Development of apothecia ofTapesia yallundae in contrasting populations selected by fungicides

Apothecia of the eyespot fungus,Tapesia yallundae, were found on 0–18% of straws in plots of wheat stubble in February–March 1994. The fungicides carbendazim, prochloraz or carbendazim plus prochloraz had been applied repeatedly to the same plots in each of the previous 9 years in which successive wheat crops had been grown. The factors most strongly correlated with the incidence of apothecia were the incidence and severity of eyespot in the preceding wheat crop and the frequency of carbendazim-resistant W-type fungus in populations recovered from that wheat crop. Plots treated with carbendazim, which had previously had more disease and more resistance to carbendazim in the pathogen population relative to untreated plots, therefore yielded most apothecia. Plots treated with prochloraz, which had selected for predominantly R-type fungus and decreased eyespot, yielded few apothecia. Single-ascospore isolates were all of the W-type and were more frequently carbendazim-sensitive than expected, except those from plots treated only with carbendazim. None showed decreased sensitivity to prochloraz. The implications of applying fungicides regularly for controlling eyespot on the capability of the eyespot fungus for genetic variation through sexual reproduction are discussed.     

Survey of benomyl resistance in Pseudocercosporella herpotrichoides on winter wheat and barley in England and Wales in 1983

Surveys of 528 randomly selected commercial fields in England and Wales in 1983 showed that isolates of Pseudocercosporella herpotrichoides resistant to benomyl were common and widespread on winter wheat and winter barley. During June and July resistant strains were recovered from 16 to 66% of fields and the proportion of resistant isolates was 37–52%. The frequency of occurrence of resistant isolates was positively correlated with the number of applications of carbendazimgenerating (MBC) fungicides during the previous 8 years. Benomyl resistance was found in 21–48% of fields where it was claimed that MBC had never been used, and 7–28% of isolates from those fields, were resistant. Resistance was more frequent in R-type than in W-type isolates of the pathogen. The proportion of R-type isolates decreased as the number of previous winter wheat crops rose and increased with the number of winter barley crops grown and with the number of MBC sprays applied to crops in previous years. The implications of these findings for the control of eyespot in England and Wales are discussed.     

Sensitivity of Pseudoeevcosporella herpotriehoides to the fungicide prochloraz

In a survey carried out in 1984, isolates of the eyespot fungus, Pseudocercosporella herpotrichoides , from cereals in the UK, Denmark and West Germany were tested in vitro for sensitivity to the fungicide prochloraz. Of 194 isolates tested, 191 showed no growth on agar amended with prochloraz at 2 μg/ml or more. The mean concentration of prochloraz calculated to inhibit colony growth by 50% (IG50) was 0 44+0−010 μg/ml. The three isolates that grew at 2 μg/ml displayed weak colony development and were clearly disrupted by the presence of the fungicide. R-type isolates appeared more sensitive to prochloraz than W-type isolates. Comparisons with similar data for isolates obtained from other years revealed no consistent change with time in sensitivity to prochloraz.     

Benzimidazole resistance in Pseudocercosporella herpotrichoides: results of ADAS random surveys and fungicide trials in England and Wales, 1982–19841

Surveys of 59 and 528 randomly selected winter wheat and winter barley crops in 1982 and 1983 respectively, showed that benzimidazole-resistant strains of the eyespot fungus (Pseudocercosporella herpotrichoides) were common and widespread. The frequency of occurrence of resistant isolates, both in 1982 and 1983. was positively correlated with the number of benzimidazole fungicide applications since 1975. Resistance was much more frequent in R-type than in W-type strains of P. herpotrichoides. Fungicides or fungicide mixtures, applied to winter wheat at growth stage (GS) 31, were compared for control of eyespot at six sites in 1983 and one in 1984 where benzimidazole-resistant strains were readily detected prior to spraying. Carbendazim alone gave no control of eyespot and in some trials actually increased disease levels compared with the unsprayed control. Prochloraz, either alone or in mixture with carbendazim, was the most effective fungicide giving a moderate control of eyespot (33–42% reduction) and cost-effective yield increases. DPX-II6573, tested only in the 1984 trial, was as effective as prochloraz. The practical implications of these findings are discussed.     

