nor shoot mass of the susceptible cultivar, but caused a 38% reduction in root mass of the susceptible cultivar. The intensities of zoosporangium development in both cultivars were similar. The susceptible cultivar had approximately four times more Spongospora root galls g^?1 root mass than the resistant cultivar. Quantitative PCR detected S. subterranea DNA in roots 1 week after inoculation, and indicated a twofold greater amount of pathogen DNA in roots of the susceptible than the resistant cultivar. This study suggests that the S. subterranea zoosporangium stage in host roots is affected differently by host resistance factors than the sporosorus (root gall and tuber scab) stages. The study has also demonstrated the usefulness of qPCR for sensitive and consistent detection of S. subterranea across the duration of potato root infection.     

The potential for the Rapid Screening of Potato Cultivars (Solanum tuberosum) for Resistance to Powdery Scab (Spongospora subterranea) using a Laboratory Bioassay

Powdery scab of potato, once established in a field, is difficult to control because of the longevity of the resting spores (cystosori) of the causal organism, Spongospora subterranea f.sp. subterranea. Host resistance is likely to be the most efficient in a long-term control strategy for preventing build-up of field inoculum and spread of the disease. Resistance screening of potato cultivars is mostly done in laborious field trials where disease development is likely to be unpredictable. A bioassay with potato tissue cultured plantlets and cystosori as inoculum is described and was tested for its potential to screen potato cultivars at an early stage for their relative susceptibility to powdery scab by comparing the lab results with field data. With cystosori inoculum of Swiss origin, the laboratory test showed clear differences between the potato cultivars in the severity of zoosporangial root infection which correlated better with ranked tuber infection data, compared to root galling. There are apparent differences in the relative trends in susceptibility between roots and tubers of five selected cultivars when using naturally infested soil instead of prepared cystosori as inoculum in the lab bioassay. Furthermore, differences in the severity of zoosporangial root infection of two selected cultivars were found when cystosori from different countries where used as inoculum. A possible host genotype × pathogen interaction is discussed. The bioassay has the potential to screen and select for resistant material at an early breeding stage thus making field trials not unnecessary but more economical. It will allow the use of a standard set of pathogen collections and facilitate testing for inoculum virulence in infested soils.     

Powdery scab resistance in Solanum tuberosum: an assessment of cultivar × environment effect

Powdery scab of potato caused by Spongospora subterranea is one of the main disease problems in many potato production regions of the world. However, no efficient and economically sound control method is currently available. Host resistance will be a key component of the integrated management of powdery scab, but there are discrepancies in published powdery scab resistance ratings of cultivars between countries. In order to identify the main factors causing such discrepancies, 10 reference cultivars thought to have a range of susceptibility to powdery scab and potato mop‐top virus were cropped over 4 years in four to six locations across Europe and disease levels on roots and tubers were assessed using standardized scoring scales. Soil contamination was tested using real‐time PCR and ELISA. The cultivars performed as expected according to previous characterization, with one exception. No relationship was found between tuber and root susceptibility. Assessment of powdery scab symptoms 1 month before harvest gave results comparable to those assessed 2 months after harvest. Neither real‐time PCR nor ELISA soil test results were closely related to disease index data. The field trial results indicate that different scoring methods are the main factor for the discrepancy in resistance ratings, and that environmental conditions and/or soil inoculum level play a minor role. Furthermore, there was either no difference between the pathogen populations in each location or the resistance of most of the cultivars is polygenic.     

Identification of differentially expressed genes in tolerant and susceptible potato cultivars in response to Spongospora subterranea f. sp. subterranea tuber infection

Powdery scab caused by Spongospora subterranea f. sp. subterranea (Sss) has recently become one of the most devastating potato diseases of economic importance in South Africa. The use of resistant cultivars has long been considered the most effective and sustainable strategy to manage the pathogen. However, little is known about the molecular mechanisms underlying resistance of potato tubers to Sss. Using RNA-sequencing (RNA-seq), 2058 differentially expressed genes (DEGs) were identified from two potato cultivars (tolerant and susceptible) in response to Sss infection. Analysis of the expression patterns of 10 selected defence-response genes was carried out at two different stages of tuber growth using RT-qPCR to validate the RNA-seq data. Several defence-related genes showed contrasting expression patterns between the tolerant and susceptible cultivars, including marker genes involved in the salicylic acid hormonal response pathway (StMRNA, StUDP and StWRKY6). Induction of six defence-related genes (StWRKY6, StTOSB, StSN2, StLOX, StUDP and StSN1) persisted until harvest of the tubers, while three other genes (StNBS, StMRNA and StPRF) were highly up-regulated during the initial stages of disease development. The results of this preliminary study suggest that the tolerant potato cultivar employs quantitative resistance and salicylic acid pathway hormonal responses against tuber infection by Sss. The identified genes have the potential to be used in the development of molecular markers for selection of powdery scab resistant potato lines in marker-assisted breeding programmes.     

