Net blotch resistance in wild species of Hordeum

Resistance to net blotch was evaluated in 175 Hordeum vulgare subsp. spontaneum (H. spontaneum) accessions and 149 accessions of thirteen species or subspecies of wild Hordeum. Most H. spontaneum accessions showed resistance to each of the four Pyrenophora teres f. teres (P. teres) isolates tested. However, H. spontaneum accessions showed different resistance reactions, depending upon their origin. In particular, some accessions from Afghanistan and Russia showed a high level of resistance, and accessions from Morocco were susceptible. Among the four P. teres isolates, the virulence spectra on the H. spontaneum accessions were more different between isolates from different countries than between those from the same country. Hordeum spontaneum accessions susceptible to the Canadian isolate WRS102, but resistant to the other three isolates were found in Iraq suggesting the geographical differentiation of resistance genes in H. spontaneum. All accessions of the other wild Hordeum species, especially some accessions of H. marinum subsp. gussoneanum, showed high levels of resistance. These resistance genes may be useful candidates for incorporation into cultivated barley. This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Radiation interception and radiation use efficiency of near-isogenic wheat lines with different height

Resistance to Pyrenophora teres Drechs. f. teres Smedeg., the net blotch pathogen, was studied in six 6-row Nordic spring barleys (Hordeum vulgare L.) in the field and in the greenhouse. The barley genotypes were: Arve, Agneta, Artturi, H6221, Pohto and WW7977. Disease progress was monitored in the field (1994 and 1995) in small artificially infected plots, sown at commercial seeding rates, and in infected hill plots (1994). Areas under the disease progress curves (AUDPC) and apparent infection rates (r) were calculated for the uppermost 3 or 4 leaves. Terminal severities (TS) were also recorded. Infection response of seedlings to a range of P. teres isolates was assessed in the greenhouse using a standard scale. In small plots in the field, Arve and Agneta were very susceptible to P. teres infection, as indicated by large values for AUDPC and TS. H6221 and WW7977 were highly resistant, while Artturi and Pohto were moderately resistant. In hill plots the situation was similar, except that Artturi and Pohto appeared less resistant than in the small plots. The relatively greater resistance of H6221 and WW7977 was reflected in seedling infection responses. According to the results of these experiments, H6221 and WW7977 possess adequate levels of quantitative resistance to P. teres to make them useful parents in future crossing programs aimed at improving net blotch resistance in Finnish spring barleys. This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Reaction of European spring barley varieties to a population of the net blotch fungus

About 320 European spring barley varieties and about 40 spring barley lines were tested in the field for reaction to a local population of the spot form of the net blotch fungus Pyrenophora teres forma maculata with the imperfect stage Drechslera teres. The European barley varieties showed a wide range of disease reactions, from nearly resistant to very susceptible. At least three groups of genetically related barley varieties could be distinguished: (0)‘Agneta’ and ‘Clermont’, (2)‘Nordal’ and ‘Arve’, and (3)‘Tellus’,‘Pamina’, ‘Albert’ and ‘Birka’. The parentages of these three groups of barley are mutually distantly related and may thus constitute three different sources of resistance to the pathogen population used. The range of disease reaction is similar in varieties from different European countries but it differs among different breeding stations. The relatively high level of resistance is fairly uniformly distributed in contemporary barley varieties all over most of Western Europe. Over time, from about 1830‐1982, the average level of resistance varied around 4.0 (scale value) (from 2.8 to 4.8). However, since about 1940 the variation in disease reaction has become much wider (from 108 to 6.9) for unknown reason(s).     

