Root and rhizomicrobial respiration: A review of approaches to estimate respiration by autotrophic and heterotrophic organisms in soil

Partitioning the root‐derived CO₂ efflux from soil (frequently termed rhizosphere respiration) into actual root respiration (RR, respiration by autotrophs) and rhizomicrobial respiration (RMR, respiration by heterotrophs) is crucial in determining the carbon (C) and energy balance of plants and soils. It is also essential in quantifying C sources for rhizosphere microorganisms and in estimation of the C contributing to turnover of soil organic matter (SOM), as well as in linking net ecosystem production (NEP) and net ecosystem exchange (NEE). Artificial‐environment studies such as hydroponics or sterile soils yield unrealistic C‐partitioning values and are unsuitable for predicting C flows under natural conditions. To date, several methods have been suggested to separate RR and RMR in nonsterile soils: 1) component integration, 2) substrate‐induced respiration, 3) respiration by excised roots, 4) comparison of root‐derived ¹⁴CO₂ with rhizomicrobial ¹⁴CO₂ after continuous labeling, 5) isotope dilution, 6) model‐rhizodeposition technique, 7) modeling of ¹⁴CO₂ efflux dynamics, 8) exudate elution, and 9) δ¹³C of CO₂ and microbial biomass. This review describes the basic principles and assumptions of these methods and compares the results obtained in the original papers and in studies designed to compare the methods. The component‐integration method leads to strong disturbance and non‐proportional increase of CO₂ efflux from different sources. Four of the methods (5 to 8) are based on the pulse labeling of shoots in a ¹⁴CO₂ atmosphere and subsequent monitoring of ¹⁴CO₂ efflux from the soil. The model‐rhizodeposition technique and exudate‐elution procedure strongly overestimate RR and underestimate RMR. Despite alternative assumptions, isotope dilution and modeling of ¹⁴CO₂‐efflux dynamics yield similar results. In crops and grasses (wheat, ryegrass, barley, buckwheat, maize, meadow fescue, prairie grasses), RR amounts on average to 48±5% and RMR to 52±5% of root‐derived CO₂. The method based on the ¹³C isotopic signature of CO₂ and microbial biomass is the most promising approach, especially when the plants are continuously labeled in ¹³CO₂ or ¹⁴CO₂ atmosphere. The “difference” methods, i.e., trenching, tree girdling, root‐exclusion techniques, etc., are not suitable for separating the respiration by autotrophic and heterotrophic organisms because the difference methods neglect the importance of microbial respiration of rhizodeposits.     

Microbial immobilisation of C rhizodeposits in rhizosphere and root-free soil under continuous C labelling of oats

A greenhouse experiment was conducted by growing oats (Avenasativa L.) in a continuously ¹³CO₂ labeled atmosphere. The allocation of ¹³C-labeled photosynthates in plants, microbial biomass in rhizosphere and root-free soil, pools of soil organic C, and CO₂ emissions were examined over the plant's life cycle. To isolate rhizosphere from root-free soil, plant seedlings were placed into bags made of nylon monofilament screen tissue (16 μm mesh) filled with soil. Two peaks of ¹³C in rhizosphere pools of microbial biomass and dissolved organic carbon (DOC), as well as in CO₂ emissions at the earing and ripeness stages were revealed. These ¹³C maxima corresponded to: (i) the end of rapid root growth and (ii) beginning of root decomposition, respectively. The δ¹³C values of microbial biomass were higher than those of DOC and of soil organic matter (SOM). The microbial biomass C accounted for up to 56 and 39% of ¹³C recovered in the rhizosphere and root-free soil, respectively. Between 4 and 28% of ¹³C assimilated was recovered in the root-free soil. Depending on the phenological stage, the contribution of root-derived C to total CO₂ emission from soil varied from 61 to 92% of total CO₂ evolved, including 4-23% attributed to rhizomicrobial respiration. While 81-91% of C substrates used for microbial growth in the root-free soil and rhizosphere came from SOM, the remaining 9-19% of C substrates utilized by the microbial biomass was attributable to rhizodeposition. The use of continuous isotopic labelling and physical separation of root-free and rhizosphere soil, combined with natural ¹³C abundance were effective in gaining new insight on soil and rhizosphere C-cycling.     