Biocontrol of powdery scab of potato by seed tuber application of an antagonistic fungus, <Emphasis Type="Italic">Aspergillus versicolor</Emphasis>, isolated from potato roots

An environmentally friendly measure to control potato powdery scab caused by a protozoan pathogen Spongospora subterranea f.sp. subterranea (Sss) was developed by focusing on antagonistic microorganisms that were considered compatible with potato root. Five hundred and eight soil fungi, isolated from potato root cultivated in soil suspensions from four potato fields in Hokkaido, were screened for suppressiveness of root infection by Sss in a hydroponic culture system and for powdery scab severity in greenhouse and field experiments. Antagonistic isolate Im6-50, identified as Aspergillus versicolor, was selected as a potent biological control agent. In a 3-year field test, A. versicolor Im6-50 suppressed powdery scab with a protection value of 54–70 (100?=?complete protection) when applied directly on seed tubers compared with a protection value of 77–93 by the synthetic fungicide fluazinam. A. versicolor Im6-50 was detected from the surface of daughter tubers and from the soil in which the inoculated seed tubers were cultivated by PCR using species-specific primers. The establishment of A. versicolor Im6-50 on the stolon of inoculated potato plants and in the rhizosphere is considered to contribute to the mechanism for disease suppression.     

Prevalence of fungal and fungus‐like diseases on potato seed tubers imported from Europe to Jordan

A total of 109 samples of potato seed tubers imported to Jordan from France, Netherlands and Denmark during the 2007/2008 growing seasons were surveyed for 10 different diseases caused by fungi and fungus‐like organisms to determine the prevalence of different tuberborne diseases and to evaluate the efficacy of the current visual examination procedures in detecting different potato diseases. The results demonstrated that most potato seed tuber lots imported to Jordan were infected with one or more of the following potato pests: Colletotrichum coccodes (black dot) (66.0%), Rhizoctonia solani (black scurf) (42.4%), Helminthosporium solani (silver scurf) (92.6%), and Spongospora subterranea (powdery scab) (13.8%). Just over a quarter (25.7%) of all lots examined in this study were found to exceed the acceptance limits for one or more potato diseases according to the Jordanian standards. This study suggests that the current visual examination procedure is not adequate to detect all tuberborne diseases of potato and to estimate their incidence and severity precisely.     

Prevalence and distribution of Potato mop‐top virus in Scotland

This study was undertaken to determine the current occurrence in Scottish seed potato crops of Potato mop‐top virus (PMTV), which is transmitted by Spongospora subterranea and causes spraing (brown arcs and lines) in the flesh of potato tubers, rendering them unsaleable. In 2004, a stratified survey of four commonly grown cultivars was conducted, while in 2007 and 2008, only samples from powdery scab‐affected crops were collected. The incidence of crops in which infection by PMTV was present was 37·5% in the stratified survey in 2004, but was greater in surveys in which tubers with powdery scab were tested (47·2% in 2007 and 44·6% in 2008). Similarly, the frequency of crops with incidences of more than 10% tuber infection was lower (9·4%) in 2004 than in 2007 (25·4%) and in 2008 (26·2%). Significant differences in crop infection were found amongst the four major seed‐producing regions and the counties within these regions. The incidence of crop and tuber infection was least for class Pre‐basic seed potatoes and greatest for class Super Elite 3 and Elite seed potatoes. The results indicate that the prevalence of PMTV has not increased since surveys in the early 1970s.     

A comparison of potato seed-tuber sampling strategies using visual and DNA analyses to estimate incidence of major seed tuber-borne pathogens

Potato seed certification is a disease management tool that minimises the risk of spreading seed tuber-borne inoculum of infectious diseases. Traditionally, certification sampling strategies have relied upon visual assessment of a seedlot from samples taken at one or two points within the load of seed tubers. However methodologies in selection of tuber samples have not been critically assessed for their precision in estimating disease load. This study presents an analysis of 37 potato seedlots over a 3 year period. Analysis of sample data using receiver operating curves (ROCs) indicates that point sampling taking two samples of 100 tubers at the beginning and end of a seedlot gives equivalent disease estimation as a continuous sampling strategy taking ten samples of 20 tubers randomly throughout the seedlot, although at lower statistical precision. This was confirmed both by visual assessment of tuber-borne disease and by analysis of pathogen DNA content from tuber peel. Across the 3 years of study, powdery scab and black scurf were the major seed tuber-borne diseases recognised and this corresponded with high levels of pathogen DNA from peel analysis for both Spongospora subterranea and Rhizoctonia solani AG3 respectively.     