Diversity among Finnish net blotch isolates and resistance in barley

Summary Seedlings of a differential barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) series (21 genotypes) and of six check genotypes were used in the greenhouse to assess variation in virulence among 20 single-spore isolates of the net blotch pathogen. Pyrenophora teres Drechs. f.teres Smedeg., collected from various sites in Finland. The experiment was run twice and symptom expression was recorded on the first three leaves. Analysis of second leaf symptom scores from Run 1 indicated differences in virulence between isolates, all of which were pathogenic, and differential resistance among the barleys. The virulence of P. teres isolates appeared to be conditioned by the host barley from which the isolate derived; the average virulence of isolates collected from a susceptible host was greater than that of isolates collected from a less susceptible host. Results from Run 2 were similar regarding resistance within the barleys, but variation in virulence among the P. teres isolates was not consistent with that from Run 1. CI 9819 caries duplicate genes for resistance to P. teres (Rpt1b and Rpt1c), and CI 7548 possesses Rpt3d. Both genotypes were highly resistant to all isolates. The Rpt1a gene of Tifang (CI4407) conferred resistance to all isolates in Run 2, but only to about half of the isolates in Run 1. The checks, including two of the symptomatically most resistant Nordic barley genotypes, were universally susceptible during these stringent tests. No selective pressure has been placed on Finnish isolates of P. teres through previous deployment of major resistance genes, and it is speculated that any variation in virulence among isolates is likely to be due to a combination of evolutionary forces including, natural selection, random genetic drift and gene flow.     

Diallel analysis of net blotch resistance in doubled haploid lines of Nordic spring barleys

A half-diallel was made between five six-rowed Nordic spring barleys to study the genetics of resistance to net blotch. Twenty-five doubled-haploid (DH) lines from each cross and the parents were sown in hill plots in Finland in 1997 and 1998. The plots were artificially inoculated with Pyrenophora teres Drechs. f. teres Smedeg. and assessed for resistance to net blotch. There were statistically significant differences in resistance of the five parents to net blotch. General combining ability (GCA) of the parents and specific combining ability (SCA) effects in the progeny were statistically significant in both years, but GCA effects predominated. Evidence for additive epistasis was minimal. Progeny of a particular cross were less resistant to net blotch than the better parent. The most resistant progeny were derived from the cross between the two most resistant parents, Pohto and WW7977, and resistance was governed by at least eleven effective factors. Narrow sense heritability estimates for resistance to net blotch were high during both years (0.84–0.99). It appears that net blotch resistance of progeny from crosses can be largely predicted from reactions of the parents. Quantitative resistance to net blotch can be further advanced by identification and incorporation of superior parents, from a screening such as reported here, into a recurrent selection breeding programme. This revised version was published online in August 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Screening the Spanish Barley Core Collection for disease resistance

The Spanish Barley Core Collection comprises 159 landrace-derived inbred lines and 16 cultivars adapted to Southern European conditions. The collection was screened for resistance to powdery mildew ( Blumeria graminis ), scald ( Rhynchosporium secalis ), leaf rust ( Puccinia hordei ), net blotch ( Pyrenophora teres f. teres ), Barley yellow dwarf virus (BYDV) and Barley mild mosaic virus (BaMMV). Resistance to powdery mildew was outstanding, with 58 lines presenting mean overall resistance, among them seven landrace-derived lines resistant to all seven isolates tested. About 26% of the Spanish lines were resistant to scald. Resistance to leaf rust and to net blotch was scarce, though a few accessions showed resistance levels as good as the checks. Thirteen accessions (12 Spanish) were totally resistant to BaMMV and c. 20% of accessions showed moderate tolerance to BYDV. Landrace-derived lines from the Mediterranean Coast and Southern regions of Spain were the most resistant to powdery mildew and leaf rust, but the most susceptible to viruses. Potential sources of resistance might be preserved in some accessions subjected to selective pressure in the region of origin.     

Inheritance of resistance to Pyrenophora teres f. teres in spring barley

The inheritance of seedling resistance to a Swedish isolate of Pyrenophora teres f. teres was investigated in four resistance sources of spring barley. Accessions CI 2330, CI 5791, CI 5822 and CI 9779 were used as resistance sources, and the cultivar ‘Alexis’ was used as a susceptible parent in different crosses. From the disease reaction in the F₁, F₂ and F₃ generations it was concluded that the resistance was governed by the same two complementary genes in CI 5791, CI 822 and CI 9776. One of these genes was present in CI 2330. The first three cultivars were highly resistant to the isolate used in this investigation. These results, when combined with earlier studies, suggest that CI 5791, CI 5822 and CI 9776 may be of great value as sources of resistance to barley net blotch. Spearman's rank correlation between the disease reaction of F₂ plants and their F₃ progeny was highly significant (r = 0.75; P ≥ 0.001) It is suggested that selection in the F₂ generation is effective. In a backcross breeding scheme, single plant reactions in F₁ or F₂ need to be confirmed in later generations.     

