Analysis of fat-soluble vitamins. XXII. High performance liquid chromatographic determination of vitamin D in concentrates. Collaborative study

A collaborative study was carried out which compared the official chemical method (43.B14-43.B24), the HPLC method according to Hofsass et al. including maleic anhydride treatment, and the HLPC procedure according to De Vries et al. for vitamin D concentrates. A total of 396 samples were distributed to 33 collaborators for analysis. Five laboratories performed both the chemical and the HPLC methods. Five laboratories performed the Hofsass method and 16 laboratories performed the De Vries method. The results for the chemical method agreed with the theoretical values for the samples, and the standard deviation was comparable to that obtained in previous AOAC collaborative studies. Collaborative results for the Hofsass method were low. In addition, incorrect use of a fixed conversion factor (1/0.586) and necessity of a double chromatogrpahic system on a non-treated and a treated vitamin D sample reduce the effectiveness of the method. There were no adverse reactions to the DE Vries HPLC method. It is recommended that the method be adopted official first action as an alternative procedure for determining vitamin D in concentrates, excluding powders containing irradiated 7-dehydrocholesterol.     

Analysis of fat-soluble vitamins. XIX. Collaborative studies on the chemical assay for vitamin D concentrates

In 1971, a chemical method for the assay of vitamin D in concentrates containing only vitamin D was collaboratively studied by 14 laboratories, using 6 different samples from 2 European manufacturers. On the basis of these results, the laboratories were divided into 2 groups: 5 with significant laboratory biases of greater than or equal to 2%, and 9 laboratories with nonsignificant bias. The 9 laboratories were subdivided into 2 groups which differed significantly as to reproducibility within laboratories. The reproducibility between laboratories, expressed as a standard deviation in per cent with 95% confidence limits, was 1.2% (confidence range 0.6-7.3) and 4.7% (confidence range 2.4-29.3) for 3 and 6 laboratories, respectively. A second collaborative test was performed in 1974, using 12 vitamin D resin samples in oil from 3 United States manufacturers, to compare 2 chemical vitamin D assay methods (with and without maleic anhydride) and to compare results from the chemical and biological methods; 9 laboratories participated in the chemical method study and 3 in the rat bioassay study. The correlation of results of the chemical method including maleic anhydride treatment and the rat bioassays was satisfactory. The reproducibility of the chemical method was about the same as that in the first collaborative test.     

Analysis of fat-soluble vitamins. XX. Determination of vitamin D in multivitamin preparations. Second collaborative study.

The official first action method for determining vitamin D in multivitamin preparations was modified. The method was collaboratively studied by 7 laboratories, using 6 preparations in oil. The preparations consisted of vitamin D at various levels and at various ratios (in w/w) in vitamin A. Three samples contained cholecalciferol and 3 samples contained vitamin D3 from vitamin D3 resin. After outliers were eliminated by the Dixon test, data were analyzed and averages were compared with amounts of vitamin D known to be in each sample. For samples with vitamin D: vitamin A ratios of 1:0.5, 1:5, and 1:10, the mean vitamin D recoveries were 98.8, 94.6, and 90.7%, respectively. The method has been adopted as official final action.     

High-pressure liquid chromatographic determination of vitamin D3 in resins, oils, dry concentrates, and dry concentrates containing vitamin A.

A high-pressur liquid chromatographic (HPLC) procedure has been developed for the determination of vitamin D3 in resins, oils, dry concentrates, and dry concentrates containing vitamin A. Specificity of the method for vitamin D3 in the presence of isomers and other related constituents was shown by ultimate recovery of the vitamin D3 and the individual constituents and their characterization by other methods such as ultraviolet spectrophotometry. Precision and accuracy are within 2%, and as many as 20 determinations may be completed in a working day. Excellent agreement with the official AOAC biological assay was found. A comparison of the response of isomers of vitamin D3 by the HPLC method vs. other instrumental and chemical procedures shows HPLC to be the most specific method for determining the bioactive isomers.     