Changes in populations of the eyespot fungi Tapesia yallundae and T. acuformis under different fungicide regimes in successive crops of winter wheat, 1984–2000

Effects of regular treatments with the fungicides carbendazim and prochloraz applied to whole plots divided into subplots with different initial population mixtures of carbendazim-sensitive or carbendazim-resistant Tapesia yallundae or T. acuformis were studied in successive crops of winter wheat from 1984/85 to 1999/2000. In unsprayed and carbendazim-sprayed whole plots, a stable coexistence of about 50% each of T. yallundae and T. acuformis developed within five seasons, but in whole plots sprayed with prochloraz or prochloraz plus carbendazim, the proportion of T. acuformis increased to > 80%. A discrete time difference equation model was derived from knowledge of the biology of eyespot and competition theory to describe the population changes. The model was fitted to the data from treatments where coexistence occurred [subplots in unsprayed (1985–92) and carbendazim-sprayed (1985–89) whole plots], using nonlinear least squares regression. The optimized value of the resource overlap coefficient was small, suggesting niche differences between the two species. Populations were nearly 100% carbendazim-resistant in carbendazim-sprayed whole plots by July 1985 (one season) and in whole plots sprayed with prochloraz plus carbendazim by July 1986 (two seasons). In prochloraz-sprayed whole plots, the proportion of carbendazim-resistant isolates decreased more rapidly than in unsprayed whole plots in the 1980s, but by July 1992 a shift in populations in unsprayed and prochloraz-sprayed whole plots towards predominantly carbendazim-resistant strains had occurred.     

2017年-2021年江苏省小麦赤霉病菌群体对4种杀菌剂的抗药性监测

为明确江苏省小麦赤霉病菌群体对常用杀菌剂的抗药性情况,本研究于2017年-2021年连续5年分别从苏南、苏北及苏中小麦种植区采集病穗,分离培养获得赤霉病菌菌株共计4 055株,采用区分剂量法测定了供试菌株对4种杀菌剂(多菌灵、氰烯菌酯、戊唑醇和咪鲜胺)的抗性频率。结果表明:2017年-2021年江苏省田间小麦赤霉病菌对多菌灵的抗性频率分别为58.44%、56.30%、44.68%、48.28%、46.39%,呈逐年下降的趋势;不同地区小麦赤霉病菌对多菌灵的抗药性呈现地区差异性,苏北地区对多菌灵的抗性频率最高,其次是苏中地区,抗性频率最低的是苏南地区。2021年首次在田间采集到对氰烯菌酯、戊唑醇和咪鲜胺的抗性菌株,其抗性频率分别为0.45%、0.89%和0.09%,在以上的抗性菌株中同时具有多菌灵抗性的双重抗性菌株。表明江苏省小麦赤霉病菌对氰烯菌酯、戊唑醇和咪鲜胺产生了抗药性,虽抗性频率较低,仍需尽快制定田间抗性治理方案,延缓田间病菌对常用杀菌剂的抗性发展。     

拟轮枝镰孢对多菌灵的敏感性及抗性菌株生物学性状和交互抗性

为评价玉米穗腐病主要致病菌拟轮枝镰孢Fusarium verticillioides对多菌灵的敏感性，采用菌丝生长速率法测定了采自山东、河北、河南、四川、甘肃、辽宁及宁夏7省(自治区)的168株玉米穗腐病拟轮枝镰孢对多菌灵的敏感性，并对经药剂驯化获得的拟轮枝镰孢抗多菌灵菌株主要生物学性状和交互抗性进行了研究。结果表明:多菌灵抑制拟轮枝镰孢菌丝生长的EC₅₀值在0.013 2~0.774 0 mg/L之间，平均EC₅₀值为(0.220 8 ± 0.143 7) mg/L。敏感性频率分布显示，供试病原菌群体中已出现对多菌灵敏感性下降的亚群体，但其中仍有35.71%的菌株对多菌灵的敏感性频率呈正态分布，因此可将此部分菌株的平均EC₅₀值 (0.081 4 ± 0.028 9) mg/L作为拟轮枝镰孢对多菌灵的相对敏感基线。药剂驯化共获得6株抗性菌株，抗性倍数在5.05~12.22之间。抗性菌株的菌丝生长速率及菌丝干重均低于亲本菌株，表明其抗性菌株的生物适合度有所降低，同时发现其抗药性均不能稳定遗传。室内交互抗性测定结果表明，拟轮枝镰孢对多菌灵的抗性与咪鲜胺、戊唑醇、三唑酮及吡唑醚菌酯之间均不存在交互抗性关系。     