Stable resistance in barley to Pyrenophora teres f. teres isolates from the Nordic-Baltic region after increase on standard host genotypes

Results from tests of a mixture of Finnish net blotch, Pyrenophora teres Drechs. f. teres Smedeg., isolates on a differential series of barley seedlings, comprising 17genotypes, indicated that patterns of infection response (IR)and percentage leaf area damaged (PLAD) were unaffected by differences in seedling size. Variation of the concentration of inoculum between 1,250 conidia ml^-1 and 20,000 conidia ml^-1 produced similar patterns of IR and PLAD on the differential series. IR and PLAD scored on the second seedling leaf differentiated resistance to P. teres f. teresamong the genotypes better than on the first seedling leaf. Ina second experiment, 120 single-spore P. teres f. teres isolates from Finland, Sweden, Norway, Latvia, Estonia and Ireland were used in tests conducted in the greenhouse to differentiate them in terms of virulence reaction on seedlings of six differential barley genotypes. Each isolate was tested directly following isolation from the leaf material and after having passaged each through barley cvs. Arve or Pohto, to produce 360 isolates in total. Virulence of the isolates differed significantly on the members of the differential series, but differences associated with country of origin and passaging, and interactions, were small. It is concluded that little variation between virulence of P. teres f. teres isolates is evident over a large geographic area, incorporating Nordic and Baltic countries, and Ireland. Barley genotype response to P. teres f. teres appeared to be of more significance than relative virulence of the pathogen isolates. This could simplify breeding barley for improved resistance to this phytopathogen. This revised version was published online in August 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Barley mutants with enhanced level of resistance to Swedish isolates of Bipolaris sorokiniana,casual agent of spot blotch

Spot blotch, caused by Bipolaris sorokiniana, has become an increasingly important disease on barley in Sweden. In order to enhance our knowledge of this disease, eight Swedish B. sorokiniana isolates were assessed for their virulence pathotype on 30 barley genotypes including eight lines of mutant origin, designated B. sorokiniana tolerant (bst). A leaf screen assay revealed the presence of virulence groups 1 and 7 in Sweden. Several mutant genotypes demonstrated enhanced resistance responses (P = 0.0001), of which bst1:3 had the lowest leaf scoring value to the most virulent isolate, Swe2 (virulence group 7). To evaluate the host root responses, two contrasting isolates Swe2 and Swe4 (virulence group 7 and 1) were used to inoculate a set of eight differential lines, including four promising mutant lines from the leaf screen. Mutant bst1:6 was significantly less susceptible (P = 0.001) compared with the other barley genotypes tested, independent of the two isolates used. Mutants bst1, bst1:3 and bst1:4, which displayed less or no spots, are also considered promising genotypes for further breeding attempts.     

Yield of doubled haploid lines of Nordic spring barley infected with net blotch, Pyrenophora teres

Five Nordic spring barley lines (‘Rolfi’, ‘Arve’, ‘Botnia’, ‘Pohto’ and WW7977) and doubled haploid (DH) populations from a half diallel of crosses between them, were sown in the field in Finland over 2 years and were artificially infected with Pyrenophora teres, the causal agent of net blotch. The purpose of the experiments was to determine the extent of yield loss under net blotch infection in a range of parent barleys and DH populations differing in symptom expression. Analysis of foliar damage symptoms, yield and aerial biomass data indicated that, in both years, there were statistically significant differences among parents and crosses, but the relationships between symptom expression and yield maintenance and between symptom expression and aerial biomass maintenance were stronger in 1997, when yields were higher and net blotch was less severe.     

