褐飞虱对噻嗪酮的抗药性监测

1996-2007年间采用稻茎浸渍法测定了我国8省(区)27个褐飞虱种群对噻嗪酮的敏感性。 在1996-2002年间, 江苏\[江浦(JPZY)、仪征(YZZY)和南通(NTZY)\]、安徽\[安庆(AQNS)\]、广西\[南宁(GXNY)和桂林(GLNS)\]褐飞虱种群对噻嗪酮均为敏感至敏感性下降 (抗性倍数为0.3~3.5倍)。 在2005-2007年间,监测到江苏 \[江浦(JPZY), 2005年\]和海南\[陵水(HNLS),2007年\]褐飞虱种群对噻嗪酮达中等水平抗性(抗性倍数分别为28.8倍和19.4倍);其余种群如广西\[南宁(GXNY)和桂林(GLNS)\]、湖南\[常德(CDTY)\]、浙江\[余姚(YYLJ)\]、江西\[新建(XJSM)\]、安徽\[和县(HXLY)、潜山(QSMC)\]及江苏\[南通(NTZY)\]等地褐飞虱种群对噻嗪酮为低水平抗性(抗性倍数为5.6~9.1倍);而江西\[上高(SGMS)\]、浙江\[兰溪(LXYC)\]和湖北\[孝感(XGXC)\]3个褐飞虱种群对噻嗪酮仍为敏感至敏感性下降(抗性倍数2.5~4.1倍)。室内饲养22代,用噻嗪酮对1996年采自安徽\[安庆(AQNS)\]的褐飞虱间断筛选13代,它的LC50下降了30%,筛选前后抗性水平没有明显差异;随后连续筛选15代,抗性倍数达1157.7倍。上述结果表明,褐飞虱对噻嗪酮已产生低到中等水平抗性,如果连续单一使用噻嗪酮,褐飞虱将具有产生高水平抗性的风险。此外,还对褐飞虱的抗性治理进行了讨论。     

褐飞虱对氟虫腈和新烟碱类药剂的抗性动态变化

于2006-2008年采用稻茎浸渍法监测了我国主要水稻种植区大田褐飞虱种群对苯基吡唑类杀虫剂(氟虫腈)、新烟碱类及昆虫生长调节剂类杀虫剂(噻嗪酮)的抗性动态变化。结果表明,2008年褐飞虱对氟虫腈的抗性水平随其迁飞途径而出现急剧上升态势,其中,从我国南方稻区迁入长江中下游流域等6省10地种群和回迁至广东韶山、深圳两种群对氟虫腈抗性分别上升至中等水平抗性(15.0～32.5倍)和高水平抗性(66.9～73.7倍),明显高于2006年5省6地(2.6～5.8倍)和2007年9省11地(3.2～8.4倍)大田褐飞虱种群的抗性水平。上述结果预示2009年、2010年两年在全国稻区可能暴发褐飞虱对氟虫腈更高水平的抗性。自从2005年10-11月褐飞虱对新烟碱类的吡虫啉产生极高水平抗性(277～811倍)以来,近3年来抗性虽有一定程度下降,但仍处于高水平-极高水平抗性阶段,其中,2008年我国8省13地褐飞虱种群的抗性仍高达210.1～381.7倍。褐飞虱对其他的新烟碱类药剂噻虫嗪、烯啶虫胺和呋虫胺的抗性水平分别为2.0～15.8、0.7～4.8和0.6～2.8倍。褐飞虱对噻嗪酮为敏感到中等水平抗性(3.0～11.9倍)。近几年来大量、广泛使用氟虫腈防治褐飞虱和稻纵卷叶螟两类迁飞性害虫是褐飞虱对其暴发抗性的重要原因。因此,必须及时制定全国范围防治两类迁飞性害虫的交替轮换用药抗性治理对策方案,才能延缓褐飞虱抗性的再次暴发。     

褐飞虱对吡虫啉敏感性的时空变化及现实遗传力

为科学用药,采用稻茎浸渍法测定了我国7省（区）42个田间褐飞虱种群对吡虫啉的敏感性时空变化。结果表明,在1996－2003年,除了1997年广西桂林种群为低水平抗性（6.3倍）外,苏、皖、桂3省13个种群对吡虫啉为敏感至敏感性下降（<5倍）;然而,2005年苏、浙、皖、赣、湘、桂6省（区）16个大田种群对吡虫啉的抗性迅速上升,达高水平至极高水平抗性（79～811倍）;2006年,除江苏通州大田种群的抗性为627倍外,苏、浙、皖、赣、湘、桂、闽7省（区）11个种群的抗性为150～322倍,比2005年有一定程度下降,这可能与暂停使用吡虫啉有关。室内用吡虫啉对褐飞虱筛选18代,其抗性由筛选前的208.3倍上升到筛选后的1110.8倍,抗性现实遗传力（h2）为0.1414。这暗示褐飞虱对吡虫啉产生高水平抗性后,如继续使用吡虫啉防治,其抗性可能会进一步上升。还讨论了稻褐飞虱抗药性的治理策略。     