中国华北地区瓜类尖孢镰刀菌对咪鲜胺的敏感性及抗药突变株生物学性状研究

为明确中国华北地区瓜类尖孢镰刀菌Fusarium oxysporum Schl.对咪鲜胺的抗药性现状及抗药突变株的生物学性状,采用菌丝生长速率法,分别测定了采自北京、山东、河北等地未使用过咪鲜胺的112株瓜类尖孢镰刀菌对咪鲜胺的敏感性,并通过药剂驯化的方法获得尖孢镰刀菌抗咪鲜胺突变株。结果表明:咪鲜胺对112株瓜类尖孢镰刀菌的平均EC50值为（0.030 1±0.030 4）μg/mL,菌株频率呈连续单峰曲线分布,未发现敏感性明显下降的亚群体,因此,可将该EC50值作为瓜类尖孢镰刀菌对咪鲜胺的敏感基线。药剂驯化共获得7株抗咪鲜胺突变株,其抗性倍数介于6.2~26.8之间;突变株在菌丝生长速率、菌丝干重和致病力等方面均明显低于亲本菌株,差异显著;仅突变株HG13052701-R1的抗药性可以稳定遗传,其他6株抗咪鲜胺突变株的抗药性均不能稳定遗传。室内交互抗性测定结果表明,咪鲜胺仅与戊唑醇之间有交互抗性,与多菌灵和齅霉灵之间均无交互抗性关系。研究表明,瓜类尖孢镰刀菌在药剂选择压下可以形成抗咪鲜胺群体,具有低等抗药性风险。     

Identification of W-type and R-type isolates of Pseudocercosporella herpotrichoides

W-type isolates of Pseudocercosporella herpotrichoides grown on a maize-based agar and exposed to near- ultra-violet radiation at c . 13°C produced a greenish black colour, whilst R-type isolates produced a pink or pale brown colour in the agar medium. More colonies from directly plated lesions or from spore suspensions could be recognized as P. herpotrichoides and could be more easily differentiated as W-type or R-type or as mixtures of both by colour production on maize agar (MA) than by colony morphology on potato dextrose agar (PDA), despite the presence of other fungi. Isolates with intermediate morphology on PDA were positively identified as W-type or R-type on MA; their pathogenicities to wheat and rye seedlings were usually similar to those of W-type or R-type isolates with typical colony morphology, confirming their identification on MA. Drops of mixed suspensions of W-type and R-type spores on PDA formed fast-growing colonies with smooth margins which sometimes had slow-growing sectors with feathery margins. Drops of the same mixtures on MA formed greenish black colonies which sometimes had pink or pale brown sectors. However, when these mixtures were spread onto MA, W-type and R-type colonies could easily be differentiated by colour.     

Resistance Risk Assessment of Cereal Eyespot, Tapesia Yallundae and Tapesia Acuformis, to the Anilinopyrimidine Fungicide, Cyprodinil

Eyespot pathogens, Tapesia yallundae and Tapesia acuformis, were isolated from two trial sites in the UK over several years. Both sites were treated with 2 applications per year of cyprodinil (a new anilinopyrimidine fungicide), prochloraz and a mixture of cyprodinil with prochloraz. One trial site was exposed to cyprodinil for 3 years, and the second for a total of 11 years, including 5 years before the trial was initiated. Control of eyespot and sensitivity to cyprodinil were monitored. During the first 3 years of the trial, disease control with all fungicide treatments ranged from 43% to 82%. At the site, where the trial was extended for a further 3 years, control then began to decline but no practical resistance was detected. The decline in control by both fungicides suggests that factors other than reduced sensitivity might be involved. Field isolates of both T. yallundae and T. acuformis with reduced sensitivity to cyprodinil were found predominantly in plots treated with cyprodinil. A reduction in sensitivity to cyprodinil was identified in the population from cyprodinil-treated plots in two years out of six, and in the population from mixture plots in the final year. No obvious trends could be identified and in-vivo studies showed control of most isolates with reduced sensitivity could be regained by increasing the dose to one tenth of the recommended field rate. Analysis of progeny from sexual crosses involving a sensitive isolate and a field isolate with an ED₅₀ value higher than the baseline sensitivity range indicated that a single gene controlled the reduction in sensitivity to cyprodinil in one T. yallundae isolate. There is clearly a resistance risk in eyespot to cyprodinil. The reduction in sensitivity is monogenic in inheritance and at a significant level in some isolates, but any shift in sensitivity in field populations has so far been gradual.     

