An evaluation of the contribution of hatchery stocking on population density and biomass: a lesson from masu salmon juveniles within a Japanese river system

Stocking is an important management tool for enhancing fisheries resources, but its actual contribution to fisheries resources is controversial, taking into consideration both the positive and negative effects. This study compared density and biomass of hatchery (otolith thermal marked) and wild masu salmon parr between stocked and unstocked rivers to evaluate the contribution of stocking with hatchery‐reared fish. Density and biomass of all fish did not differ between stocked and unstocked rivers. Moreover, density and biomass of wild fish in the stocked rivers were lower than those of the unstocked rivers. Density and biomass of hatchery fish in a non‐natural reproducing river were similar with those of all fish in natural reproducing rivers. These results indicate that hatchery stocking does not have positive effects on population density or biomass but replaces wild fish with hatchery fish and that non‐natural reproducing areas are more suitable as stocking sites.     

Modelling the impacts of removing seal predation from Atlantic salmon, Salmo salar, rivers in Scotland: a tool for targeting conflict resolution

Abstract  Bioenergetics were used to model the potential impacts on adult Atlantic salmon, Salmo salar L., stocks and rod fisheries of removing harbour seals, Phoca vitulina L., from three rivers of different scales in the Moray Firth, Scotland, viz: the Spey (large), Conon (medium) and Moriston (small). Overall, seals had the greatest impact on the Moriston, where removal of a single animal could increase cumulative catch by 17% during the fishing season. On the Conon and Spey the impacts were negligible, and resulted in increased catches of <1% annually. On all rivers eliminating seal predation had the greatest impact during the spring due to the smaller size of spring salmon sub-stocks. A generalised model of seal removal illustrated that stocks and catches increased by >33% in rivers with monthly rod catches ≤10 fish, but declined to <10% for rivers with catches >34 fish. The outputs of the models are qualitative, but provide a management tool for targeting action to resolve seal-salmon fishery conflict. Smaller salmon population units, and spring salmon sub-stocks and fisheries in particular, are most vulnerable to predation. The merit of this approach is discussed regarding the management of Special Areas of Conservation for salmon and seals.     

A Desk Study of the Performance of Trout Fisheries in a Selection of British Reservoirs

Routine statistics have been analysed from a varied selection of 18 British reservoir fisheries The numbers and weights of fish caught have been compared with the numbers and weights stocked. In lowland reservoirs the “put and take” system of management is used and annual stocking rates of 40–60 fish ha^-1 (c 12 kg ha^-1) give catches of 20–30 fish ha^-1 (c 20 kg ha^-1). Higher stocking rates lead to greater catches numerically but to relatively little increase in the weight of catch per unit area. In general, the recapture of rainbow trout is greater than that of brown trout, relative to the numbers stocked. The management of upland reservoirs is complicated by the presence of indigenous trout, poorer growing conditions and lack of research into the population dynamics of fish populations in such places. A wide variety of management possibilities exist in upland reservoirs and these are worthy of thorough investigation. Stocking at rates comparable to those used in lowland reservoirs takes negligible advantage of the potential for natural trout growth in upland reservoirs and the economics of this practice would repay closer analysis.     

The large‐scale stocking of young anadromous whitefish (Coregonus lavaretus) and corresponding catches of returning spawners in the River Tornionjoki,northern Baltic Sea

Stocking and fishing effort are two important potentially conflicting factors in fish stock management that require appropriate assessment to ensure a sustainable fishery. In the River Tornionjoki, which discharges into the northern Baltic Sea, a summer‐ascending whitefish, Coregonus lavaretus L., stock has long been a target by traditional dipnet fishing. Enhancement stocking of young whitefish started in the River Tornionjoki in the 1970s after a collapse in catches, with millions of age‐0 whitefish stocked annually in the river, but after about three decades, the stocking rates were considerably reduced. As a result, dipnet catches of whitefish in the Kukkolankoski Rapids rose simultaneously, peaking in the 1980s and 1990s, and then subsequently decreased. There was a significant positive correlation between stocking intensity and catch, both in weight and in numbers, revealing a strong relationship between whitefish releases and dipnet catch. Changes in gillnet fishing effort in the sea affected dipnet catches in weight as well as in mean size of captured whitefish. When the combined effect of stocking and gillnet effort was evaluated, only stocking significantly affected dipnet catches.     

