Key Factors Affecting Reproductive Success of Thoroughbred Mares and Stallions on a Commercial Stud Farm

To evaluate factors contributing to fertility of thoroughbred mares, data from 3743 oestrous periods of 2385 mares were collected on a large thoroughbred farm in Ireland. Fourteen stallions (mean age 8.3 years; range 4–15 years) had bred 2385 mares (mean age 9.4 years; range 3–24 years). Maiden mares accounted for 12%, mares with a foal at foot for 64%, and barren, slipped or rested mares for 24% of the total. The mean pregnancy rate per cycle was 67.8% (68.6% in year 1 and 66.9% in year 2). Backward stepwise multivariable logistic regression analysis was utilized to develop two models to evaluate mare factors, including mare age, reproductive status, month of foaling, dystocia, month of cover, foal heat, cycle number, treatments, walk‐in status and stallion factors including stallion identity, stallion age, shuttle status, time elapsed between covers and high stallion usage on the per cycle pregnancy rate and pregnancy loss. Old age (p < 0.001) and cover within 20 days post‐partum (p < 0.003) were associated with lowered pregnancy rates. High mare age (p < 0.05) and barren, slipped or rested reproductive status (p = 0.05) increased the likelihood of pregnancy loss. Uterine inflammation or infection, if appropriately treated, did not affect fertility. Only high usage of stallions (used more than 21 times in previous week) was associated with lowered (p = 0.009) pregnancy rates. However, shuttle stallions were more likely to have increased (p = 0.035) pregnancy survival, perhaps reflecting a bias in stallion selection. In conclusion, mare age exerted the greatest influence on fertility; nonetheless, thoroughbreds can be effectively managed to achieve high reproductive performance in a commercial setting.     

Studies on Motility and Fertility of Cooled Stallion Spermatozoa

This study on extended, cooled stallion spermatozoa aimed to compare the ability of three extenders to maintain sperm motility during 24 h of preservation, and to describe pregnancy and foaling rates after artificial insemination (AI) of stallion spermatozoa stored and transported in the extender chosen from the in vitro study. After 6 and 24 h of preservation, motility, both subjective and evaluated by the motility analyzer (total, progressive and rapid), was lower in non-fat, dried skim milk-glucose than in both other extenders: dried skim milk-glucose added to 2% centrifuged egg yolk, and ultra high temperature treated skim milk-sugar-saline solution added to 2% centrifuged egg yolk (INRA82-Y). Rapid spermatozoa and sperm velocity parameters, after 24 h, were significantly higher in INRA82-Y. In the fertility trial, semen collected from three Maremmano stallions, diluted in INRA82-Y, and transported in a refrigerated Styrofoam box, was used to inseminate 56 mares of the same breed. Pregnancy rates after the first cycle and per breeding season were significantly higher for the 31 mares inseminated in three AI centres (54.8 and 80.6%, respectively) than for the 25 mares inseminated at the breeder's facilities (28.0 and 52.0%). Foaling rates were not significantly different between the AI centres mares (54.8%) and the other mares (44.0%). In conclusion, INRA82-Y yielded satisfactory pregnancy and foaling rates, especially when employed in the more controlled situation of an AI centre, and can therefore be included among those available for cooled stallion semen preservation.     

Male, female and management risk factors for non-return to service in Dutch mares

The "effect" of stallion, mare and management-related factors on the odds of pregnancy per cycle in the horse were identified and quantified from the breeding records of Dutch Warmblood (n=4491), Friesian (n=1467) and Shetland-pony mares (n=3267) mated either naturally or by artificial insemination to one of the 88 stallions between 1992 and 1996. A mare was considered to be pregnant when she did not return to oestrous within 28 days of the last insemination. For Dutch Warmblood horses, the percentage of mares that did not return for service within 28 days (NR28) varied between studfarms and ranged from 61 to 82%. The NR28 for mares inseminated with fresh semen ranged from 67 to 74% and for mares inseminated with frozen/thawed semen this percentage was 59. Mares served at a second cycle had lower odds not to return than mares served at the third or subsequent cycle (OR=0.84). For Friesian horses, the NR28 for young mares was higher than that for older mares. Mares served before 1 May in any year had lower odds of non-return than mares served after 1 July (OR=0.69). The NR28 of mares inseminated once per cycle was 6% lower than that of mares inseminated three times or more per cycle. For Shetland ponies, the NR28 also varied between studfarms and ranged from 62 to 78%. Stallions < or =3 years old had lower odds of non-return compared to older stallion (> or =11) (OR=0.57). Mares served before 1 July had lower odds of non-return. Other significant factors for this breed were age of the mare, cycle number and insemination frequency. Stallion factors accounted for 5.9, 2.0 and 14.7% of the variation in the NR28 for Dutch Warmblood, Friesian horses and the Shetland ponies, respectively.     