Incidence of apothecia of Tapesia yallundae at setaside sites in England and sensitivity of the ascospore offspring to the fungicides benomyl and prochloraz

A total of 45 field sites in England were surveyed once for the presence of apothecia of Tapesia yallundae from 1992 to 1994. Apothecia were found at 21 locations and were mainly present on less than 3% of stems. However, apothecia were found on 1532% of stems at four sites. Analysis of the growth characteristics of ascospore isolates from seven sites showed that most produced colonies characteristic of the W-type of T. yallundae , with only one site yielding the R-type, Most ascospore isolates were resistant to the fungicide benomyl and effectively all remained sensitive to prochloraz. The results of the study are discussed in relation to the fungicidal control and epidemiology of T. yallundae , and the risk of spread of disease from set-aside sites.     

Occurrence of Tapesia yallundae apothecia on field and laboratory-inoculated material and evidence for recombination between isolates

Tapesia yallundae was observed in early July on wheat straws, which had been inoculated with isolates of Pseudocercosporella herpotrichoides (W-type) 9 months previously and placed in plots of winter wheat, to act as inoculum in a resistance screen. A perfect state was not observed on straws inoculated with R-type isolates in the same experiment. One hundred and thirty-four single-ascospore isolates were obtained and observations on morphology in culture, pathogenicity to wheat and rye seedlings, resistance to benomyl and the pattern of restriction fragment length polymorphisms demonstrated that all isolates were W-type, although some grew at half the expected rate on agar, and at least two isolates were involved in the production of apothecia. Apothecia were produced in vitro on straws inoculated with single isolates of P. herpotrichoides only when they were incubated in contact with other straws similarly inoculated with certain other isolates. No apothecia were produced on straws with only isolate present, suggesting the need for at least two strains, possibly representing different mating types, for apothecium formation. Apothecia of T. yallundae were produced in vitro on straw pieces which had been inoculated individually with W-type isolates, 14-16 weeks after straws of different isolates were mixed. Evidence for genetic recombination between isolates was obtained when single-ascopore colonies were analysed for resistance to benomyl in culture and for restriction-length polymorphisms (RFLPs).     

Carbendazim resistance in the eyespot pathogen Pseudocercosporella herpotrichoides

Mycelial isolates (115) of Pseudocercosporella herpotrichoides were obtained from five field sites in England. Carbendazim-resistant isolates were detected by their mycelial growth on agar containing 1 μg/ml carbendazim. Resistant isolates were found at two of the five sites examined and one of these had never been treated with benzimidazole fungicides. Amongst the carbendazim- resistant isolates there was a predominance of isolates with pale mycelium, an irregular colony margin and a relatively slow growth rate; however, this association was not absolute. Large differences in the effects of carbendazim on mycelial growth of sensitive and resistant isolates were demonstrated; growth of sensitive isolates was completely inhibited at 0.5 μg /ml carbendazim whilst five of the six resistant isolates examined grew on agar containing 1000 μg/ml fungicide. The carbendazim-resistant isolates were cross-resistant to benomyl, thiophanate-methyl and to a Icsser degree thiabendazole, but not to prochloraz. Conidia of carbendazim-resistant isolates were as resistant. Carbendazim-resistant isolates were just as pathogenic to wheat as sensitive isolates. The implications of these results and other reports of benzimidazole resistance in P. herpotrichoides are discussed in relation to disease control.     

Development of disease symptoms and fungal pathogens on shoot bases in continuous winter wheat, and effects of fungicides

Field plots in three consecutive crops of winter wheat were sampled at approximately 2-week intervals from April to July in 1989, 1990 and 1991. Culm and stem bases were examined for symptoms of eyespot, sharp eyespot and brown foot rot. The W-type and R-type of Pseudocercosporella herpotrichoides, P. anguioides, Fusarium culmorum, F. avenaceum and Microdochium nivale grown from this plant material on agar were identified. Eyespot was most severe in 1991, when plant development was least rapid following cool weather in late winter and the summer was relatively cool and wet. Sharp eyespot was most severe in 1990, which had a warm summer with moderate rainfall. The other warm summer, 1989, was drier and these conditions favoured late development of brown foot rot, associated mainly with F. culmorum which was scarce at other times. Sharp eyespot sometimes increased where prochloraz, which decreased eyespot, was applied. Distinct symptoms of more than one disease occurred less frequently on the same stem than expected from the individual total occurrences, but co-occurrences of different fungi were often more frequent than expected. In July 1990, Fusarium spp. co-occurred with R-type, but not W-type, P. herpotrichoides more frequently than expected, and in July 1990 and 1991 M. nivale and both W-type and R-type co-occurred more frequently than expected. Fusarium spp. and M. nivale were more frequent, especially in the earlier samples, on nodes than on internodes, whilst P. herpotrichoides normally infected at the internodes. The results suggest that stems weakened or altered by a primary colonizer are often a suitable substrate for a secondary colonizer, often a Fusarium sp., which may begin infection at a distance from the original lesion and often not cause distinct symptoms itself.     