防治褐飞虱的高毒农药替代药剂的室内筛选及交互抗性研究

为了筛选防治褐飞虱的高毒农药的替代药剂,于2005-2006年, 采用稻茎浸渍法测定了6类20余种杀虫剂对广西南宁、桂林,湖南常德和江苏南京褐飞虱种群的室内毒力。结果表明,噻嗪酮、氟虫腈、噻虫嗪、烯啶虫胺、毒死蜱、异丙威、猛杀威、丁硫克百威等8种药剂对褐飞虱具有较高的毒力,可作为替代高毒药剂的候选品种。采用稻茎浸渍法对1个室内褐飞虱种群用吡虫啉筛选23代后,褐飞虱对吡虫啉的抗性从筛选前的200.1倍上升至筛选后的1298.5倍（上升了5.5倍）;高抗吡虫啉的褐飞虱种群对氯噻啉、噻虫啉和啶虫脒表现出明显的交互抗性,而对呋虫胺、噻虫嗪和烯啶虫胺则无明显的交互抗性。 还讨论了褐飞虱的抗性治理策略。     

亚致死剂量吡虫啉和吡蚜酮对褐飞虱生物适合度的影响

 全面评价了亚致死剂量吡虫啉和吡蚜酮对褐飞虱繁殖力和生存力的长期影响。毒力测定结果显示,吡虫啉和吡蚜酮对褐飞虱3龄若虫的LC50分别为42.41 mg/L和396.46 mg/L,吡虫啉毒力约是吡蚜酮毒力的9.35倍。通过建立褐飞虱在吡虫啉和吡蚜酮亚致死剂量（LC30）作用下的生命表,发现褐飞虱在两种药剂处理下生物适合度都有所下降,分别为对照试虫的83.8%和8.4%。吡虫啉处理试虫仅羽化率明显低于对照,而吡蚜酮处理试虫的羽化率、雌虫比例、雌成虫寿命和卵孵化率各参数都明显下降。亚致死剂量的吡蚜酮使褐飞虱日产卵节律和卵孵化高峰都有所推迟,这可能是吡蚜酮对褐飞虱产生取食抑制作用进而导致其生殖器官发育缓慢造成的。     

灰飞虱对几类杀虫剂的抗性和敏感性

采用点滴法和稻茎浸渍法分别测定了2006年4月采自江苏省无锡市和浙江省湖州市灰飞虱种群对9种杀虫剂的抗性及17种杀虫剂的敏感性。点滴法测定结果表明,无锡种群和湖州种群对吡虫啉均产生了高水平抗性,抗性倍数分别为79.6倍和44.6倍;对残杀威的抗性倍数分别为76.6倍和40.1倍,属高水平抗性;对甲萘威的抗性倍数分别为29.8倍和45.3倍,属中等-高水平抗性;对二嗪磷、杀螟硫磷、仲丁威、丁硫克百威、醚菊酯、氰戊菊酯的抗性倍数为1.4~8.1倍,属敏感-低水平抗性。毒力测定结果表明氟虫腈、丁烯氟虫腈对无锡和湖州灰飞虱3龄若虫的毒力最高,LC50值为0.21~041 mg/L;噻虫嗪、烯啶虫胺、毒死蜱、吡蚜酮、异丙威、敌敌畏为田间药效试验的推荐用药。还讨论了灰飞虱抗药性的治理。     