<Emphasis Type="Italic">Spongospora subterranea</Emphasis> soil contamination and its relationship to severity of powdery scab on potatoes

We investigated soil contamination by Spongospora subterranea f. sp. subterranea (Sss) and disease severity of powdery scab in 29 potato fields in Hokkaido, Japan, using a hydroponic culture method with tomato seedlings as bait plants. The quantity of Sss infection on the roots of bait plants was evaluated using the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and expressed in terms of the infection potential in the soil. The infection potential was positively correlated with the disease severity of harvested tubers, whereas the spore ball density determined using PCR had an indistinct relationship with disease severity. The infection potential can be useful in evaluating soil contamination and in applying countermeasures against powdery scab.     

Effect of temperature on the transmission of Potato mop-top virus from seed tuber and by its vector, Spongospora subterranea

Potato mop-top virus (PMTV) causes disease in both the growing plant and tubers (spraing) of potato and is transmitted by the plasmodiophorid Spongospora subterranea , the cause of powdery scab. The effect of temperature during plant growth on the transmission of PMTV from infected seed tubers and from infested growing media was investigated in a series of glasshouse experiments. Symptoms developed on foliage of plants derived from infected seed tubers but none developed when PMTV was transmitted by S. subterranea in soil. The incidence of foliar symptoms was greatest on plants grown at 12°C, less at 16°C, few at 20°C and absent at 24°C. The transmission of PMTV from infected seed tubers was not significantly affected by temperatures between 12 and 24°C, but when the virus was transmitted by S. subterranea , minimal tuber infection occurred at 24°C and no differences were recorded at temperatures between 12 and 20°C. The incidence of powdery scab on tubers was greatest at 12 and 16°C and very low at 20 and 24°C. However, the incidence and severity of root galling caused by S. subterranea , was greatest at 20 and very low at 24°C. The incidence of powdery scab was greater on tubers of plants derived from infected seed tubers grown in a fluctuating temperature regime of 12 h at 20°C followed by 24 h at 12°C than on those grown at a constant 20°C, whereas the incidence of tuber infection by PMTV and spraing was similar for both regimes. This demonstrates that infection of roots can occur at a higher temperature than that for powdery scab on tubers and that this root infection can enable the transmission of PMTV into the potato plant.     

The importance of the infected seed tuber and soil inoculum in transmitting Potato mop‐top virus to potato plants

Potato mop‐top virus (PMTV), the cause of spraing in potato tubers, is transmitted by Spongospora subterranea, the cause of powdery scab, and by planting infected seed tubers. This study was undertaken to determine the relative importance of these sources of infection in seed potato production in Scotland. The transmission of PMTV from tested seed tubers to daughter plants was examined over 2 years and six cultivars. The development of foliar symptoms varied with year and cultivar. Infection of daughter tubers derived from PMTV‐infected seed tubers was more prevalent on plants affected by foliar symptoms than those without symptoms. The rate of transmission of PMTV from infected seed tubers to daughter tubers ranged from 18 to 54%. Transmission was affected by cultivar and by origin of seed tubers used for a cultivar, but not by a cultivar's sensitivity to PMTV infection. The incidence of PMTV in daughter tubers of cv. Cara grown from seed potatoes from one source (common origin) by more than 25 seed producers was examined over two successive generations. The incidence of PMTV in daughter tubers was not correlated with that in the seed tubers but appeared to be strongly associated with soil inoculum. The incidence of PMTV was correlated with powdery scab in those crops in which both were present. There was some evidence from soil tests conducted in 2006 using a tomato bait plant and real‐time RT‐PCR that planting PMTV‐infected seed potatoes could increase the risk of introducing the virus into land not infested by PMTV.     