Three‐source partitioning of CO2 efflux from maize field soil by 13C natural abundance

A natural‐¹³C‐labeling approach—formerly observed under controlled conditions—was tested in the field to partition total soil CO₂ efflux into root respiration, rhizomicrobial respiration, and soil organic matter (SOM) decomposition. Different results were expected in the field due to different climate, site, and microbial properties in contrast to the laboratory. Within this isotopic method, maize was planted on soil with C₃‐vegetation history and the total CO₂ efflux from soil was subdivided by isotopic mass balance. The C₄‐derived C in soil microbial biomass was also determined. Additionally, in a root‐exclusion approach, root‐ and SOM‐derived CO₂ were determined by the total CO₂ effluxes from maize (Zea mays L.) and bare‐fallow plots. In both approaches, maize‐derived CO₂ contributed 22% to 35% to the total CO₂ efflux during the growth period, which was comparable to other field studies. In our laboratory study, this CO₂ fraction was tripled due to different climate, soil, and sampling conditions. In the natural‐¹³C‐labeling approach, rhizomicrobial respiration was low compared to other studies, which was related to a low amount of C₄‐derived microbial biomass. At the end of the growth period, however, 64% root respiration and 36% rhizomicrobial respiration in relation to total root‐derived CO₂ were calculated when considering high isotopic fractionations between SOM, microbial biomass, and CO₂. This relationship was closer to the 50% : 50% partitioning described in the literature than without fractionation (23% root respiration, 77% rhizomicrobial respiration). Fractionation processes of ¹³C must be taken into account when calculating CO₂ partitioning in soil. Both methods—natural ¹³C labeling and root exclusion—showed the same partitioning results when ¹³C isotopic fractionation during microbial respiration was considered and may therefore be used to separate plant‐ and SOM‐derived CO₂ sources.     

Modification of the original chloroform fumigation extraction technique to allow measurement of δC of soil microbial biomass carbon

In studies of the soil microbial biomass C by the chloroform fumigation extraction (CFE) technique, biomass C is routinely extracted using 0.5 M K₂SO₄ solution. The excessive amounts of salts contained in the extracting solution pause a significant challenge in using ¹³C isotope techniques to study the nature of C in the soil microbial biomass. This is because the salts can affect the oxidation process and therefore hamper accurate mass spectromic analysis of dried extracts. In spite of this, no standard protocol exists for preparing the K₂SO₄ extracts for ¹³C isotope analysis. We have modified the original CFE method to allow measurement of the δ¹³C of soil microbial biomass C by using 2 M KCl instead of the usual 0.5 M K₂SO₄ solution to extract biomass C. Excess salts were removed by dialysis in 100 molecular weight cut off membranes, after which the extracts were freeze-dried and their δ¹³C measured using a mass spectrometer. The soil microbial biomass C and δ¹³C of 2 M KCl extracts were compared with those of 0.5 M K₂SO₄ extracts. There was excellent agreement between organic C and δ¹³C estimates for dialyzed 2 M KCl and 0.5 M K₂SO₄ extracts, but the speed of dialysis for the latter was very slow, making use of the former more rapid. These results suggest that in procedures where oxidation with potassium dichromate is not critical to analysis of soluble C, 2 M KCl may be used in place of 0.5 M K₂SO₄ to extract soil microbial biomass C for δ¹³C measurements. The new procedure is relatively easy and rapid for obtaining indices for both pool sizes and turnover rates of soil microbial biomass C and provides a promising approach to study soil organic C.     

Turnover of soil organic matter and of microbial biomass under C3-C4 vegetation change: Consideration of C fractionation and preferential substrate utilization