吡蚜酮对水稻褐飞虱取食行为的影响

吡蚜酮是防治褐飞虱的推荐替代杀虫剂之一。取食选择性试验表明,0.1g/L吡蚜酮处理和清水处理24h稻株上的平均落虫数分别为(1.6±1.2)头/株和(1.5±0.9)头/株。刺探电位技术监测发现,与清水对照相比,0.1g/L吡蚜酮浸苗处理下褐飞虱的口针刺探频次、韧皮部刺入频次、在韧皮部外部活动的持续时间以及木质部取食行为的持续时间没有显著差异,而褐飞虱的非刺探持续时间显著增加,褐飞虱在韧皮部内摄取汁液被极显著干扰,吡蚜酮处理后4h内褐飞虱成虫在韧皮部取食的总持续时间只有(1.2±0.5)min,而在对照上的总持续时间为(65.1±11.3)min。取食恢复试验表明吡蚜酮对褐飞虱韧皮部取食的抑制作用可逆,但是取食抑制的恢复非常缓慢。经吡蚜酮0.1g/L处理24h再转移至清水处理苗上120h后,韧皮部取食的总持续时间也仅约为10min。研究表明,吡蚜酮对褐飞虱没有驱避性和拒食性,不阻碍褐飞虱口针刺探和木质部取食,但对韧皮部取食具有明显的抑制作用,且这种抑制作用恢复非常缓慢。因此,吡蚜酮防治褐飞虱的持效期较长。     

浙江省褐飞虱抗药性监测与治理

对浙江省稻区采集的水稻褐飞虱,应用稻茎浸渍法测定其对主要防治药剂的抗药性.结果表明,褐飞虱对吡虫啉仍维持高水平抗性,但抗性水平比2005年有下降,对噻嗪酮和氟虫腈仍为敏感。根据褐飞虱的抗药性水平,制定用药方案,是治理抗性褐飞虱,控制褐飞虱为害的有效措施。     

灰飞虱对氟虫腈抗性风险评估、遗传分析及杀虫剂敏感性研究

 在室内采用稻茎浸渍法进行了灰飞虱对氟虫腈抗性风险评估、抗性遗传分析和杀虫剂的敏感性研究。于2005年采自无锡麦田的灰飞虱种群在室内饲养43代期间用氟虫腈筛选了41代,结果此灰飞虱种群的抗性从8.4倍上升到2305倍。根据Tabashnik介绍的方法计算,现实遗传力(h2)分别为0.0388(1~31代)、0.2636(32~43代)和0.1113(1~43代), 表明灰飞虱对氟虫腈具有一定的抗性风险。采用稻茎浸渍法测定了2007-2008年江苏无锡和浙江长兴两地灰飞虱种群对15种杀虫剂的敏感性, 结果表明,苯基吡唑类杀虫剂氟虫腈、丁烯氟虫腈和乙虫腈的毒力最高(LC50=0.2~1.7 mg/L),其次为烯啶虫胺、噻虫嗪、毒死蜱、吡蚜酮(LC50=1.7~9.7 mg/L),其余杀虫剂的毒力较低;按照年度间敏感性变化,发现2008年无锡灰飞虱种群对氟虫腈和乙虫腈的敏感性比2007年降低了1.1倍。近年来氟虫腈已广泛用于防治这种害虫,但乙虫腈几乎没有使用。因此,对氟虫腈敏感性降低的大田灰飞虱种群似乎对乙虫腈存在交互抗性。通过抗(R)、感(S)亲本、正反交(F1、 F1′)、自交(F2)及回交(BC)后代对氟虫腈的剂量反应研究了灰飞虱对氟虫腈的抗性遗传特性,结果表明,其抗性为常染色体的不完全显性遗传\[D(F1)=0.20, D(F1′)=0.38\],抗性由2个或2个以上等位基因控制。还对灰飞虱的抗性治理进行了讨论。     

水稻飞虱对十三种杀虫剂的抗性监测

1987～1991年选用有机磷、有机氮和拟除虫菊酯类十三种杀虫剂对白背飞虱和褐飞虱用国际统一标准毒力测定点滴法进行抗药性监测。结果表明:1)白背飞虱和褐飞虱对呋喃丹最为敏感,对马拉硫磷敏感度最低。LD_(50)值相差上百倍。因两种飞虱均属迁飞性害虫,年度间的测定结果稍有波动。2)白背飞虱抗药性发展比褐飞虱快,在测定方法和供试昆虫条件基本相同的情况下,将1990年所测几种药剂的LD_(50)与日本Nagata(1967)测定数据进行比较,浙江省白背飞虱种群对马拉硫磷的抗性差异高达110.56倍,对杀螟松为48.90倍;褐飞虱种群对马拉硫磷、杀螟松的抗性分别相差11.61倍和6.11倍。3)褐飞虱种群对药剂的敏感度与当地用药水平呈负相关。4)有机磷类不同品种杀虫剂对两种飞虱的毒力差异较大,毒力较高的久效磷的LD_(50)值与毒力较低的马拉硫磷的LD_(50)相差数十倍。     