Evaluation of the <Emphasis Type="BoldItalic">Sss</Emphasis> AgriStrip rapid diagnostic test for the detection of <Emphasis Type="BoldItalic">Spongospora subterranea</Emphasis> on potato tubers

Spongospora subterranea, f.sp. subterranea (Sss), which causes powdery scab, is mainly spread through infected seed tubers and survives in contaminated soil for many years. The visual assessment of tuber lots by inspectors carries the risk of misidentification due to the difficulty of distinguishing lesions caused by either Sss or Streptomyces spp.. To avoid this, the “Sss AgriStrip”, a rapid and lab-independent test tool based on a lateral flow immunoassay has been developed, and we assessed its accuracy and sensitivity for detecting Sss. The Sss AgriStrip performed as well as other lab-based identification methods. The Sss AgriStrip, microscopy, ELISA, PCR, and real-time PCR techniques identified infection with S. subterranea in all tubers with typical powdery scab lesions. When lots with tubers showing a mixture of typical and atypical (suspicious) symptoms were tested, the presence of S. subterranea was confirmed in all lesions by all methods. The DNA content was generally lower in atypical than in typical lesions. Diverse and suspicious symptoms, which were difficult to assign to either powdery or common scab, tested negative with Sss AgriStrip and the other methods. This was despite microscopic observation of sporosori-like structures in some samples. Isolation and molecular identification confirmed that these lesions were mostly caused by Streptomyces spp. The Sss AgriStrip is as sensitive as DAS-ELISA with a detection limit between 1 and 10 sporosori per ml buffer. It is ideal for rapid and selective detection of Sss on farms and border inspection points to prevent spread of the pathogen.     

Detection and Quantification of Spongospora subterranea in Soil, Water and Plant Tissue Samples Using Real-Time PCR

A sensitive real-time polymerase chain reaction (PCR) assay was developed for the quantification of Spongospora subterranea, the cause of powdery scab and root galling in potato, and the vector of Potato mop top virus. A specific primer pair and a fluorogenic TaqMan® probe were designed to perform a quantitative assay for the detection of S. subterranea in soil, water and plant tissue samples. The assay was tested using DNA from cystosori, zoospores, plasmodia and zoosporangia of the pathogen. DNA was extracted directly from cystosori suspended in water and from clay soil with varying levels of added cystosori. DNA obtained from zoospores released into nutrient solution by cystosori in the presence of tomato bait plants was also tested, as was DNA from plasmodia and zoosporangia in infected tomato roots. In many cases, detection was successful even at low inoculum levels. This specific quantitative assay could therefore be a useful tool for studying the biology of S. subterranea, and for the optimisation of disease avoidance and control measures.     

Relationship between Spongospora subterranea f. sp. subterranea soil inoculum level,host resistance and powdery scab on potato tubers in the field

The relationship between initial soil inoculum level of Spongospora subterranea f. sp. subterranea (Sss) and the incidence and severity of powdery scab on potato tubers at harvest was investigated. In all experiments soil inoculum level of Sss (sporeballs/g soil) was measured using a quantitative real‐time PCR assay. Of 113 commercial potato fields across the UK, soil inoculum was detected in 75%, ranging from 0 to 148 Sss sporeballs/g soil. When arbitrary soil inoculum threshold values of 0, <10 and >10 sporeballs/g soil were set, it was observed that the number of progeny crops developing powdery scab increased with the level of inoculum quantified in the field soil preplanting. In four field trials carried out to investigate the link between the amount of inoculum added to the soil and disease development, disease incidence and severity on progeny tubers was found to be significantly (P < 0·01) greater in plots with increasing levels of inoculum incorporated. There was a cultivar effect in all years, with disease incidence and severity scores being significantly greater in cvs Agria and Estima than in Nicola (P < 0·01).     

Detection of the root lesion nematode Pratylenchus penetrans in potato tubers

The root lesion nematode Pratylenchus penetrans parasitizes a wide range of economically important crops, including potato (Solanum tuberosum). Damage by P. penetrans impacts not only the potato yield but can also reduce the tuber quality. Detailed information on tuber infection by P. penetrans is scarce for most cultivars and molecular detection of nematodes from infected tubers is needed. The objective of this study was to assess tuber symptomatology due to P. penetrans infection in 10 potato cultivars and to provide an accurate molecular methodology for nematode detection using tuber peels. Sprouts of certified potato seed from cultivars Agata, Agria, Camel, Désirée, Dirosso, Kennebec, Laura, Picasso, Royata, and Stemster were planted in 2 L pots, and soil was inoculated with 4 P. penetrans/g of soil. Sixty days after inoculation, tubers were harvested, inspected for lesions, and the number of nematodes/g of potato peel assessed. Observations of tubers with symptoms showed the presence of P. penetrans in superficial layers of peels around the lenticels and injured necrotic tissue. Different nematode stages were detected in tubers of all inoculated cultivars, varying from 4 to 46 nematodes/g of potato peel. Species-specific primers showed suitable sensitivity and reproducibility for the detection of P. penetrans in tuber potato peel samples. The molecular detection of P. penetrans directly from tuber peels can facilitate routine nematode inspections of potato seed tubers or cull potatoes for nematode detection, and prevent further dissemination of this species.     