Effect of supplementary stocking of juvenile brown trout,Salmo trutta,on yield in a Norwegian mountain reservoir

Abstract The effect of supplementary stocking of juvenile (age 0+), hatchery‐reared, brown trout, Salmo trutta L., on annual yields was assessed in a Norwegian mountain reservoir between 1979 and 2007. Fishing was mainly carried out by local fishermen with benthic gillnets. During the study period, annual stocking ranged from 0 to 52 500 fish (19.8 ha^?1). No stocking has been carried out since 1997. Annual yield varied from 1650 to 5653 kg, corresponding to 0.62–2.13 kg ha^?1. Exploitation rate in terms of number of gillnets and mean weight of 6+ fish (age when catchable size was reached) explained 64% of the variability in catches. Stocked fish contributed very little to the yield or catch‐per‐unit‐effort, exhibiting no positive correlation with stocking density. The lack of contribution from stocked fish was probably caused by a competitive bottleneck in the eroded epibenthic zone, causing high juvenile mortality. If stocking continues, it is recommended that fish with body lengths >15–20 cm are used.     

Conservation of endemic landlocked salmonids in regulated rivers: a case‐study from Lake Vänern,Sweden

Conservation of migratory salmonids requires understanding their ecology at multiple scales, combined with assessing anthropogenic impacts. We present a case‐study from over 100 years of data for the endemic landlocked Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar, Salmonidae) and brown trout (Salmo trutta, Salmonidae) in Lake Vänern, Sweden. We use this case‐study to develop life history‐based research and monitoring priorities for migratory salmonids. In Vänern, small wild populations of salmon and trout remain only in the heavily regulated Rivers Klar (Klarälven) and Gullspång (Gullspångsälven), and commercial and sport fisheries are maintained by hatchery stocking. These populations represent some of the last remaining large‐bodied (up to 20 kg) landlocked salmon stocks worldwide. We found that one of four stocks of wild fish has increased since 1996; the other three remain critically low. Hatchery return rates for three of four stocks appear stable at roughly 1% and annual fisheries catch is roughly 75 metric tons, with an estimated 7.5% of hatchery smolts being recruited to the fishery; this also appears relatively stable since 1990. Our analysis reveals much uncertainty in key data requirements, including both river return and fisheries catch rates, estimates of wild smolt production and survival, and hatchery breeding and genetics protocols. These uncertainties, coupled with a lack of information on their riverine and lacustrine ecology, preclude effective management of these unique populations. We conclude with a framework for a life history‐based approach to research and monitoring for Vänern salmon and trout, which should be applicable for all endemic, migratory salmonid populations.     

Population characteristics of channel catfish near the northern edge of their distribution: implications for management

Channel catfish, Ictalurus punctatus (Rafinesque), populations in six lakes in northern Idaho, USA, were sampled to describe their population characteristics. During the summers of 2011 and 2012, 4864 channel catfish were sampled. Channel catfish populations had low to moderate catch rates, and length structure was dominated by fish <400 mm. Channel catfish were in good body condition. All populations were maintained by stocking age‐1 or age‐2 fish. Growth of fish reared in thermally enriched environments prior to stocking was fast compared to other North American channel catfish populations. After stocking, growth of channel catfish declined rapidly. Once stocked, cold water temperatures, prey resources and (or) genetic capabilities limited growth. Total annual mortality of age 2 and older channel catfish was generally <40%. Tag returns indicated that angler exploitation was low, varying from 0 to 43% among lakes. This research provides insight on factors regulating channel catfish population dynamics and highlights important considerations associated with their ecology and management.     

The effects of stocking Atlantic salmon, Salmo salar, in a Norwegian regulated river

Abstract  Stocking is undertaken in the River Suldalslågen, western Norway, to compensate for an estimated annual loss of 20 000 Atlantic salmon smolts, Salmo salar L., caused by regulating the river for hydropower production. The annual contribution to angling catches from stocked hatchery fish varied from 7 to 334 kg, or <15% of the total number caught. Between 160 000 and 250 000 one-summer old fish were stocked, but only between 6 and 10 (<0.005%) were recaptured as adults in the river. Recaptured stocked fish never exceeded 0.03% by number, despite smolts dominating the stocking material in recent years. It is not certain whether the slight increase in catches comes in addition to or at the expense of natural reproduction. In most years more adults were used as parent stock than were caught as offspring. The lack of positive response to stocking is possibly due to lesser age, smaller size and later migration of hatchery smolts, and that seawater tolerance of hatchery smolts is poorly developed, all factors increasing mortality at sea.     