Artificial insemination and preservation of semen.

Artificial insemination is an effective technique for improving utilization of stallions in breeding programs. When proper semen handling and insemination procedures are used, optimal pregnancy rates are attainable. When AI techniques are employed for mares and stallions with marginal fertility, pregnancy rates may be improved in comparison with natural mating. Preservation of stallion semen in the liquid or frozen state reduces the costs and potential health hazards incurred by transporting mares and provides easier access to genetic material that may otherwise be unavailable. Acceptable pregnancy rates are consistently obtained with cooled semen. Conversely, techniques for cryopreservation of stallion semen will require more refinement before the procedure can be considered commercially viable on a wide scale.     

The influence of mare numbers, ejaculation frequency and month on the fertility of Thoroughbred stallions

Reason for performing the study: Although considerable variation in per cycle pregnancy rates exists between Thoroughbred (TB) stallions, there is little information on factors that may influence this figure. Objective: To assess the influence of month, mare numbers and mating frequency on the fertility of TB stallions standing on studfarms in East Anglia, England. Methods: The daily breeding records of 31 TB stallions mating 3034 mares on 4851 occasions during the 2010 season were surveyed and related to first scan pregnancy rates. The influences of mare book size, month, number of matings per day and mating frequency or abstinence on per mating pregnancy rates were analysed. Results: The overall per mating pregnancy rate for all the stallions was 59.6%, but for individual stallions the figures ranged from 19.0% to 80.1%. The first mating occurred on 9 February and the last on 24 July and the per mating pregnancy rate per month was significantly reduced in June and July. The number of mares mated by individual stallions ranged from 15 to 161, giving a mean overall workload of 160 matings per 100 mares. The per mating pregnancy rate was not related to book size, the number of matings in the season or the mating frequency per day. However, some stallions showed differences in per mating pregnancy rate related to month or the number of ejaculations in the preceding 3 days. Conclusions: The majority of TB stallions are able to maintain good fertility despite large books of mares. However, 5 of the 31 stallions surveyed showed a per mating pregnancy rate of ≤50%. Potential relevance: This survey has identified wide differences between the per mating pregnancy rate in TB stallions. Identification of the factors involved through more comprehensive surveys would provide useful information for mare and stallion owners.     

Reproductive performance measures among Thoroughbred mares in central Kentucky,during the 2004 mating season

Reason for performing study: To improve efficiency at the farm level, a better understanding of how farm management factors impact reproductive performance is important. Objective: To assess reproductive efficiency and effectiveness among Thoroughbred mares in central Kentucky. Methods: A cohort of 1011 mares on 13 farms in central Kentucky was followed during the 2004 mating and 2005 foaling season. Information on farm level practices was collected via interviews with farm managers. Reproductive records were collected for each mare mated to obtain information on mare characteristics. The influence of mare age and status (maiden, foaling, barren) on Days 15 and 40 post mating pregnancy rates, foaling rates and total effective length of the mating season were assessed. The influence of stallion book size on reproductive performance measures was also examined. Results: Per season pregnancy rates on Days 15 and 40 post mating and live foal rate were 92.1, 89.3 and 78.3%, respectively. Per cycle rates for the same time periods were 64.0, 58.3 and 50.8%. There were no significant associations between stallion book size and reproductive performance outcomes. The mean s.d. interval from the beginning of the mating season to the last mating of the mare was 36.5 ± 26.1 days. Conclusions: Mare age had a significant impact on efficiency of becoming pregnant, maintaining pregnancy and producing a live foal. Overall, fertility did not decrease among stallions with the largest book sizes. Total interval length of the mating season can be reduced if managers ensure maiden and barren mares are mated at the beginning of the season and foaling mares are mated at the earliest oestrus after acceptable uterine involution has been achieved. Potential relevance: Measures identified in the study can be used by owners, farm managers and veterinarians to improve mare reproductive performance and identify parameters to assist with the implementation of effective culling practices.     