Resistance spectra of wheat genotypes and virulence patterns of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Mycosphaerella graminicola</Emphasis> isolates in Iran

Co-evolution of wheat and its devastating pathogen Mycosphaerella graminicola (anamorph Septoria tritici), the causal agent of septoria tritici blotch, a foliar disease of wheat, is suggested to occur in Fertile Crescent as their center of origin and, thus, interaction between pathogen virulence and host resistance is important subject to be addressed. We have investigated resistance spectra of 54 wheat genotypes including a set of differentials carrying known resistance genes and virulence patterns of 14 M. graminicola isolates at seedling stage under controlled environmental conditions. The isolates were collected in Iran from five provinces. Diversity in virulence and aggressiveness was observed among the isolates from four provinces. Isolates collected from Golestan province were virulent to all wheat genotypes from germplasm of Iran, while specific resistances were identified to the isolates from other provinces. Among wheat genotypes, cvs. Chamran, Morvarid and Hirmand had the greatest number of specific resistances as well as partial resistance. Wheat genotypes of the differential set also differed in their reactions to the isolates. Arina, Flame and TE 9111 were specifically resistant to the greatest number of isolates from different provinces. Most isolates were virulent to the other differentials such as cvs. Shafir, Estanzuela federal and Courtot indicating that extensive adaption of virulence to most of the known resistance genes (Stb) has occurred in these regions. The new sources of resistance to highly virulent isolates from Iran may also be utilized in wheat breeding programs to develop resistant cultivars against pathogen populations in other countries.     

Genes for resistance in barley to Finnish isolates of Rhynchosporium secalis

Summary Twenty Finnish isolates of Rhynchosporium secalis (Oud.) J.J. Davis, the causal agent of scald, were taken from infected barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) plants and inoculated on to seedlings of a differential series of barley containing a range of major genes for resistance to the fungus, as well as on to six Nordic 6-row spring barleys and three winter ryes (Secale cereale L.). These fungal isolates derived from four sites and three host varieties. Disease development was monitored on two leaves of seedlings in the greenhouse employing a standard scale, and on adult plants in the field by assessing the diseased area on the three uppermost leaves. A comparison was also made between the pathogenicity and virulence of ten Finnish and ten Canadian R. secalis isolates. The Finnish isolates varied in virulence, but with the exception of Algerian (CI 1179) seedlings and adult La Mesita (CI 7565) all seedlings and adult plants of the entire differential series were resistant to all isolates. Canadian isolates were, on average, less virulent than Finnish isolates. All the Nordic checks were susceptible to all Finnish and seven Canadian isolates, but differences in the degree of susceptibility were evident. Isolates of R. secalis from barley were non-pathogenic on rye, isolates from Elymus repens L. were non-pathogenic on barley and rye, and isolates from rye were only pathogenic on rye. Finnish R. secalis isolates contain no redundant pathogenic diversity. The differential series represents a useful, but as yet untapped, source of resistance to R. secalis for Finnish barley breeders.     

Approaches for field assessment of resistance to leaf pathogens in spring barley varieties

The resistance of spring barley varieties to powdery mildew, leaf rust, leaf scald and net blotch was characterized by using results from inoculated small‐plot nurseries and larger survey plots subject to natural infection. The experiments were conducted in different environments. Both trial types often yielded complementary results with respect to the ranking of varieties suggesting that a recommended variety characterization should include both naturally infected survey‐type trials and nursery trials in which the most relevant pathogen isolates and/or isolate mixtures or populations are used for inoculation. Average and median values of the diseased leaf area of a variety were highly correlated with each other and with the ‘genotype main effect’ determined by joint regression analysis, whereas maximum diseased leaf area was poorly correlated with them. Statistics based on absolute disease severity values were highly correlated with the corresponding statistics derived from relative values. It is suggested that one should use at least two parameters to characterize the disease resistance of a variety, a parameter indicating the overall resistance level and a parameter indicating the potential susceptibility and/or resistance instability of a variety. For practical purposes, the genotype median and maximum, respectively, may represent these, although statistically more appropriate parameters do exist.     