Field evolution of insecticide resistance in the brown planthopper (Nilaparvata lugens Stål) in China

The brown planthopper (Nilaparvata lugens Stål) is one of the most destructive pests of rice crops in Asian countries including China, Vietnam, Thailand, etc. Evolution of resistance in this pest insect to isoprocarb, buprofezin, pymetrozine, imidacloprid and other neonicotinoid insecticides has been reported. In order to investigate the current status of resistance to commonly used insecticides, nine field populations of N. lugens were collected from Central China, East China and South China, and resistance to insecticides was monitored from 2009 to 2012. All the 9 field populations collected in 2012 had developed extremely high resistance to imidacloprid, with resistance ratios (RR) ranging from 209.3 to 616.6. Resistance to imidacloprid was much higher in 2012 than in 2009. The RR of thiamethoxam varied from 17.4 to 47.1, and the RR of nitenpyram varied from 1.4 to 3.7 in 2012. Of the 9 field populations, six populations showed higher resistance to nitenpyram in 2012 than in 2011. RR for buprofezin varied from 110.1 to 221.6 in 2012 whereas resistance was at a medium level (RR 20.4 ∼ 39.4-fold) in 2009. RR for pymetrozine ranged from 34.9 to 46.8 in 2012. As for isoprocarb, RR ranged from 21.7 to 38.1 in 2012. The obvious increase in resistance to widely applied insecticides indicates that insecticide resistance management strategies are urgently needed to prevent or delay further increase of insecticide resistance in N. lugens.     

Effect of host plant resistance and insecticide on brown planthopper Nilaparvata lugens (Stål) and predator population development in the Mekong Delta, Vietnam

Crop yield and populations of brown planthopper Nilaparvata lugens (Stål), whitebacked planthopper Sogatella furcifera (Horvath) (Homoptera: Delphacidae), green leafhopper Nephotettix spp. (Homoptera: Cicadellidae), and hemipteran and spider predators were monitored on rice varieties susceptible, moderately resistant, and highly resistant to N. lugens, under insecticide-treated and insecticide-free conditions. Nilaparvata lugens outbreaks and hopperburned plants were observed only in plots of the insecticide-treated susceptible varieties. In insecticide-free plots, the yield of the susceptible variety was lower than those of resistant varieties in only one of four seasons. In plots of a moderately resistant and a highly resistant variety, populations of N. lugens, S. furcifera, Nephotettix spp., and predators were generally similar, and yields did not differ, under both insecticide-treated and insecticide-free conditions. In insecticide-free plots, predator-N. lugens ratios were generally higher on resistant varieties than susceptible varieties. Two conclusions can'be drawn from our results relevant to the question of what levels of N. lugens host plant resistance are appropriate for farmers who do not overuse insecticides. First, susceptible varieties will not necessarily be damaged by N. lugens, even when N. lugens outbreaks occur in adjacent plots. Second, moderate and high levels of N. lugens resistance do not appear to be incompatible with biological control of N. lugens or other homopteran pests.     

Monitoring of insecticide resistance in Spodoptera litura (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) from four districts of Punjab,Pakistan to conventional and new chemistry insecticides

Studies were carried out to evaluate the resistance of Pakistani populations of the beet armyworm, Spodoptera litura (F) to several commonly used insecticides. Different field populations of S. litura from four districts of the Punjab were monitored from 2009 to 2011 for resistance to insecticides using a standard leaf dip bioassay method. For organophosphates and pyrethroids, resistance ratios compared with a susceptible Lab-Pk population were in the range of 8–109 fold for deltamethrin, 11–139 fold for cypermethrin, 19–143 fold for chlorpyrifos and 39–162 fold for profenofos. For new chemistry insecticides, resistance levels were 2–74 fold for spinosad, 4–216 fold for abamectin, 7–87 fold for indoxacarb, 2–77 fold for emamectin benzoate, 1.9–58 fold for lufenuron and 4–43 fold for methoxyfenozide. Pairwise correlation coefficients of LC₅₀ values showed a positive correlation with cross-resistance among deltamethrin, cypermethrin and chlorpyrifos, while resistance to profenofos showed correlations with resistances to other insecticides except chlorpyrifos. New chemistry insecticides showed no correlations between any of the tested insecticides. There were high to very high levels of resistance to organophosphates in most of the population, which suggested that the use of these should be avoided against this pest. Selective use of pyrethroids in several areas, including Bahawalpur and Lodhran, where the pest showed a low level of resistance, would appear to be acceptable, the new chemistry insecticides, lufenuron, methoxyfenozide, emamectin and indoxacarb had no, very low, low and moderate resistance levels against populations, respectively. These are considered to be safe to the environment and safer to natural enemies.     