Efficiency of Northern pike (Esox lucius) stocking in metropolitan France at large spatial and temporal scales

Stocking and electrofishing occurrence and abundance data for northern pike Esox lucius L. in >3800 km of French rivers across 7 years were compared to assess the effect of recreational fisheries stocking programmes on wild pike populations. A positive relationship was found between the additive effect of stocking and the size of the stocked pike. However, the stocking programmes implemented in France by recreational fishery managers from 2008 to 2013 increased the probability of pike occurring in the river network, without increasing abundance in well-established pike populations, because pike stocked in their early-life stages were used in most of the stocking programmes.     

The effects of the net fishery closure on angling catch in the River Hvítá, Iceland

Between 1991 and 2000, angling associations on the tributaries of the River Hvítá leased net fishery rights in the Hvítá mainstem, with the aim of eliminating net fishery harvest and improving the rod catch. The rod catch and net catch in the Hvítá system were significantly correlated (r = 0.94; P < 0.001) over the 10‐year period prior to (1981–1990) closure of the net fishery. The rod fishery in the tributaries of the River Hvítá was also significantly correlated to the rod fishery in selected groups of rivers in west (r = 0.80; P < 0.01) and north (r = 0.73; P < 0.05) before the closure. Significant increases (P < 0.01) were observed in rod catches in the Hvítá tributaries between 1991 and 2000 after the closure, while rod catches in control regions decreased. Based on evaluation of rod catch trends before and after the closure, it was estimated that the net fishery lease increased rod catches in the tributaries between 1773 and 2175 fish (28–35%). The increase in rod catches also suggested that the rod fishery may be taking 39–52% of the estimated previous net catch. The high price paid annually for the net fishery lease just to eliminate net fishing (€135 000) reflects the high value of rod caught salmon compared with salmon caught by the net fishery.     

Impact of stocked Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar L.) on habitat use by the wild population

Laffaille P. Impact of stocked Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar L.) on habitat use by the wild population.
Ecology of Freshwater Fish 2011: 20: 67–73. © 2010 John Wiley & Sons A/S Abstract – We investigated the summer habitat occupied by populations of young‐of‐the‐year wild and stocked (farmed populations released into the native range) Atlantic salmon under allopatric and sympatric conditions. Under allopatric conditions, farmed and wild salmon occupied habitats with the same characteristics. The salmon preferentially occupied the riffle areas. However, under sympatric conditions, the fish occupied meso‐ and micro‐habitats with different characteristics. Wild salmon avoided habitats used by farmed salmon and preferred glide areas with considerable vegetation cover. This study suggests that differences in the pattern of habitats used by young Atlantic salmon were both size‐ and origin‐dependent and may result from intra‐species competition between farmed and wild populations. Given that stocking with farmed Atlantic salmon is carried out intensively to enhance recreational angling or to conserve salmon populations, this study warns that this can have a negative impact on the extant wild Atlantic salmon population.     

Quantifying contributions to tournament catches among resident,stocked and hybrid black basses (Micropterus spp.)

Millions of Florida bass, Micropterus floridanus Lesueur, are stocked annually into populations of largemouth bass, Micropterus salmoides Lacepède, to increase trophy fish abundance. However, little effort has related the role that resultant hybrids make to angler catches. Largemouth bass were sampled from an important recreational fishery subject to extensive Florida bass stocking to address the hypothesis that anglers capture Florida bass, largemouth bass and hybrids at rates equivalent to their overall abundance in the population. Fin clips obtained from tournament angling events (n = 348) and boat‐mounted electrofishing sampling (n = 219) were screened at 38 species‐diagnostic markers and individuals were assigned to genealogical classes using Bayesian clustering algorithms. No significant differences were identified between angler and electrofishing catches providing evidence that hybridised individuals stemming from a long‐term stocking programme may constitute an important contribution to tournament angling catch.     