2018年我国小麦赤霉病菌对多菌灵抗性检测

以多菌灵为主的苯并咪唑类杀菌剂一直是小麦抽穗扬花期防控赤霉病的主要手段之一。本研究对2018年我国主要麦区采集的1 464株赤霉病菌菌株进行多菌灵抗性分子检测。共检测出多菌灵抗性菌株97株,抗性频率为6.63%,同时发现抗性菌株以F167Y突变频率最高,其次为E198Q和F200Y。通过比较不同省份间多菌灵抗性发生频率发现,长江中下游麦区赤霉病菌群体抗性频率明显高于黄淮麦区群体。本研究相比之前研究中的抗性频率大幅度上升,表明在多菌灵的选择压力下,多菌灵抗性种群发展迅速。为防止抗性群体的进一步发展,致使多菌灵防治赤霉病失效,应采用混配、复配药剂、不同作用机理的杀菌剂交替轮换使用来防治小麦赤霉病。     

Sensitivity of South African Ramulispora herpotrichoides isolates to carbendazim and ergosterol biosynthesis inhibitors

In a survey conducted during 1991–1992, single-spored isolates of the eyespot fungus from the Swartland area were characterized and tested for sensitivity to carbendazim and ergosterol inhibiting fungicides. The 100 isolates tested were all fast growing, even marginate, and designated as Ramulispora herpotrichoides . Fungal growth was completely inhibit on PDA amended with carbendazim (1 μg/ml), indicating that the local population of the fungus is still at baseline sensitivity to benzimidazoles. The mean concentration of prochloraz calculated to inhibited growth by 50% (IC₅₀ value) was 0.043 ± 0.029 μg/ml, which is comparable with the baseline sensitivity reported for European isolates. Of the 36 representative isolates screened against 2 μg/ml triadimenol, 44% were sensitive, while 36% were resistant. The triadimenol-resistant isolates were sensitive to propiconazole and flusilazole. However, four of the triadimenol-resistant isolates were also resistant to tebuconazole. These results indicate that South African isolates of R. herpotrichoides are sensitive towards carbendazim, prochloraz, propiconazole and flusilazole. They were found to differ, however, in sensitivity towards triadimenol and tebuconazole, where some isolates had an IC₅₀ value greater than 2 μg/ml.     

药剂对稻曲病菌的毒力测定及复配研究

为筛选防治稻曲病的有效单剂和复配组合,采用菌丝生长速率法,测定烯唑醇、腈菌唑、丙环唑、咪鲜胺、苯菌灵、多菌灵、戊唑醇、井冈霉素、松脂酸铜9种杀菌剂及互相复配后对稻曲病菌的毒力,并比较了不同复配组合的协同作用.结果表明:稻曲病菌对烯唑醇最敏感,EC5o为0.145 μg/mL;井冈霉素对稻曲病菌的毒力作用最弱,EC50为13.6 μg/mL.从252种不同比例复配的药剂中,筛选出12种增效配方,其中烯唑醇和咪鲜胺复配(1∶10),协同系数高达3.70,增效作用最大;烯唑醇和咪鲜胺(1∶10)对稻曲病菌的毒力作用最强,EC5o为0.06μg/mL,其次是烯唑醇和咪鲜胺(1∶20)与烯唑醇和腈菌唑(10∶1),EC50分别为0.10μ/mL和0.11μg/mL.田间试验结果也表明:烯唑醇与咪鲜胺(1∶10)复配,对稻曲病的平均防效为79.2％,高于其他常用药剂.     