Bph36介导的抗性机制及相关信号通路的研究

褐飞虱（Nilaparvata lugens Stål., BPH）是水稻最主要的害虫之一,给水稻生产造成严重的危害。携带不同抗性基因的抗褐飞虱水稻材料抗性机制不同,挖掘普通野生稻抗褐飞虱基因并研究其介导的抗性机制及相关信号通路对水稻育种具有重要的意义。本研究基于课题组前期从广西普通野生稻‘W2183'挖掘出的位于4号染色体InDel标记S13和X48之间38 kb处新基因Bph36,以‘9311'和‘抗蚊青占'为感性对照,05RBPH16和NIL-Bph36为抗性对照,通过褐飞虱宿主选择性、蜜露量测定、褐飞虱存活率及褐飞虱生长速率等方法分析Bph36介导的抗褐飞虱机制;同时,以‘抗蚊青占'为感性对照,NIL-Bph36为抗性对照,通过qRT-PCR分析植物防御昆虫侵害的三大信号途径：水杨酸、茉莉酸和乙烯相关基因表达量的差异。抗性机制研究结果表明：褐飞虱在抗性材料植株上的虫口密度显著低于感性材料植株,抗性材料上的褐飞虱存活率、群体生长率及取食后排泄的蜜露量均比感性对照显著降低。Bph36介导的抗性机制是寄主抗生性和害虫趋避性相互作用的结果。qRT-PCR结果表明：褐飞虱取食后,各个时间段抗性材料NIL-Bph36植株中水杨酸合成相关基因EDS1、PAD4、PAL和水杨酸途径病程相关蛋白基因PR10的表达量显著高于感性材料‘抗蚊青占'植株中的表达量;抗性材料NIL-Bph36植株中,茉莉酸合成基因LOX2和茉莉酸积累基因AOS2的表达量比褐飞虱取食前显著提升,但是比同时段感性材料植株中表达量显著降低;褐飞虱取食后,抗、感性材料植株中乙烯信号途径基因EIN2的表达量都受到抑制,基因ACO3表达量都提高,但2种材料间的差异不显著。茉莉酸途径和乙烯途径参与了NIL-Bph36植株抗褐飞虱的基础防御反应,但Bph36激活的抗性不是茉莉酸和乙烯依赖的信号防御途径而是激活水杨酸依赖的系统获得性抗性。研究结果为进一步研究Bph36与其他抗性基因聚合,培育兼有多种抗性机制和防御信号途径的优良品种奠定基础。     

Resistance monitoring and enzyme activity in three field populations of cowpea aphid (Aphis craccivora) from Egypt

The cowpea aphid (Aphis craccivora) is one of the most important sucking insect pests attacking certain legumes in Egypt particularly faba bean, cowpea and pea. In this study we monitored the resistance level of three field populations of A. craccivora to seven insecticides belonging to three different chemical classes (organophosphates, carbamates and neonicotinoids). The three populations were collected from three governorates in Egypt namely Dakahlia, Qalyobia and Beni Suef. Diagnostic concentrations (LC₉₀ values for susceptible strain) for each insecticide were established using a leaf dipping technique. Resistance monitoring showed that the field population from Dakahlia was highly resistant to all the tested insecticides. In a similar manner, the population from Qalyobia was also resistant to all insecticides except for fenitrothion to which only moderate resistance was observed. The field population from Beni Suef exhibited a lower level of resistance to all the seven tested insecticides.Biochemical assay showed that esterase activity in these three field populations was generally higher as the enzyme activity ratio ranged from 4.3 to 7.8 fold more than that for the susceptible strain. The activity of the other measured detoxifying enzymes (glutathione -S- transferase and mixed function oxidases) was moderate in the populations from Qalyobia and Dakahlia. Nevertheless, the enzyme activity in A. craccivora collected from Beni Suef was variable and differed slightly from the activity measured in the susceptible strain. Monitoring insecticide resistance among the three aphid populations was a proactive approach to detect any shift in insecticide efficiency. The possible occurrence of resistance in the cowpea aphid to the tested insecticides may be due to the higher activity of carboxylesterases. Further studies on the resistance mechanism to these insecticides are needed to provide insights in how to manage and delay the onset of the resistance and thus prolong the performance of insecticides against A. craccivora.     