Analysis of fat-soluble vitamins. XXVIII. High performance liquid chromatographic determination of vitamin D in pet foods and feeds: collaborative study

A high performance liquid chromatographic (HPLC) method for vitamin D in pet foods and feeds at low concentrations (2-8 IU/g = 50-200 ppb) was studied collaboratively. The procedure consists of the following purification steps: saponification, extraction of the unsaponifiable fraction, chromatography on alumina, cleanup on reverse phase HPLC, and quantitation with straight phase HPLC. The original method, developed by Knapstein, was simplified by deleting the quantitative TLC step. Six coded samples were distributed to 31 laboratories, along with a known sample containing 15 IU/g to allow practice of the rather complicated procedure. Eighteen collaborators returned their results. Results for the spiked samples show good recovery. The estimates of repeatability and reproducibility are 0.96 and 2.2 IU/g for spiked samples and 1.5 and 3.1 IU/g for commercial samples, respectively, which are considered acceptable for these low concentrations. The method has been adopted official first action.     

Determination of crude protein in animal feeds, using block digestion followed by steam distillation: collaborative study.

A method consisting of digesting animal feeds in a block digestor and determining ammonia by steam distillation followed by titration has been evaluated and compared with the official final action Kjeldahl method, 7.016. Fifteen laboratories analyzed 5 feed samples and lysine monohydrochloride. Statistical analysis showed that results from the 2 methods were comparable. The distillation technique has been adopted as official first action as an alternative technique for ammonia determination from the digest of the official final action block digestor method, 7.B11.     

Analysis of fat-soluble vitamins. XXIX. Liquid chromatographic determination of vitamin D in AD concentrates: collaborative study

A simplified liquid chromatographic (LC) method for determining vitamin D in vitamin AD concentrates (greater than or equal to 5000 IU vitamin D/g) was collaboratively studied. In the simplified method, the 2 columns specified in AOAC LC method 43.101-43.109 are replaced by a single column, which separates the vitamin D isomers and the vitamin A esters. The procedure for oils includes dissolution and quantitation by normal phase LC. Dry multivitamin concentrates and aqueous dispersions are treated with an enzyme system and the vitamins are extracted with n-pentane. Six coded samples were distributed to 16 laboratories; 15 collaborators returned their results. Estimates of repeatability and reproducibility for the oil samples were 1.1 and 3.1%, respectively; for the high-level concentrated dry preparation 1.4 and 3.9% and for the low-level concentrated dry preparation 1.3 and 11.4%, respectively. These values are a considerable improvement over the results obtained in the 1979 multivitamin collaborative study. The method has been adopted official first action for determination of vitamin D in vitamin AD concentrates containing greater than or equal to 5000 IU vitamin D/g.     

Microbiological plate and turbidimetric assays of chlortetracycline in feeds: collaborative study.

The manual and automated turbidimetric assays and a modified official plate assay for chlortetracycline (CTC-HCl) in feed were collaboratively studied. Three feed samples (swine feed, 100 g CTC-HCl/ton; premix I, 20 g each of CTC-HCl and sulfamethazine/lb, and 10 g penicillin/lb; and premix II, 50 g CTC-HCl/lb) were analyzed at 2 dilutions. Twelve laboratories conducted the plate assay; 8 laboratories the manual turbidimetric method; and 7 laboratories, the Autoturb analysis. Within a method, there was no significant difference between dilutions. Between methods, there was a significant difference between the manual turbidimetric plate assays only for swine feed. However, the same sample dilutions or the average values of the 2 dilutions for both methods showed no statistical difference. Among the collaborators, the slope of CTC-HCl standard curve varied between about 2.0 and 3.0 for the plate method. The turbidimetric assay has been adopted as official first action for feeds containing larger than or equal to 20 g CTC-HCl/lb.     

Automated method for the determination of niacin and niacinamide in cereal products: collaborative study.