Reproductive performance of Thoroughbred mares in the Waikato region of New Zealand: 2. Multivariable analyses and sources of variation at the mare,stallion and stud farm level

Abstract

AIM: The objective of this study was to utilise multivariable statistical methods appropriate for clustered data to identify mare-related explanatory variables that significantly affected the reproductive performance of Thoroughbred mares in the Waikato region of New Zealand. In addition, we aimed to determine the relative contribution of the mare, stallion and stud farm to reproductive performance.

METHODS: A prospective cohort study was performed involving five stud farms in the Waikato region of New Zealand during three consecutive breeding seasons (2006–2008). A total of 1,482 individual mares contributed 2007 mare years and 3,402 oestrous cycles over the three breeding seasons. Reproductive performance was measured using three parameters; (a) first-cycle pregnancy rate (FCPR), (b) end-of-season pregnancy rate (SPR), and (c) the start-of-mating to conception interval.

RESULTS: When controlled for the effects of serving stallion, stud farm and year of study the only significant mare-related variables included in the final models of FCPR, SPR and conception interval were the age of the mare and her reproductive status (classified as dry or foaling). Advancing mare age significantly reduced reproductive performance regardless of reproductive status and foaling mares had significantly poorer reproductive outcomes compared with dry mares when controlled for age. For each additional increase in year of age, the FCPR was reduced by a factor of 0.94 (95% CI=0.92–0.96) and the SPR was reduced by a factor of 0.91 (95% CI=0.88–0.93). Mares older than 14 years of age took longer to conceive after the start-of-mating compared with younger mares. The daily hazard of conception for mares 14 years and older was 0.64 (95% CI=0.47–0.83) times less than mares younger than 9 years of age. Determining the relative contribution of the mare, stallion and stud farm to the FCPR indicated that 95.9% of the variation was at the mare level, 4.1% was at the stallion level and 0% was at the stud farm level. For the SPR the variance components indicated that 92.5% of the variation was at the mare level, 6.7% was at the stallion level and 0.8% was at the stud farm level.

CONCLUSIONS: The reproductive performance of Thoroughbred mares in the Waikato region of New Zealand is influenced by two main mare-related factors; the age of the mare and her reproductive status (dry or foaling). The majority of variation in reproductive performance was associated with mare-level factors and the contribution of the stallion and stud farm was relatively minor.     

Reproductive efficiency of intensively managed Thoroughbred mares in Newmarket

The findings of a retrospective survey of 1393 Thoroughbred mares visiting 22 studfarms in the Newmarket region of the UK during the 1998 mating season were compared with those of a similar study undertaken in 1983. The effects of mare age and status, stallion, month of mating, application of uterine treatments and other parameters on the rates of singleton and twin conception and subsequent pregnancy losses were analysed. Mare age and status significantly affected the per cycle pregnancy rate and the incidence of pregnancy loss. Overall, the mean number of matings per oestrus was 1.12 and the mean number of times a mare was mated until diagnosed pregnant at 15 days after ovulation was 1.88. An overall mean per cycle pregnancy rate of 59.9% at 15 days after ovulation resulted in 94.8% of the mated mares being pregnant at least once at 15 days after ovulation. This high initial pregnancy rate fell to 89.7% by Day 35 and 87.5% by the time of the October pregnancy test; 82.7% of the mares surveyed gave birth to a live foal at term, which compares favourably with the proportion of mares foaling in 1983 (77%). However, despite improvements in the foaling rates over the last 15 years, the overall rate of pregnancy failure remains high and represents a major loss to the Thoroughbred breeding industry.     

Prediction of first season stallion fertility of 3-year-old Dutch Warmbloods with prebreeding assessment of percentage of morphologically normal live sperm.