水稻飞虱对十三种杀虫剂的抗性监测

1987～1991年选用有机磷、有机氯和拟除虫菊酯类十三种杀虫剂对白背飞虱和褐飞虱用国际统一标准毒力测定点滴法进行抗药性监涮。结果表明：1)白背飞虱和褐飞虱对呋喃丹最为敏感。对马拉硫磷敏感度最低,LD50值相差上百倍。因两种飞虱均属迁飞性害虫,年度间的测定结果稍有波动;2) 白背飞虱抗药性发展比褐飞虱快,在测定方法和供试昆虫条件基本相同的情况下, 将1990年所测几种药剂的LD50与Nagata (1967)测定的数据进行比较。浙江省白背飞虱种群对马拉硫磷的抗性差异高达1lO．56倍, 对杀螟松为48.90倍;褐飞虱种群对马拉硫磷、杀螟松的抗性分别相差11.61倍和6．11倍。3)褐飞虱种群对药剂的敏感度与当地用药水平呈负相关。4) 有机磷类不同品种杀虫剂对两种飞虱的毒力差异较大。毒力较高的久效磷的LD50值与毒力较低的马拉硫磷的LD50值相差数十倍。     

Susceptibility to Insecticides and Ecological Fitness in Resistant Rice Varieties of Field Nilaparvata lugens Stl Population Free from Insecticides in Laboratory

A population of rice brown planthopper(BPH) Nilaparvata lugens collected from a paddy field in Hangzhou was successively reared on susceptible rice Taichung Native 1(TN1) in a laboratory free from insecticides for more than 14 generations. The changes in susceptibility to insecticides and ecological fitness on different resistant rice varieties were monitored in each generation. The resistance ratio to imidacloprid sharply declined with the succession of rearing generations without insecticides from 359.94-fold at F1 to 6.50-fold at F14 compared with the susceptible strain, and the resistance ratio to chlorpyrifos was from 9.90-fold at F1 to 5.94-fold at F14. Nymphal duration and weights of newly hatched female adults were significantly affected by rice variety, generation and their interactions, but nymphal survival was significantly affected by the generation only. The ratio of brachypterous adults in males was affected by the generation and generation × variety interaction, whereas no difference was found in females. Nymphal duration extended with increasing generations, and the female nymphal duration was shorter in the susceptible variety TN1 than those in the resistant varieties IR26 and IR36. In addition, the female adult weight in TN1 was higher than those in IR26 and IR36. These results indicated that the resistance of field BPH population to insecticides was reversed after several generations of no-exposure to insecticides, and the ecological fitness in TN1 was higher than those in IR26 and IR36. These findings suggested the rational and reduced use of insecticides in combination with the manipulation of resistant rice varieties would be effective for BPH management.     

长江流域稻区二化螟抗药性监测

2008-2009年期间,采用毛细管点滴法测定了浙、苏、皖、湘、鄂、川、豫等7省17个种群二化螟4龄幼虫对常用杀虫剂的抗性,结果表明:长江流域稻区二化螟对杀虫剂的抗性分布存在明显的区域性。高抗区浙江南部的苍南、瑞安、江山二化螟种群对20世纪70-90年代广泛使用的沙蚕毒素类的杀虫单(抗性倍数43.2～177.0倍)和有机磷类的三唑磷(238.7～728.1倍)、毒死蜱(31.7～57.8倍)均产生了高-极高水平抗性,且对近年来开始广泛使用的氟虫腈(11.2～24.7倍)和阿维菌素(5.9～7.1倍)也产生了中等或低水平抗性;中抗区的安徽庐江、湖南攸县、江苏高淳种群对三唑磷产生极高水平抗性(203.2～379.0倍),对杀虫单(18.3～48.8倍)和毒死蜱(29.8倍)产生了中等-高水平抗性,对氟虫腈(4.4倍)和阿维菌素(4.1～4.7倍)为敏感性降低;低抗区除江苏仪征种群对毒死蜱(45.2倍)、安徽和县种群对三唑磷(50.0倍)开始产生高水平抗性外,对其他杀虫剂为敏感-中等水平抗性,对氟虫腈和阿维菌素为敏感;敏感区的河南信阳、江苏连云港、四川武胜种群除对个别杀虫剂(如杀虫单)为低水平抗性外,对其他大多数杀虫剂为敏感-敏感性降低。还讨论了按抗性分布的区域性来制定相应的抗性治理方案。