Eel, Anguilla anguilla L., stock and yield in Polish lakes

Abstract. Details of mean annual slocking rate and catch of eels in a random sample of 68 Polish lakes over a period of 36 years are presented. Multiple correlation and curvilinear regressions are used to assess the effectiveness of stocking. Maximum stocking rate of 275 elvers/ha/year and maximum catch of 5.2 kg/ha were determined. Yields per recruit were highest in the lakes in which the greatest catches of other fish were made and stocking was most effective in lakes of depth less than 5 m.
The theoretical maximum catch of 5.2kg/ha was very much less than maxima observed elsewhere. Two possible contributory factors are the Polish practice of using relatively large-meshed seines for fishing, permitting the escape of eels of less than 50cm and the relatively small number of potential competing fish species in fisheries such as that of Lough Neagh in Ireland.     

Angling Success for Atlantic Salmon (Salmo salar) in the River Wye in Relation to Effort and River Flows

Salmon catch and effort data for 1977 from ten private fisheries on the River Wye are analysed and discussed. The 555 salmon caught represent 10.7% of the total Wye rod catch and the mean angling success rate of 0.045 ± 0.022 salmon per angler-hour, equivalent to about 22 h per salmon, compares favourably with that for other rivers in Britain and Canada. Over 75% of all salmon caught were 2 sea-winter fish, the age distribution of salmon caught in the sample being similar to those for the whole river. Angling success in the upper reaches during July and August may have been reduced by limited availability affected by water temperatures too high for migration, Flows most suitable for successful angling in each fishery are compared in relation to distance from the estuary and long-term average daily flows. Salmon appeared to be caught nearer the crest of a spate in the upper compared with the lower reaches of the river and this difference is discussed.     

Assessing the long-term genetic impact of historical stocking events on contemporary populations of Atlantic salmon, Salmo salar

Abstract  Supplementation of wild fish with non-native or domesticated fish is common practice. However, these stocked and native fish differ both ecologically and genetically and, in the wild, they interact in a multitude of ways, often with negative repercussions for the native population. This study assessed the long-term genetic impact of historical stocking activities on a contemporary population of Atlantic salmon, Salmo salar L. During the 1960s salmon from hatcheries in Scotland and Iceland were transplanted to the River Dart, England. Microsatellite loci were used to assess the current level of population admixture between samples taken from the source location of the stocked fish during the 1960s and contemporary Dart populations. After allowances were made for natural genetic relationships between donor and recipient populations, the long-term impact of the historical stocking events on a catchment scale appears minimal. However, one tributary consistently reflected closer genetic relationships with the donor populations, indicating a possible long-term impact on a localised scale.     

Current status of natural spawning of chum salmon <Emphasis Type="Italic">Oncorhynchus keta</Emphasis> in rivers with or without hatchery stocking on the Japan Sea side of northern Honshu,Japan

Information on the status of natural spawning is needed on the Japan Sea side of northern Honshu, Japan for ecosystem-based sustainable management of chum salmon resources. We conducted on-site visual surveys in October–December of 2015 and 2016 that targeted spawning chum salmon redds in all rivers?>?5 km long (total 94 rivers) in Akita, Yamagata, Niigata (including Sado Island), and Toyama prefectures. The ratio of rivers found to host natural reproduction to the total number of surveyed rivers was 93.6% (44/47) in stocked rivers and 74.5% (35/47) in non-stocked rivers. These results show that there is a wide occurrence of natural reproduction of chum salmon in these rivers, regardless of the history of hatchery stocking. The density of spawning redds (number of redds/1000 m²) as an indicator of chum salmon escapements did not differ (P?=?0.54) between stocked rivers (mean 3.5, N ?=?49) and non-stocked rivers (mean 2.4, N? =?36),when rivers where no redds were observed were excluded from the analysis. These results suggest that chum salmon escapements into non-stocked rivers may not be negligible. Conservation measures for wild fish are needed in stocked and non-stocked rivers to promote enhancement programs based on natural reproduction.     