In a collaborative study, an automated method for the determination of niacin and niacinamide in cereal products was compared with the official final action microbiological (43.121-43.125) and chemical (43.044-43.046) methods. Ten samples of cereal products, including enriched flour, yeast-leavened baked products, fortified breakfast cereals, and baked pet food products, were submitted to 14 laboratories. Nine laboratories reported values by the automated method, 6 reported values by the microbiological method, and 7 reported values by the chemical method. The results from the microbiological method were not subjected to analysis of variance because of the unusually large between-laboratory variation. The between-laboratory coefficients of variation for the automated and chemical methods were 10.90 and 10.18%, on the basis of results from 7 and 4 laboratories, respectively. There was no significant (p greater than 0.05) difference between methods when results from the 4 laboratories who used both methods were compared. The automated chemical method has been adopted as official first action.     

High pressure liquid chromatographic determination of aflatoxins in corn.

A high pressure liquid chromatographic (HPLC) method is proposed for determining aflatoxins in corn. The sample is extracted with methanol-10% NaCl (4 + 1), pigments are precipitated with zinc acetate, and the extract is cleaned up on a small (2 g) silica gel column. Aflatoxins in the purified extract are resolved by normal phase HPLC on a microparticulate (10 micrometer) silica gel column with water-saturated chloroform-cyclohexane, acetonitrile solvent, and detected by fluorescence on a silica gel-packed flowcell. The method was compared with chloroform-water extraction of the official CB method on 15 samples of contaminated corn. In 5 of the 6 samples containing aflatoxins B1, B2, G1, and G2, methanol-10% NaCl extracted more aflatoxin than did cloroform-water, as measured both by HPLC and by thin layer chromatography. In samples containing only B1 and B2, the 2 extraction solvents were virtually equivalent. Agreement was good between HPLC and TLC for each extraction solvent. Average recovery of aflatoxins B1, B2, G1, and G2 added to yellow cornmeal at 3 levels was greater than 90%.     

Liquid chromatographic determination of vitamin D in milk and infant formula

Vitamin D2 or vitamin D3 is determined by liquid chromatography (LC) in milk and infant formula. Vitamin D is extracted from the saponified sample, passed through an amino-cyano LC cleanup column to remove major interferences, and quantitated using normal phase LC. Within-day precision is 4.5% relative standard deviation (RSD); the overall method RSD (reflecting technician-to-technician, day-to-day, and within-day variability) is 7.7%. Overspike recoveries averaged 97% for milk, 98% for milk-based infant formula, and 93% for soy-based infant formula. The performance of the method is compared with that of the official AOAC vitamin D method (rat bioassay). The method is applicable to the determination of vitamin D in milk and in the major milk- and soy-based infant formulas available in the United States. The method can quantitate (but not distinguish) either vitamin D2 or vitamin D3. The method is applicable to milk and infant formula samples containing between 100 and 1500 IU vitamin D/L. Sample throughput is between 4 and 8 replicates per day.     

Analysis of fat-soluble vitamins. XXI. High pressure liquid chromatographic assay methods for vitamin D in vitamin D concentrates.

Two high pressure liquid chromatographic methods, a straight and a reverse phase system, were developed and compared with the official (chemical) AOAC method for vitamin D concentrates. The effects of the systematic error and the reproducibility of using an internal or external standard were studied, as well as the effect of using peak height or peak height X retention time for calculating the potential vitamin D content. A method is given for determining the conversion factor to calculate previtamin D as vitamin D. Based on the results of the comparison, the following conditions were selected for collaborative study: straight phase, amyl alcohol-hexane mobile phase, external standard, and calculation of potency by peak height.     