Differential response and genes for resistance to Peronospora parasitica (downy mildew) in Brassica juncea (mustard)

The response of a wide range of Brassica juncea accessions to 14 isolates of Peronospora parasitica, 12 from India (IP00A, IP02, IP03, IP04, IP04A, IP05, IP05B, IP33 and IP33A were derived from B. juncea; IP09, IP14 and IP13A from B. rapa) and two from B. napus in the UK (R1 and P003), was screened. Sixteen differential host response groups to these isolates (classified as groups A‐P) were identified. Groups‘A’and‘B’expressed the widest resistance profiles to these isolates. Group‘A’was susceptible to isolates IP05 and IP05B, moderately resistant to isolate IP33 and resistant to all other isolates. Group‘B’was susceptible to isolates IP03, IP04 and IP04A, and resistant to the other isolates. Putative homozygous lines resistant to all 14 isolates were selected from the F₄ progeny of crosses involving lines RESBJ‐200 from group‘A’(selection from cv. Kranti) and RESBJ‐190 from group‘B’(selection from cv. Krishna). Both selections were selfed and tested for uniformity of reactions to all isolates for three generations. The resistance of RESBJ‐200 to isolates IP00A, IP04A and IP33A seems to be conditioned by single dominant genes. The resistance of RESBJ‐190 to isolates IP00A, IP05B and IP33A was also conditioned by single dominant genes. The gene for resistance to IP00A and IP33A in RESBJ‐200 seems to be independent of the genes for resistance to the same isolates in RESBJ‐190. The new genes for differential resistance to P. parasitica will be of value in future studies of the genetics of the host‐pathogen interaction and for breeding for disease resistance.     

QTL mapping of net blotch resistance genes in a doubled-haploid population of six-rowed barley

Net blotch, caused by Pyrenophora teres f. teres, is a damaging foliar disease of barley worldwide. It is important to identify resistance germplasm and study their genetics. 'Chevron', a six-rowed barley used as a parent for the production of a doubled haploid (DH) population for mapping of Fusarium head blight (FHB) resistance, was also found to be resistant to net blotch. To map the resistance genes, the population was evaluated for resistance at the seedling stage in a greenhouse. The resistance data showed a two-peak distribution. Through linkage mapping, one resistance gene, tentatively called Rpt, was located on chromosome 6HS flanked by Xksua3b-Xwg719d, which was also detected by QTL mapping. This QTL explained 64% of the phenotypic variance for the resistance in this DH population. In addition, a minor QTL was found on chromosome 2HS defined by Xcdo786-Xabc156a. 'Chevron' and 'Stander' contributed the resistant alleles of Rpt and the 2HS QTL, respectively. Both QTLs together explained nearly 70% of the phenotypic variance. The markers for these QTLs are useful for marker-assisted selection of net blotch resistance in barley breeding.     

Resistance to powdery mildew in selections from Moroccan barley landraces

Seventy-five barley landraces from Morocco were tested for resistance to powdery mildew and a number of different resistance genes were detected. Thirty-five isolates of Blumeria graminis f. sp. hordei and the Pallas isoline differential set were used. Isolates used in the experiment had virulences corresponding to all major resistance genes used in Europe. Forty-four of the tested landraces showed resistant reactions. From each of these landraces, one to five resistant plants were selected and 92 single plant lines were created. Six lines selected from 3landraces were assumed to carry the mlo gene but they were discarded after microscopic investigation. Seventeen lines were tested in the seedling stage with 17isolates and another 69 lines were tested with 23 differential isolates. These lines showed 71 reaction spectra to isolates of powdery mildew. Eight lines (9%), 255-3-3, 282-3-4, 286-1-1, 294-2-3,294-2-4, 295-1-2, 308-1-2 and 327-2-1, selected from 7 landraces showed resistance to all isolates. Seventy-eight lines (90%) showed a resistant infection type 2with more than 50% of the isolates used. In most of the selected lines (86%) unknown genes, alone or in combination with known specific resistance genes, were detected. Four different resistance alleles (Mlat, Mla6, Mla14 and Mla1) were postulated to be present in the tested lines. The most common was Mlat, which was postulated in 35 (41%) lines. The use of newly identified sources of powdery mildew resistance in barley breeding is discussed. This revised version was published online in August 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

The resistance to leaf rust and powdery mildew of recombinant lines of barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) derived from H. vulgare × H. bulbosum crosses