In the selection procedure to acquire a breeding licence, 3-year-old Dutch Warmblood stallions have to undergo a breeding soundness test It is questioned whether this evaluation is predictive of the stallion's fertility results in the first breeding season. Therefore, semen parameters at the beginning of their first breeding season were evaluated and correlated to nonreturn at first cycle and foaling rate of mares bred by stallions (n = 13). The total number of mares inseminated with chilled semen from those stallions was 1055. Semen parameters were recorded on 2 ejaculates, collected 1 h apart. Percentage progressive sperm motility, % morphologically normal from unstained spermatozoa (MNA), % sperm cells with abnormal acrosomes and the total number of spermatozoa were correlated with first cycle nonreturn rate and foaling rate. Mean motility at evaluation was 72 +/- 6%. Mean MNA was 62 +/- 13%. Mean first cycle nonreturn rate and foaling rate were 58 +/- 15% and 69 +/- 12%, respectively. A significantly positive correlation (P<0.05) was found between the MNA and first cycle nonreturn rates. Foaling rates were not significantly correlated with semen characteristics and first cycle nonreturn rates. In conclusion, the breeding soundness test is of predictive value for the breeding results in the breeding season following the test. First cycle nonreturn rates reflect fertilising capacity better than foaling rates.     

Cryopreservation of Stallion Spermatozoa with INRA96 and Glycerol

The aim of the present study was to improve success of cryopreservation of stallion spermatozoa. Semen from eleven stallions was collected and frozen in INRA 96 with two different concentrations of glycerol (3.5% and 6.0%) and compared with a control freezing process. The mean post-thaw motility for the eleven stallions of 57.93% (3.5% glycerol) and 66.50% (6.0% glycerol), which was statistically higher (P < 0.05) when compared with the mean post-thaw motility (39.7%) for semen in a control egg-yolk extender (Equipro^® CryoGuard™ Complete, Minitube). The Equipro^® CryoGuard™ Complete is a commercial semen freezing protocol that has been one of the standard processes used in our laboratory for freezing equine spermatozoa. INRA 96 with 6% added glycerol was used in the fertility trial as it provided the highest spermatozoa survival. To evaluate fertility of the frozen semen, eight mares were bred over two cycles with both fresh and frozen semen. The pregnancy rate of mares bred with frozen semen (55.6%) was not statistically different (P > 0.05) from the pregnancy rate of mares bred with fresh semen (55.6%). INRA 96 with 6.0% glycerol improved the survivability of stallion spermatozoa through the cryopreservation process, and subsequent fertility was not different (P > 0.05) from fresh, extended semen.     

Effect of book size and age of mare and stallion on foaling rates in thoroughbred horses

The entire population data for Thoroughbred horses in the United States, Canada and Puerto Rico registered with the Jockey Club of America were utilized to study the effect of stallion book size, age of mare and age of stallion on live foal percentage for the 1987 and 1988 breeding seasons. There were 17,260 stallions bred to 179,009 mares, with a resulting overall live foaling rate of 58.1%. There was an increase in live foal percentage as book size increased (P<0.001) and a decrease in live foal percentage as mare age increased (P<0.0001). Stallion age had no effect on live foal percentage.     

Factors Influencing the Frequency of Pregnancy Loss among Thoroughbred Mares in Hidaka,Japan

Pregnancy loss in mares is thought to be a main problem associated with reproductive efficiency. To clarify the situation of pregnancy loss in Thoroughbred mares in Japan, the occurrence of pregnancy loss before and after 35 days of gestation was investigated with 1,476 Thoroughbred mares in Hidaka, Japan, from 2007 to 2009. Pregnancy loss on days 17-35 was determined by ultrasound examination between 17 and 35 days after the last mating. Follow-up surveys were conducted between 35 days and foaling to determine pregnancy loss on day 35 until foaling in 843 of these mares. Using multiple logistic regression analysis, we assessed the influence of mare age, reproductive status, twin pregnancy reduction, body condition score (BCS), estrus type in foaling mares (foal heat or not), progesterone therapy, and endometrial cysts on pregnancy loss rates on days 17-35 and on day 35 until foaling in this population of mares. The pregnancy loss rates on days 17-35 and on day 35 until foaling were 5.8% and 8.7%, respectively. The overall pregnancy loss rate (day 17 until foaling, including parturient losses) was 14.7%. Risk factors for pregnancy loss included decrease in BCS between 17 and 35 days, <5 BCS at day 35, mating during foal heat, and endometrial cysts. In all, 14.7% of pregnancies were lost between day 17 and birth, contributing significantly to reduced reproductive efficiency in Thoroughbred mares in Japan. These observations indicate that mares should be maintained at high BCS and should be prevented from mating in foal heat to decrease the pregnancy loss rates.     