Determination of sulfur amino acids and tryptophan in foods and food and feed ingredients: collaborative study

Samples of 4 foods, 1 animal feed, isolated soy protein, and beta-lactoglobulin were analyzed by 9 laboratories to determine concentrations of cysteine as cysteic acid, methionine as methionine sulfone, and tryptophan. Sulfur amino acids were determined by AOAC method 43.A08-43.A13 for food and feed ingredients, in which samples are oxidized with performic acid before protein hydrolysis with 6N HCl. Tryptophan was determined after protein hydrolysis with 4.2N NaOH. In both methods, free amino acids were separated by ion-exchange or reverse-phase chromatography. Each laboratory was provided with detailed methods and with sealed vials containing solutions of standards. Samples were analyzed in duplicate, and variation between laboratories was determined. Coefficients of variation between laboratories for the 6 samples ranged from 5.50 to 11.8% for methionine as methionine sulfoxide, 8.59 to 17.3% for cysteine as cysteic acid, and 3.87 to 16.1% for tryptophan. Amino acid recoveries were determined by analysis of beta-lactoglobulin and were based on expected levels of each amino acid obtained from amino acid sequence data. The mean recovery of cysteine was 97% with a range of 88-119%. For methionine, mean recovery was 98% (range 89-115%) and for tryptophan, 85% (range 59-102%). Method 43.A08-43.A13 for food and feed ingredients has been adopted official first action for determination of cysteine and methionine in processed foods. The alkaline hydrolysis method has been adopted official first action for determination of tryptophan in foods and food and feed ingredients.     

Bacillus stearothermophilus disk assay for detection of residual penicillins in milk: collaborative study

A collaborative study was performed on a Bacillus stearothermophilus paper disk method designed to detect residual levels of 4 antibiotic drugs in whole market milk. This method is a modification of an earlier procedure developed for the International Dairy Federation. Whole milk samples spiked at low levels with ampicillin, cephapirin, cloxacillin, and penicillin G were sent frozen to 11 collaborating laboratories with instructions to assay them promptly according to the method provided. Five of the laboratories reported inconclusive results due to technical difficulties encountered with the method. The 6 remaining laboratories all detected levels of 0.005-0.008 microgram or unit/mL for penicillin G, ampicillin, and cephapirin and 0.05-0.08 microgram/mL for cloxacillin. The most commonly used official methods, the Sarcina lutea (Micrococcus luteus) cylinder plate method and the Bacillus subtilis paper disk method, can detect levels of 0.01 and 0.05 unit penicillin G/mL, respectively. The B. stearothermophilus method is rapid, simple to perform, and more sensitive than present official methods. The method has been adopted as official first action for the detection of penicillins in milk.     

Collaborative study for the comparison of two methods for the determination of total cholesterol in multicomponent foods.

The gas chromatographic method for determining total cholesterol in multicomponent foods, collaboratively studied by the AOAC in 1974 (Method 1), has been evaluated by 9 collaborating laboratories and compared with the Interim Methodology Instructions No. 2 modified method (Method 2). The 5 samples selected for collaboration were deviled ham sandwich spread, vegetable beef stew, frozen chicken pot pie, frozen fish sticks, and mayonnaise. The recovery data were obtained from a sample of wheat germ oil spiked with 0.297% cholesterol as cholesteryl palmitate. Collaborators performed 2 replicate analyses on all samples by both methods. The statistical evaluation of the results showed that Method 1 is superior to Method 2. Average recoveries from the spiked wheat germ oil samples were 91.4% (9 laboratories) and 85.8% (7 laboratories) with coefficients of variation of 12.5 and 14.4%, respectively. Based on the collaborative results and statistical evaluation, Method 1 has been adopted as official first action.     

International mycotoxin check sample program: Part I. Report on laboratory performance for determination of aflatoxins B1, B2, G1, and G2 in raw peanut meal, deoiled peanut meal, and yellow corn meal

Three aflatoxin-contaminated samples (raw peanut meal, deoiled peanut meal, and yellow corn meal) were analyzed by 121 laboratories in 31 countries. Sufficient data were obtained to permit a statistical comparison of the performance of laboratories using the BF, CB, and EEC methods and those using high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) for quantitation. No significant differences were found between means for laboratories using these 4 methods for the analysis of raw peanut meal or yellow corn meal. However, for deoiled peanut meal, means were significantly different for laboratories using the BF method compared with the CB or EEC methods for B1 and B2, and for laboratories using the CB method compared with HPLC methods for G2.     