A set of 23 recombinant lines (RLs) of barley ( Hordeum vulgare L.) derived from H. vulgare  ×  H. bulbosum L. crosses was inoculated with barley leaf rust ( Puccinia hordei ) and powdery mildew ( Blumeria graminis f.sp. hordei ) at the seedling stage to identify their levels and mechanisms of resistance. Eight RLs were studied further in glasshouse and field tests. All three barley parents ('Emir', 'Golden Promise' and 'Vada') were highly susceptible to powdery mildew and leaf rust isolates. Several RLs showed partial resistance expressed as high relative latency periods and low relative infection frequencies against leaf rust. This high level of partial resistance was due to a very high level of early aborting colonies without host cell necrosis. Several RLs showed hypersensitive resistance to some or all isolates. For powdery mildew, one RL was completely resistant to the CC1 isolate and had a hypersensitive resistance to the CO-02 isolate. Three RLs derived from 'Emir' were completely resistant to both powdery mildew isolates, and three more RLs tested in the field had higher levels of partial resistance than their parents. The results indicate that H. bulbosum contains major and minor gene(s) for resistance to leaf rust and powdery mildew that can be transferred to cultivated barley.     

Genotype × environment interactions in the expression of net blotch resistance in spring and winter barley varieties

The net blotch resistance of barley varieties widely grown in Denmark was studied using data obtained from naturally infected field plots and inoculated disease nurseries in multiple years and locations. Data were analysed by combining two statistical procedures, 1) joint regression (JR) and 2) additive main effect, multiplicative interactive effect analysis (AMMI). Of the total variation for net blotch disease severity, 61–81% could be explained by plant genotype (G) and environment (E) main effects. Of the remaining variation, 77–86% could be explained by significant G × E interactions that were due to genotype sensitivity to the mean environmental disease level and/or to specific reactions of individual genotypes in particular environments. G × E interactions led to a different ranking of varietal performance across environments. There was evidence for G × E interactions caused by the virulence characteristics of the initial inoculum sources. The spring barley varieties Alexis and Bartok and the winter barley varieties Jolante, Ludo, and Rafiki were identified as varieties with high levels of net blotch resistance in all environments. Their performance was little affected by G × E interactions, suggesting that they represent good sources for non-specific resistance. Combining JR and AMMI reduced the dimensionality of complex G × E problems greatly, identified systematic reaction patterns of varieties possibly pertaining to different resistance mechanisms, and described specific and non-specific resistance of varieties by means of few parameters while maintaining the possibility to reconstruct the original data with little loss of information. This is very useful for improving the evaluation of varietal resistance for breeding and disease management purposes. This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Distorted Segregation for Mildew Resistance in Doubled Haploid Lines of Spring Barley

The mildew reactions of the second generation of doubled haploid (DH) plants, derived from anther culture of crosses among three spring barley lines carrying different Mla mildew resistance alleles and the cv. ‘Pallas’, were analyzed by using a set of three European and one Israeli mildew isolate. The results indicated, (1) a significant level of distortion segregation in favour of resistant DH genotypes, which was possibly due to linkage of mildew resistance genes on chromosome 5 with genes for plant regeneration and (2) various degrees of dominance for the different resistance genes studied as well as the possible action of modifier genes.     

Identification of RAPD markers closely linked to the mlo-locus in barley

Developing resistance to powdery mildew, Erysiphe graminis f.sp. hordei, is a major goal of many barley breeding programmes. Several resistance genes have been tagged or mapped with molecular markers. The mlo gene confers durable resistance towards all known isolates of the pathogen. In this study, RAPD markers and bulked segregant analysis were used to determine PCR-based markers linked to the mlo-locus. Sixty doubled haploid lines from a cross between an isogenic line of ‘Ingrid’ carrying the mlo11 allele and a susceptible cv. ‘Pokko’ were used as plant material. Seven linked RAPD markers were found, the closest lying 1.6 cM away from the resistance gene. When eight barley varieties were assayed for the presence of this band, F4-980, it was found in the resistant varieties but not in the susceptible ones. The linked marker bands could be amplified from DNA-samples prepared by using three different methods, including a quick squash technique. PCR-based markers linked to the resistance gene can be used as tools for selection in breeding programmes.