Two processes contribute to changes of the δ¹³C signature in soil pools: ¹³C fractionation per se and preferential microbial utilization of various substrates with different δ¹³C signature. These two processes were disentangled by simultaneously tracking δ¹³C in three pools - soil organic matter (SOM), microbial biomass, dissolved organic carbon (DOC) - and in CO₂ efflux during incubation of 1) soil after C₃-C₄ vegetation change, and 2) the reference C₃ soil.The study was done on the Ap horizon of a loamy Gleyic Cambisol developed under C₃ vegetation. Miscanthus giganteus - a perennial C₄ plant - was grown for 12 years, and the δ¹³C signature was used to distinguish between ‘old’ SOM (>12 years) and ‘recent’ Miscanthus-derived C (<12 years). The differences in δ¹³C signature of the three C pools and of CO₂ in the reference C₃ soil were less than 1‰, and only δ¹³C of microbial biomass was significantly different compared to other pools. Nontheless, the neglecting of isotopic fractionation can cause up to 10% of errors in calculations. In contrast to the reference soil, the δ¹³C of all pools in the soil after C₃-C₄ vegetation change was significantly different. Old C contributed only 20% to the microbial biomass but 60% to CO₂. This indicates that most of the old C was decomposed by microorganisms catabolically, without being utilized for growth. Based on δ¹³C changes in DOC, CO₂ and microbial biomass during 54 days of incubation in Miscanthus and reference soils, we concluded that the main process contributing to changes of the δ¹³C signature in soil pools was preferential utilization of recent versus old C (causing an up to 9.1‰ shift in δ¹³C values) and not ¹³C fractionation per se.Based on the δ¹³C changes in SOM, we showed that the estimated turnover time of old SOM increased by two years per year in 9 years after the vegetation change. The relative increase in the turnover rate of recent microbial C was 3 times faster than that of old C indicating preferential utilization of available recent C versus the old C.Combining long-term field observations with soil incubation reveals that the turnover time of C in microbial biomass was 200 times faster than in total SOM. Our study clearly showed that estimating the residence time of easily degradable microbial compounds and biomarkers should be done at time scales reflecting microbial turnover times (days) and not those of bulk SOM turnover (years and decades). This is necessary because the absence of C reutilization is a prerequisite for correct estimation of SOM turnover. We conclude that comparing the δ¹³C signature of linked pools helps calculate the relative turnover of old and recent pools.     

C signature of CO2 evolved from incubated maize residues and maize-derived sheep faeces

Analyses of the spatial and temporal variations in the natural abundance of ¹³C are frequently employed to study transformations of plant residues and soil organic matter turnover on sites where long continued vegetation with the C₃-type photosynthesis pathway has been replaced with a C₄-type vegetation (or vice versa). One controversial issue associated with such analyses is the significance of isotopic fractionation during the microbial turnovers of C in complex substrates. To evaluate this issue, C₃-soil and quartz sand were amended with maize residues and with faeces from sheep feed exclusively on maize silage. The samples were incubated at 15 °C for 117 days (maize residues) or 224 days (sheep faeces). CO₂ evolved during incubation was trapped in NaOH and analysed for C isotopic contents. At the end of incubation, 63 and 50% of the maize C was evolved as CO₂ in the soil and sand, respectively, while 32% of the faeces C incubated with soil and with sand was recovered as CO₂. Maize and faeces showed a similar decomposition pattern but maize decomposed twice as fast as faeces. The δ¹³C of faeces was 0.3‰ lower than that of the maize residue (δ¹³C −13.4‰), while the δ¹³C of the C₃-soil used for incubation was −31.6‰. The δ¹³C value of the CO₂ recovered from unamended C₃-soil was similar or slightly lower (up to −1.5‰) than that of the C₃-soil itself except for an initial flush of ¹³C enriched CO₂. The δ¹³C values of the CO₂ from sand-based incubations typically ranged −15‰ to −17‰, i.e. around −3‰ lower than the δ¹³C measured for maize and faeces. Our study clearly demonstrates that the decomposition of complex substrates is associated with isotopic fractionation, causing evolved CO₂ to be depleted in ¹³C relative to substrates. Consequently the microbial products retained in the soil must be enriched in ¹³C.     

C fractionation at the root-microorganisms-soil interface: A review and outlook for partitioning studies