Distribution and fitness of isolates of Botrytis cinerea with multiple fungicide resistance in Spanish greenhouses

Forty-nine greenhouses of vegetable crops were surveyed in southeast Spain at the beginning of the disease season in December 1992 to estimate frequencies of resistance to benzimidazoles, dicarboximides and N -phenylcarbamates (NPC) in B. cinerea . Out of 261 isolates collected, 28% were sensitive to both benzimidazoles and dicarboximides, 15% were benzimidazole-resistant and dicarboximide-sensitive, 8% were benzimidazole-sensitive and dicarboximide-resistant and 46% were benzimidazole- and dicarboximide-resistant. Resistance to benzimidazole, dicarboximide and N -phenylcarbamate was determined by measuring the ability of each isolate to grow in the presence of carbendazim, procymidone and diethofencarb fungicides respectively. Carbendazim- or procymidone- resistant isolates were found in all surveyed greenhouses. Three isolates were found with resistance to carbendazim, procymidone and diethofencarb collected in two adjacent greenhouses that were sprayed with the carbendazim and diethofencarb mixture. All other isolates were sensitive to the mixture because they were either sensitive to carbendazim and resistant to diethofencarb or vice versa. Fitness of 31 isolates of B. cinerea was determined in vivo by measuring their sporulation and lesion growth rate on leaf disks. No fitness costs were associated with resistance to iprodione (dicarboximide) and benomyl (benzimidazole). Isolates with EC₅₀ values higher than 101 mg/L for benomyl and 1.6 mg/L for iprodione were considered to be field resistant (they caused visible lesions on cucumber leaf disks treated with each fungicide).     

湖北省小麦赤霉病菌对多菌灵、戊唑醇和咪鲜胺的敏感性

对2014年采自中国湖北省7个县、市的206株小麦赤霉病菌样品进行单孢分离与鉴定,并采用菌丝生长速率法随机测定了其中100株菌株对多菌灵、戊唑醇和咪鲜胺的敏感性,建立了其敏感基线。结果表明:多菌灵、戊唑醇和咪鲜胺对湖北省小麦赤霉病菌的EC50值范围分别为0.115~0.705、0.006~1.356和0.002~0.370 μg/mL,平均值分别为0.248、0.181和0.040 μg/mL;供试100株小麦赤霉病菌对3种药剂的敏感性频率均呈单峰拟正态分布,因此可将所得各EC50平均值分别作为湖北省小麦赤霉病菌对3种药剂的敏感基线参考值。以各药剂EC50平均值的10倍作为敏感性鉴别浓度,对2015及2016年湖北省小麦赤霉病菌的敏感性进行了监测,在该鉴别浓度下,多菌灵、戊唑醇和咪鲜胺对2015年小麦赤霉病菌的平均抑制率分别为100%、85.14%和82.35%,对2016年小麦赤霉病菌的平均抑制率分别为100%、76.67%和73.62%。研究表明,虽然戊唑醇和咪鲜胺对2016年小麦赤霉病菌的抑制率略有下降,但整体而言,湖北省小麦赤霉病菌对多菌灵、戊唑醇及咪鲜胺仍具有较高的敏感性。     

2009—2014年间广东省菜心炭疽病菌对咪鲜胺的敏感性

为了解广东省菜心炭疽病菌对咪鲜胺的敏感性差异和变化,于2009—2014年从广东省15个县/市菜心产区分离获得105个菜心炭疽病菌菌株,采用菌丝生长速率法测定了其对咪鲜胺的EC₅₀值,并比较了同一年份不同地区菜心炭疽病菌菌株对咪鲜胺的敏感性差异和不同年份间菜心炭疽病菌菌株对咪鲜胺的敏感性变化。结果显示:同一年份菌株间,采自2009年间的菌株对咪鲜胺的敏感性差异最小,敏感性最低地区菌株的平均EC₅₀值是最高地区菌株的1.2倍;采自2014年间的菌株对咪鲜胺的敏感性差异最大,敏感性最低地区菌株的平均EC₅₀值是最高地区菌株的34.9倍;其余年份间的不同地区最大平均EC₅₀值和最小平均EC₅₀值相差9.2~10.4倍。不同年份菌株间,2010年的菌株对咪鲜胺的敏感性最高,平均EC₅₀值为0.052 0 μg/mL;2012年的菌株对咪鲜胺的敏感性最低,平均EC₅₀值为0.259 9 μg/mL;2012—2014年的菌株对咪鲜胺的平均EC₅₀值范围在0.104 5~0.259 9 μg/mL之间,高于2009—2011年的菌株对咪鲜胺的平均EC₅₀值(0.052 0~0.074 3 μg/mL)。2009—2014年广东省田间菜心炭疽病菌菌株对咪鲜胺的敏感性呈降低趋势,存在潜在抗药性风险。