Changes in commercially exploited populations of tench, Tinca tinca (L.) in lakes of Northeastern Poland

Commercially exploited tench populations in 755 lakes in the Northeastern part of Poland were observed on the basis of the fishing data from 1951 to 1994. The observations were analyzed in five size categories of water reservoirs, whose total area reached over 123,900 ha. The analyses were performed according to the parameter of a commercial fish catch per area unit, taking into consideration the number of months per year when the lakes were exploited. Statistically significant differences were determined in the mean value of the tench catch parameter between the different size categories of lakes. Similar time-related differences were observed. In the lakes >100 ha the relative tench catch gradually declined in the successive time intervals. Tench was the rarest in catches from lakes <50 ha. The complete disappearance of tench from commercial catches occurred first as early as the late 1960s in lakes <200 ha. The largest quantities of tench stocking material were introduced to the lakes from 1951 to 1972. The amount of stocking material per 1 ha of stocked lakes decreased for larger lakes. The average frequency of tench stocking in the analyzed lakes was higher in larger lake size categories. On the other hand, in each lake size group the frequency of stocking was found to have declined along with the average volume of the stocking material in the subsequent 11-year-long periods.     

Otter (Lutra lutra) predation on stocked brown trout (Salmo trutta) in two Danish lowland rivers

Abstract –  This study aimed to evaluate otter predation on stocked trout. Large hatchery-reared trout (16–30 cm) were stocked into two Danish rivers with different fish populations. Otter diet before and after trout stocking was determined by analysing 685 spraints, collected regularly during the 35-day study period. Fish composition in the rivers before stocking was assessed by electrofishing. In River Trend, a typical trout river, the proportion of trout in the otter diet increased from 8% before stocking to 33% a few days after stocking. Moreover, trout lengths in the diet changed significantly towards the lengths of stocked trout, indicating that newly stocked trout were preferred to wild trout. In River Skals, dominated by cyprinids, there was no change in otter diet after stocking of hatchery trout, i.e., these were ignored by otter. Otter predation should be taken into account together with fish and bird predation, when stocking is used as a measure for conserving endangered salmonid populations.     

Variation in the population density of adult sea-trout, Salmo trutta, in 67 rivers in England and Wales

Abstract– Analysis of annual rod and commercial catches of adult seatrout demonstrated strong positive relationships between large-scale spatial variance (S²_s, variation in catches between rivers for each year) and spatial mean density (x?_s, mean catch per year), and also between temporal variance (S²_t, variation in catches between years for each river) and temporal mean density (x?_t, mean catch for each river). Both relationships were described by a power function, s²=ax^-b. For spatial variability, there were no significant differences between power functions for both rod and commercial catches from the North West, Welsh and South West regions. As the power b was not significantly different from two, relative spatial variability (measured by coefficients of variation (CV)) was fairly constant between years. Significantly higher values of b were obtained for the Wessex (GM b= 2.233) and North East (GM b=2.824) regions, and therefore the increase in CV with mean annual catch was significant but slight for Wessex rivers and marked for North East rivers. For temporal variability, there were no significant differences between power functions for both rod and commercial catches from all 5 regions and therefore a common power function was fitted to the data from all 67 rivers. As the power b was significantly less than two (GM b= 1.729), relative temporal variability (measured by CV) decreased significantly with increasing mean catch per river. Some limitations and implications of this analysis are discussed. Similar results from different regions for both rod and commercial catches suggest that such data do reflect adult population density, in spite of the different methods used to catch the sea-trout, variations in fishing effort and failures to report catches. The analysis of temporal variability provides a basis for classifying the major sea-trout rivers according to their mean annual catch and their relative variability in catches between years (using the CV).     

Comparison of Atlantic salmon, Salmo salar L., stocks exploited by commercial fisheries in the Adour Basin, France at the end of the 19th and 20th centuries

Abstract. The characteristics of the commercial catches of Atlantic salmon, Salmo salar L., in the Adour-Gaves Basin at the end of the 19th and 20th centuries were compared with regard lo age structure and mean weight-at-age. A visual analysis of the monthly weight distributions determined an age structure for the 20th century data which was proved to be consistent with the one obtained by scale-reading, ft was therefore used to study the 19th century weight frequency data. Age structure comparison showed a decrease in mean sea age between the two periods (most catches with one sea winter in the 1985-1990 period, instead of two sea winters in the 1873-1898 period). In addition, a drastic decline of the three-sea-winter salmon stock and the almost total disappearance of the four-sea-winter fish was noted between the two periods. The mean weight of one-sea-winter salmon seemed not to have changed while those of multi-sea-winter fish showed a slight decrease between the two periods. The main causes of those changes could have been the reduction of spawning areas due to the building of impassable dams, the dramatic increase in industrial pollution in both upper and lower parts of the rivers, and the exploitation of multi-sea-winter fish in sea fisheries.