Natural variations of the ¹³C/¹²C ratio have been frequently used over the last three decades to trace C sources and fluxes between plants, microorganisms, and soil. Many of these studies have used the natural-¹³C-labelling approach, i.e. natural δ¹³C variation after C₃-C₄ vegetation changes. In this review, we focus on ¹³C fractionation in main processes at the interface between roots, microorganisms, and soil: root respiration, microbial respiration, formation of dissolved organic carbon, as well as microbial uptake and utilization of soil organic matter (SOM). Based on literature data and our own studies, we estimated that, on average, the roots of C₃ and C₄ plants are ¹³C enriched compared to shoots by +1.2 ± 0.6‰ and +0.3 ± 0.4‰, respectively. The CO₂ released by root respiration was ¹³C depleted by about −2.1 ± 2.2‰ for C₃ plants and −1.3 ± 2.4‰ for C₄ plants compared to root tissue. However, only a very few studies investigated ¹³C fractionation by root respiration. This urgently calls for further research. In soils developed under C₃ vegetation, the microbial biomass was ¹³C enriched by +1.2 ± 2.6‰ and microbial CO₂ was also ¹³C enriched by +0.7 ± 2.8‰ compared to SOM. This discrimination pattern suggests preferential utilization of ¹³C-enriched substances by microorganisms, but a respiration of lighter compounds from this fraction. The δ¹³C signature of the microbial pool is composed of metabolically active and dormant microorganisms; the respired CO₂, however, derives mainly from active organisms. This discrepancy and the preferential substrate utilization explain the δ¹³C differences between microorganisms and CO₂ by an ‘apparent’ ¹³C discrimination. Preferential consumption of easily decomposable substrates and less negative δ¹³C values were common for substances with low C/N ratios. Preferential substrate utilization was more important for C₃ soils because, in C₄ soils, microbial respiration strictly followed kinetics, i.e. microorganisms incorporated heavier C (? = +1.1‰) and respired lighter C (? = −1.1‰) than SOM. Temperature and precipitation had no significant effect on the ¹³C fractionation in these processes in C₃ soils. Increasing temperature and decreasing precipitation led, however, to increasing δ¹³C of soil C pools.Based on these ¹³C fractionations we developed a number of consequences for C partitioning studies using ¹³C natural abundance. In the framework of standard isotope mixing models, we calculated CO₂ partitioning using the natural-¹³C-labelling approach at a vegetation change from C₃ to C₄ plants assuming a root-derived fraction between 0% and 100% to total soil CO₂. Disregarding any ¹³C fractionation processes, the calculated results deviated by up to 10% from the assumed fractions. Accounting for ¹³C fractionation in the standard deviations of the C₄ source and the mixing pool did not improve the exactness of the partitioning results; rather, it doubled the standard errors of the CO₂ pools. Including ¹³C fractionations directly into the mass balance equations reproduced the assumed CO₂ partitioning exactly. At the end, we therefore give recommendations on how to consider ¹³C fractionations in research on carbon flows between plants, microorganisms, and soil.     

Sources of CO2 efflux from soil and review of partitioning methods

Five main biogenic sources of CO₂ efflux from soils have been distinguished and described according to their turnover rates and the mean residence time of carbon. They are root respiration, rhizomicrobial respiration, decomposition of plant residues, the priming effect induced by root exudation or by addition of plant residues, and basal respiration by microbial decomposition of soil organic matter (SOM). These sources can be grouped in several combinations to summarize CO₂ efflux from the soil including: root-derived CO₂, plant-derived CO₂, SOM-derived CO₂, rhizosphere respiration, heterotrophic microbial respiration (respiration by heterotrophs), and respiration by autotrophs. These distinctions are important because without separation of SOM-derived CO₂ from plant-derived CO₂, measurements of total soil respiration have very limited value for evaluation of the soil as a source or sink of atmospheric CO₂ and for interpreting the sources of CO₂ and the fate of carbon within soils and ecosystems. Additionally, the processes linked to the five sources of CO₂ efflux from soil have various responses to environmental variables and consequently to global warming. This review describes the basic principles and assumptions of the following methods which allow SOM-derived and root-derived CO₂ efflux to be separated under laboratory and field conditions: root exclusion techniques, shading and clipping, tree girdling, regression, component integration, excised roots and insitu root respiration; continuous and pulse labeling, ¹³C natural abundance and FACE, and radiocarbon dating and bomb-¹⁴C. A short sections cover the separation of the respiration of autotrophs and that of heterotrophs, i.e. the separation of actual root respiration from microbial respiration, as well as methods allowing the amount of CO₂ evolved by decomposition of plant residues and by priming effects to be estimated. All these methods have been evaluated according to their inherent disturbance of the ecosystem and C fluxes, and their versatility under various conditions. The shortfalls of existing approaches and the need for further development and standardization of methods are highlighted.     