High pressure liquid chromatographic determination of carbohydrates in food products: evaluation of method

A high pressure liquid chromatographic (HPLC) method for determining 5 common carbohydrates in food products was evaluated. Reproducibility data were generated showing a relative standard deviation of 2.8%. Recovery studies on a variety of foods gave an average recovery of 98.8%. The HPLC data for 3 varieties of ready-to-eat cereals were compared with data from 4 independent laboratories using current AOAC chemical methods. The HPLC mean values differed from the chemical mean values by 3.2%.     

Determination of melengestrol acetate in bovine tissue: collaborative study.

Seven laboratories collaboratively studied a method for the assay of melengestrol acetate at the 0, 10, and 20 ppb levels in bovine fat, liver, muscle, and kidney. The study included fortification of tissue by each laboratory and analysis of fat samples taken from treated heifers which had endogenous levels of 0, 10, and 20 ppb melengestrol acetate. The multistep cleanup procedure used included extraction, solvent partition, column chromatography, and electron capture gas-liquid chromatographic, determination. Results of the study for muscle, liver, kidney, and fat showed that the method gave satisfactory recoveries and accuracy. In fat, the most critical tissue, recovery was greater than 93%. A statistical comparison of the results reported for fat tissue from treated heifers demonstrated that 5 of the 7 laboratories obtained similar results. The results produced by the method can be expected to be repeatable within and among laboratories. On the basis of the collaborative results the method has been adopted as official first action.     

Identification of d- or dl-alpha-tocopherol in pharmaceuticals, food supplements, or feed supplements: a collaborative study.

A collaborative study was conducted to evaluate a method for identifying d- or dl-alpha-tocopherol in pharmaceuticals, food supplements, or feed supplements. The sample is extracted and saponified, the extraneous color is removed by chromatography, and the sample is assayed for vitamin E. Optical rotations are determined before and after formation of the ferricyanide oxidation product. The specific optical rotation of the oxidation product is negligible for the dl-form and +25.5 degrees for the d-form. Statistical analysis of the data reported by 8 collaborators for the standard d-alpha-tocopheryl acetate and for 6 unknown samples indicates a significant interaction between laboratories and samples. The mean coefficients of variation among laboratories for the determinations of the corrected specific optical rotation of the standard and the rotation ratio for the unknown samples containing d-alpha-tocopherol were 11.7 and 21.6%, respectively, for all laboratories and 5.8 and 11.8%, respectively, for experienced laboratories. This identification test for vitamin E is acceptable for determining the form of vitamin E as either d or dl, but is not acceptable for accurately determining mixtures of the 2 forms. The method has been adopted as official first action for the identification of d- or dl-alpha-tocopherol.     

Collaborative study of a rapid method for determing aflatoxins in cottonseed products.

Eleven laboratories collaboratively studied a modification of the official final action AOAC method, 26.048-26.056, for determining aflatoxins in cottonseed products. An aflatoxin-negative meal, 6 contaminated meals, 4 contaminated meats (kernels) samples, and 2 ammonia-inactivated meals were used. Mean aflatoxin values, mug/kg, ranged from 6 to 223 (B1), 2 to 44 (B2), and 7 to 266 (total: B1 + B2). Only one laboratory reported a false-positive for the negative meal. The mean coefficients of variation for B1, B2, and total were 28, 56, and 29%, respectively, for meals; 35, 54, and 37%, respectively, for meats; and 35, 58 and 38%, respectively, for ammoniated meals. Statistical treatment of data from triplicate sets of meals and meats showed evidence for systematic error between laboratories. Since the modified method is considerably faster than the official method and yields precision estimates consistent with previous AOAC collaborative studies on determining aflatoxins, the method has been adopted as official first action.