Gestational length in Carthusian broodmares: effects of breeding season, foal gender, age of mare, year of parturition, parity and sire

The length of gestation in Carthusian broodmares was calculated on the basis of 339 spontaneous full-term deliveries taking place in the 8-year period 1998-2005 from 158 broodmares and 29 stallions in a major farm of Spanish horses of Carthusian strain in southern Spain. Ultrasonography was used to determine follicular dehiscence, 1st day of pregnancy and to confirm conception in mares. Mean GL was 332.4 +/- 12.1 days, and a normal interval of 297-358 days was established for this breed. GL records were grouped on the basis of foal sex (colts or fillies), mating month (between November and January; February and April; May and July), age of the mare (4 to 7 years; 8 to 12 years; 13 to 17 years), breeding year, stallion and parity (primiparous vs. multiparous). GLs were 12.9 days shorter in mares mated between May and July than those mated between November and January and 15.3 days in mares mated between February and April (p < 0.001). Mares aged between 8-12 years had 5.3 days shorter GLs than those aged between 13-17 years (p < 0.05). Pregnancy was significantly 5.7 days longer when the mare gave birth to colts than fillies (p < 0.05). GL was 14.5 days longer in primiparous than in multiparous mares ( p < 0.001). No statistical differences in GL were found between the studied years. This study shows the influence of certain stallion on GL.     

CASE STUDY: Use of Modified Phosphate-Buffered Saline as a Component of Semen Extenders Allows the Use of Transported Semen from Two Stallions

Conception rates for mares bred with transported-cooled and fresh stallion semen were collected over a 4-yr period (1998–2002) for two stallions. Both stallions stood at a commercial breeding farm. Semen from both stallions was used immediately after collection on the farm and after 24 to 48 h of cold storage when transported to locations in the U.S. and Canada. Semen for insemination of mares located on the farm was extended with a commercially available skim milk glucose extender (SKMG). Spermatozoal motility following cold storage for spermatozoa diluted in SKMG extender was unacceptable. Thus, semen from both stallions was centrifuged, and spermatozoa were resuspended in SKMG supplemented with modified PBS. In a previous study, the percentage of motile spermatozoa increased following centrifugation and reconstitution of the sperm pellet in SKMG-PBS as compared with semen dilution in SKMG (Stallion A: 15% vs 47%; Stallion B: 18% vs 43%). In the current study, 22 of 25 (88%) and 3 of 4 (75%) mares conceived with transported-cooled semen from Stallions A and B, respectively. Conception rates for mares inseminated with transported semen did not differ (P>0.05) from those inseminated on the farm with fresh semen. These data illustrate that stallion owners can modify standard cooled semen processing procedures and semen extender composition to improve post-storage spermatozoa motility and to obtain acceptable fertility.     

Management Strategies Aiming to Improve Horse Welfare Reduce Embryonic Death Rates in Mares

The objective of this retrospective study was to evaluate the effect of management strategies aiming to improve animal well‐being on pregnancy and embryonic death (ED) rates. Breeding records of a cohort of 1206 Thoroughbred mares brought to a stallion station facility, to be bred with the stallions housed there, were evaluated during ten breeding seasons. Mares were blocked according to management strategies in two groups: Stress and Relax. Strategies used to improve animal well‐being (Relax group) were as follows: stopping the teasing routine, reducing or eliminating stall confinement, reducing the number of mares per group and maintaining herd stability during the breeding season. In barren mares, the pregnancy rate was higher in the Relax group (91.8%) when compared to the observed in Stress group (84.7%). However, no difference in pregnancy rates were observed (Stress = 85.2% vs. Relax = 86.2) in foaling mares. ED rate was higher in barren and foaling mares of the Stress group mares (25.5% and 26.8%, respectively) compared with the Relax group (16.1% and 14.7%, respectively). No significant differences were observed on foal heat pregnancy rate between groups; yet, the embryo loss on foal heat was significant reduced in Relax mares (Relax = 8.7% vs Stress = 24.5%). In conclusion, management strategies aimed to reduce social stress can reduce early pregnancy losses and the average cycles per pregnancy, improving reproductive performance in mares.     