Palatability trials on hardwood leaf litter grown under elevated CO2: a stable carbon isotope study

The palatability to isopods and microbes of a broad range of hardwood leaf litter, derived from three field CO₂-enrichment experiments in the USA, was investigated, using δ¹³C, to trace the C flow from litter to isopods and to CO₂ respired by microbial decomposition. Leaf litter grown under elevated CO₂ had δ¹³C values ranging from −39 to −45‰, which were significantly different from ambient litter δ¹³C values of around −30‰. Litter palatability to isopods of the Porcellio sp. was tested by incubating ambient- and elevated-CO₂ litter, and a mixture of the two, in the presence of isopods for 14 days, under environmentally controlled conditions; δ¹³C was measured on litter and isopods' body before and after incubation. In an additional experiment, litter was incubated in the absence of fauna for 30 days, and on five occasions the δ¹³C of the CO₂ respired from litter was measured. The ¹³C label was clearly carried from the litter source to the isopods' bodies, and their faeces. For microbial-respired CO₂, δ¹³C was significantly higher than that of the litter source, suggesting preferential degradation of substrates enriched in ¹³C as compared to those in the overall litter. With the exception of Quercus myrtifolia leaf litter, elevated CO₂ did not affect the palatability to isopods nor the microbial degradation of any of the litters, possibly as a result of unaltered litter N concentration. However, significant differences in litter palatability and decay rates were observed among the different species. With this study, the use of isotopically labelled litter material was confirmed as a key methodology that can significantly contribute to the advancement of the understanding of litter decomposition and of the quantification of C fluxes in the process.     

Natural abundance δN and δC of DNA extracted from soil

We report the first simultaneous measurements of δ¹⁵N and δ¹³C of DNA extracted from surface soils. The isotopic composition of DNA differed significantly among nine different soils. The δ¹³C and δ¹⁵N of DNA was correlated with δ¹³C and δ¹⁵N of soil, respectively, suggesting that the isotopic composition of DNA is strongly influenced by the isotopic composition of soil organic matter. However, in all samples DNA was enriched in ¹³C relative to soil, indicating microorganisms fractionated C during assimilation or preferentially used ¹³C enriched substrates. Enrichment of DNA in ¹⁵N relative to soil was not consistently observed, but there were significant differences between δ¹⁵N of DNA and δ¹⁵N of soil for three different sites, suggesting microorganisms are fractionating N or preferentially using N substrates at different rates across these contrasting ecosystems. There was a strong linear correlation between δ¹⁵N of DNA and δ¹⁵N of the microbial biomass, which indicated DNA was depleted in ¹⁵N relative to the microbial biomass by approximately 3.4‰. Our results show that accurate and precise isotopic measurements of C and N in DNA extracted from the soil are feasible, and that these analyses may provide powerful tools for elucidating C and N cycling processes through soil microorganisms.     

Effluxed CO2-C from sterilized and unsterilized treatments of a calcareous soil

Soil inorganic carbon (C) represents a substantial C pool in arid ecosystems, yet little data exist on the contribution of this pool to ecosystem C fluxes. A closed jar incubation study was carried out to test the hypothesis that CO₂-¹³C production and response to sterilization would differ in a calcareous (Mojave Desert) soil and a non-calcareous (Oklahoma Prairie) soil due to contributions of carbonate-derived CO₂. In addition to non-sterilized controls, soils were subjected to sterilization treatments (unbuffered HgCl₂ addition for Oklahoma soil and unbuffered HgCl₂ addition, buffered HgCl₂ addition, and autoclaving for Mojave Desert soil) to decrease biotic respiration and more readily measure abiotic CO₂ flux. Temperature and moisture treatments were also included with sterilization treatments in a factorial design.The rate of CO₂ production in both soils was significantly decreased (36-87%) by sterilization, but sterilization treatments differed in effectiveness. Sterilization had no significant effect on effluxed CO₂-¹³C values in the non-calcareous Oklahoma Prairie soil and autoclaved Mojave Desert soil as compared to their respective non-sterilized controls. However, sterilization significantly altered CO₂-¹³C values in Mojave Desert soil HgCl₂ sterilization treatments (both buffered and non-buffered). Plots of 1/CO₂ versus CO₂-δ¹³C (similar to Keeling plots) indicated that the source CO₂-δ¹³C value of the Oklahoma Prairie soil treatments was similar to the δ¹³C value of soil organic matter [(SOM); −17.76‰ VPDB] whereas the source for the (acidic) unbuffered-HgCl₂ sterilized Mojave Desert soil was similar to the δ¹³C value of carbonates (−0.93‰ VPDB). The source CO₂-δ¹³C value of non-sterilized and autoclaved (−18.4‰ VPDB) Mojave Desert soil treatments was intermediate between SOM (−21.43‰ VPDB) and carbonates and indicates up to 13% of total C efflux may be from abiotic sources in calcareous soils.     