Improved immunological detection of S<Emphasis Type="Italic">pongospora subterranea</Emphasis>

The genus Spongospora has two members which are important pathogens of vegetables, S. subterranea f.sp. subterranea (Sss) and S. subterranea f.sp. nasturtii (Ssn). The close taxonomic relationship of these formae speciales is based on similar cystosori morphology. The potato disease powdery scab, caused by Sss, is difficult to control. The key control measure is avoidance, aimed at planting clean seed in clean soil. For the development of routine tests for the presence of the pathogen on tubers and in soil, a monoclonal antibody (MAb) was developed using Sss cystosori as immunogen. It detected less than one Sss cystosorus and recognised Sss material from many parts of the world. No cross-reactions with other Plasmodiophoromycetes including Plasmodiophora brassicae, Polymyxa betae, Polymyxa graminis and different Streptomyces species causing common and netted scab of potatoes were observed. A novel tuber sample test method was developed using a kitchen peeling machine. This detected two tubers with one powdery scab lesion each in a sample including eighteen uninfected tubers. When soil samples spiked with cystosori were tested with the MAb, different Sss infestation levels could be discriminated. Ssn cystosori gave absorbance values in ELISA as high as Sss cystosori, whereas fresh crook roots of watercress containing Ssnzoosporangia and plasmodia or mud from an Ssninfected watercress bed gave low absorbance values or no reaction. The potential of these findings for the development of a disease control management are discussed.     

Effect of soil inoculum level and environmental factors on potato powdery scab caused by Spongospora subterranea

The effects of soil inoculum level and three environmental factors (soil type, soil moisture regime and temperature) on the incidence and severity of powdery scab caused by Spongospora subterranea were investigated in potato plants grown under controlled environmental conditions. Symptoms of powdery scab on tubers were assessed visually, after which DNA was extracted from tuber peelings and quantified in a real-time polymerase chain reaction assay using primers and a TaqMan® probe specific to S. subterranea to establish tuber infection levels. Soil inoculum concentration of S. subterranea did not significantly affect the incidence and severity of either tuber infection or powdery scab symptoms at maturity. No significant differences in disease incidence and severity were found between sandy, loamy and clay soils, although the two lighter soils yielded more powdery scab than clay soil. Constant dampness of the soil resulted in significantly more disease than a fluctuating moisture regime. Infection and disease levels were high at all three temperatures tested (9, 12 and 17°C), but symptoms were most severe at 12°C. The percentage of plants with infected tubers did not increase after tuber initiation, although the amount of S. subterranea DNA detected in tubers and the severity of powdery scab symptoms increased in mature plants. Latent tuber infections were found to be common, especially under conditions suboptimal for disease development. This new information may be important for the prevention of powdery scab in potato-growing areas around the world.     

PCR-based determination of colonization patterns during potato tuber infection by single and multiple pathogens

Potato tubers piled in storage are prone to infection by numerous pathogens. Each pathogen can cause damage alone, but severe losses often arise when more than one pathogen is involved. Currently, only a visual diagnosis is practiced on potato tubers before storing them, which does not allow any prediction of further disease spread. The aim of the present study was to determine differences in patterns of tissue colonization by several tuber decay pathogens and how late blight infection affects further tuber colonization by other important tuber pathogens. This study was conducted using artificial inoculation of potato tubers and PCR to provide an early and accurate diagnosis of disease development for major potato tuber rots, and to assess potential synergism/antagonism between Phytophthora infestans and other pathogens in stored tubers. In order to accurately follow the progress of each pathogen in tuber tissues, samples were collected over time from both the surface (peel, 0–2 mm depth) and internal tissues (flesh, depth > 2 mm) of the tubers at various distances from the inoculation site, at 3, 5, 7, 10, 12, 14, 17, and 19 days after inoculation. Successful detection of single or multiple pathogens was achieved using specific PCR-primers for each pathogen. Pathogens were always detected several centimeters ahead of the visible lesions. This tracking enabled us to determine the extent of colonization both on the tuber’s surface and in internal tissues by each tested pathogen, either after single or multiple infections involving P. infestans as the primary pathogen. The presence of P. infestans was shown to enhance the development of Pectobacterium atrosepticum and to slow down that of P. erythrospetica and Pythium ultimum. No noticeable effect on further tuber colonization by F. sambucinum, V. dahliae or V. albo-atrum was observed in the presence of P. infestans. This approach involving more than one pathogen is more realistic than classical studies considering single pathogens, and may be helpful in monitoring the sanitary status of stored tubers. Our results make the outcome of certain combinations of pathogens in potato tubers more predictable and may result in more efficient preventive measures.