Reproductive performance and factors that decrease pregnancy rate in heavy draft horses bred at the foal heat

Reproductive performance and factors that decrease the pregnancy rate in heavy draft horses bred at the foal heat were investigated. The study was based on a total of 422 mares varying from 4 to 20 years in age, which had foaled during the period 1991 to 1994. Over the four years, the percentage of the mares bred at the foal heat was 62.6% and the pregnancy rate was 60.2%. The pregnancy rate following breeding at the foal heat in 1991 (67.7%) was significantly higher than that in 1992 (44.1%). Significant correlation was observed between the pregnancy rate and the mean placental retention time and also between the pregnancy rate and the mean temperature during the winter season. When compared on a monthly basis, the pregnancy rate following breeding at the foal heat in February was 53.3% and in May, 48.2%. The mean number of covers per mare at the foal heat was 2.3; this figure decreased to 1.8 for those bred in May. The mean number of days from parturition to the first breeding date was 11.3 days and the number of days from parturition to the last breeding day at the foal heat was 14.0 days. The number of days from parturition to the last breeding day at the foal heat decreased to 12.5 days in May. The latter may have been influenced by factors involving the stallion. When compared on a monthly basis, the mean placental retention time was longest in January (219 min.) following which it decreased gradually up to mid-summer. The mean placental retention time of mares which were not bred at the foal heat was significantly longer (197 min.) than in mares bred at the foaling heat (143 min.) and also in mares that conceived following breeding at the foal heat (135 min.). The pregnancy rate was less in mares bred shortly after parturition. The findings of this study would suggest that certain factors decrease the pregnancy rate in mares bred at the foal heat. The stress of low temperature in winter, prolonged placental retention time, breeding too early after parturition and factors pertaining to individual stallions may be involved. Expulsion of the placenta as soon as possible after foaling and appropriate breeding timing are significant factors that can influence the pregnancy rate following breeding at the foal heat.     

Retrospective study on the incidence of postinsemination uterine fluid in mares inseminated with frozen/thawed semen

Uterine fluid accumulation has been reported after insemination or natural breeding of mares. This retrospective study examined the factors affecting the incidence of uterine fluid after insemination of frozen semen. Specifically, this study determined the association between mare age, reproductive status, fluid accumulation, and pregnancy rates in mares. Records were available from 283 warmblood mares throughout 496 cycles. Mares were divided into maiden, foaling, and barren and age groups of 3 to 9, 10 to 16, and more than 16 years. Mares were inseminated only once with frozen semen within 4 to 8 hours before or after ovulation. Ultrasound examinations were performed 12 to 18 hours after insemination. A depth of at least 20 mm of fluid was considered significant. Mares with less than 20 mm were treated with oxytocin, and those with more than 20mm of fluid were given oxytocin and uterine lavage. Pregnancy determination was performed at 14 to 16 and 30 to 50 days after ovulation. Fluid level of more than 20 mm was recorded in 25% of the cycles. Barren mares and aged mares (10-16 and > 16 years) had a higher incidence of uterine fluid accumulations. Per-cycle pregnancy rate was lower (45%) in mares with uterine fluid than in mares without uterine fluid (51%). This difference was primarily due to the reduction in fertility of mares who were older than 16 years and retained fluid after insemination. Apparently, oxytocin and lavage treatments provided acceptable fertility in the other groups of mares that had uterine fluid.

Introduction

Use of equine frozen semen is accepted by the majority of horse registries. According to several field studies,[1, 2, 3, 4 and 5] insemination of frozen semen has resulted in acceptable pregnancy rates. Postbreeding fluid accumulation is a physiologic inflammation that clears the uterus of foreign material such as excess spermatozoa, seminal plasma, bacteria, and extenders. [6, 7, 8, 9 and 10] Uterine fluid can be easily diagnosed with ultrasonography. [10, 11 and 12] Persistent postbreeding uterine fluid has been associated with a decrease in fertility after natural mating or artificial insemination (AI) of fresh semen. [11, 12 and 13] Predisposing factors to persistent fluid accumulations are reduced myometrial contractions, poor lymphatic drainage, large overstretched uterus, and cervical incompetence. [7, 14 and 15] Normal mares are able to expel uterine fluid quickly after inseminations, whereas susceptible mares accumulate fluid in their uterine lumen for more than 12 hours after breeding or insemination. [10]It is commonly stated that insemination with frozen semen leads to greater post-AI fluid accumulation than insemination with fresh or cooled semen or after natural mating. Apparently, there is only 1 controlled study on this comparison.[7] The authors reported that infusion of frozen semen resulted in a greater inflammatory response than natural breeding. In a field study, [16] 16% of mares naturally mated had persistent postbreeding fluid accumulations compared with a 30% rate reported for mares inseminated with frozen semen. [1 and 2] More recently, Watson et al. [17] reported a postbreeding fluid accumulation rate of 16%, which is identical to that reported for natural mating. [16] It is difficult to compare studies because details of mare selection and insemination or breeding frequencies are not always reported. Obviously, a higher proportion of barren and aged mares in a study would increase the incidence of postbreeding fluid accumulation. [1 and 2]The study presented herein was a retrospective study designed to determine the incidence of postbreeding fluid accumulation in a large number of mares inseminated with frozen semen. Associations were determined between mare age, reproductive status and fluid accumulation, and pregnancy rate in mares with and without uterine fluid accumulation.

Materials and methods

Mares

Records were available from 283 warmblood mares inseminated with frozen semen at the Cristella Veterinary Clinic in Italy during 1998 to 2001. Mares ranging in age from 3 to 20 years were inseminated with semen that was frozen in 10 centers and was from 34 stallions. The broodmare population was subdivided into 3 reproductive groups: 89 maiden mares (mean age, 7.2 years), 106 foaling mares (mean age, 9.4 years), and 87 barren mares (mean age, 11.9 years). Maiden mares older than 7 years were selected with biopsy scores of 1 or 2 only. Barren mares were open for no more than 2 consecutive seasons and had negative cytology and bacteriology scores. Age groups were divided as follows: 3 to 9 years (n = 132), 10 to 16 years (n = 137) and older than 16 years (n = 14). Data from 496 cycles were used. Distribution of the estrous cycles was 172, 157, and 167 in the maiden, foaling, and barren groups, respectively; and 224, 244, and 28 in the youngest, intermediate, and oldest groups, respectively.

Mare reproductive management and artificial insemination protocol

During estrus, all mares underwent a daily ultrasound examination with a 5-mHz transrectal probe (SA 600 Vet; Medison Inc., Seoul, South Korea) until 1 or more 35-mm ovarian follicles were detected. Ovulation was then induced by the intravenous administration of 2000 IU of human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG). Ultrasound examination was performed 12 hours after hCG treatment and then every 4 to 8 hours until ovulation occurred. Mares were inseminated only once within a period of 4 to 8 hours before or after ovulation. The semen used was thawed according to the distribution center's instructions and had the following minimum post-thaw quality requirements: not less than 200 × 10⁶ progressively motile spermatozoa per dose and a minimum of 30% progressive spermatozoal motility. Foaling mares were not inseminated at their first postpartum (“foal heat”) estrous period, because pregnancy rates are recognized to be lower than during the subsequent estrous periods.[18] During the first postpartum estrus, ovarian ultrasound scan examinations were performed every 2 to 3 days until an ovulation was detected. A prostaglandin F₂α injection was given 5 days later to short-cycle the mare.

Postinsemination monitoring

An ultrasound examination of the reproductive tract was performed 12 to 18 hours after insemination to detect any intrauterine fluid accumulation. The presence and depth of intrauterine fluid was recorded. Twenty millimeters or more of grade II or III intrauterine fluid[19] was recorded as a significant amount of fluid. Mares with less than 20 mm of fluid were treated with an intravenous injection of 20 IU oxytocin. For mares with more than 20 mm of fluid, oxytocin was administered, and the uterus was flushed daily with buffered saline solution: 1-L aliquots were infused and recovered until the recovered fluid was clear. In these mares, oxytocin treatment was repeated up to 3 times daily. Post insemination treatments were performed for no more than 4 days after ovulation had occurred.Pregnancy diagnosis was performed with ultrasound at 14 to 16 days after ovulation. Scans were then repeated at 30 and 50 days of gestation to confirm the presence in the uterus of an apparently healthy developing conceptus.

Statistical analysis

χ² Analysis was used to determine the effect of reproductive status and age on the incidence of fluid accumulation. In addition, the influence of persistent uterine fluid accumulation on pregnancy rates per cycle was determined for each reproductive class and age by using χ² analysis.

Results

The per-cycle pregnancy rate at 14-16 days after ovulation was 49.3% (245/496 cycles). By the end of the season, 245 of 283 mares (86.5%) were confirmed pregnant. Fluid level of at least 20 mm (grade II or III) was recorded in 126 of the 496 cycles (25.4%). Barren mares had a higher (P < .05) incidence of postbreeding fluid accumulation (64/167; 38.3%) than maiden (34/172; 19.7%) and foaling (28/157, 17.8%; Table 1) mares. The incidence of fluid accumulation was also higher in mares older than 16 years (19/28; 67.8%) than those aged 10 to 16 years (69/244; 28.2%) and 3 to 9 years (38/224; 17%). The incidence of uterine fluid was also higher (P < .05) for mares aged 10 to 16 years than those aged 3 to 9 years (Table 2). Overall, the per-cycle pregnancy rate was lower (P < .05) for mares with post-AI fluid accumulations than for those with no uterine fluid or only a small quantity of fluid (57/126, 41.9% vs 188/360, 56.2%). Pregnancy rates were similar (P > .05) for mares with or without uterine fluid when comparisons were made within maiden and barren mare groups. However, more foaling mares became pregnant when no fluid was detected after insemination. Pregnancy rate for this group (68.1%) was higher than that for maiden (44.2%) and barren (44.6%) mares (Table 3). Older mares with uterine fluid accumulations had a lower per-cycle pregnancy rate (36.8%) than mares in the same group but without fluid. Surprisingly, if no fluid was detected, the highest pregnancy rates were in mares older than 16 years ( Table 4).     

Use of manual stimulation for collection of semen from an atactic stallion unable to mount

A 9-year-old atactic breeding stallion was trained to ejaculate, with only manual stimulation, while standing on the ground. Ejaculates obtained yielded fertile semen with morphologic and motility characteristics within the range for normal stallions. This method extended the breeding life of a stallion unable to mount a live or dummy mare or to ejaculate into an artificial vagina while standing on the ground.     

Reflections on mare behavior: Social and sexual perspectives

Among horse owners “mare-ishness” is easily recognized, if poorly defined, as generally awkward or recalcitrant behavior. In common with other mammals, however, horses do show a range of female-specific behavior patterns concerned particularly with sexual and maternal functions but also encompassing aspects of social peer interaction. Many of these behavior patterns are observed more easily in free living feral populations and are repressed at least partially under standard domestic management regimes. Feral horses form small stable breeding groups within which mares create linear dominance hierarchies based on the outcomes of aggressive encounters and positive social bonding. Rank within the social hierarchy may also influence reproductive success, with dominant mares having shorter foaling intervals and earlier foaling than lower ranking subordinate mares. Advantageous early foaling may reflect preferential mating by the group stallion based either simply on enhanced physical condition leading to earlier reproductive cycling in dominant mares or on an increased attractiveness to dominant mares by the stallion contingent on some aspect of dominance characteristics. The endocrine axis responsible for regulation of sexual behavior in the mare shows a degree of commonality with systems underlying social dominance. Both these behavior patterns are driven by a complex interaction of endocrine and neuro-endocrine factors sensitive to physical and social environmental cues and in feral free-living horses these are interlinked to an extent that may be under appreciated in domestic breeding populations.