Rhizodeposition-induced decomposition increases N availability to wild and cultivated wheat genotypes under elevated CO2

Elevated CO₂ may increase nutrient availability in the rhizosphere by stimulating N release from recalcitrant soil organic matter (SOM) pools through enhanced rhizodeposition. We aimed to elucidate how CO₂-induced increases in rhizodeposition affect N release from recalcitrant SOM, and how wild versus cultivated genotypes of wheat mediated differential responses in soil N cycling under elevated CO₂. To quantify root-derived soil carbon (C) input and release of N from stable SOM pools, plants were grown for 1 month in microcosms, exposed to ¹³C labeling at ambient (392 μmol mol⁻¹) and elevated (792 μmol mol⁻¹) CO₂ concentrations, in soil containing ¹⁵N predominantly incorporated into recalcitrant SOM pools. Decomposition of stable soil C increased by 43%, root-derived soil C increased by 59%, and microbial-¹³C was enhanced by 50% under elevated compared to ambient CO₂. Concurrently, plant ¹⁵N uptake increased (+7%) under elevated CO₂ while ¹⁵N contents in the microbial biomass and mineral N pool decreased. Wild genotypes allocated more C to their roots, while cultivated genotypes allocated more C to their shoots under ambient and elevated CO₂. This led to increased stable C decomposition, but not to increased N acquisition for the wild genotypes. Data suggest that increased rhizodeposition under elevated CO₂ can stimulate mineralization of N from recalcitrant SOM pools and that contrasting C allocation patterns cannot fully explain plant mediated differential responses in soil N cycling to elevated CO₂.     

Dynamics of maize (Zea mays L.) leaf straw mineralization as affected by the presence of soil and the availability of nitrogen

An incubation experiment was carried out with maize (Zea mays L.) leaf straw to analyze the effects of mixing the residues with soil and N amendment on the decomposition process. In order to distinguish between soil effects and nitrogen effects for both the phyllospheric microorganisms already present on the surface of maize straw and soil microorganisms the N amendment was applied in two different placements: directly to the straw or to the soil. The experiment was performed in dynamic, automated microcosms for 22 days at 15 °C with 7 treatments: (1) untreated soil, (2) non-amended maize leaf straw without soil, (3) N amended maize leaf straw without soil, (4) soil mixed with maize leaf straw, (5) N amended soil, (6) N amended soil mixed with maize leaf straw, and (7) soil mixed with N amended maize leaf straw. ¹⁵NH₄¹⁵NO₃ (5 at%) was added. Gas emissions (CO₂, ¹³CO₂ and N₂O) were continuously recorded throughout the experiment. Microbial biomass C, biomass N, ergosterol, δ¹³C of soil organic C and of microbial biomass C as well as ¹⁵N in soil total N, mineral N and microbial biomass N were determined in soil samples at the end of the incubation. The CO₂ evolution rate showed a lag-phase of two days in the non-amended maize leaf straw treatment without soil, which was completely eliminated when mineral N was added. The addition of N generally increased the CO₂ evolution rate during the initial stages of maize leaf straw decomposition, but not the cumulative CO₂ production. The presence of soil caused roughly a 50% increase in cumulative CO₂ production within 22 days in the maize straw treatments due to a slower decrease of CO₂ evolution after the initial activity peak. Since there are no limitations of water or N, we suggest that soil provides a microbial community ensuring an effective succession of straw decomposing microorganisms. In the treatments where maize and soil was mixed, 75% of microbial biomass C was derived from maize. We concluded that this high contribution of maize using microbiota indicates a strong influence of organisms of phyllospheric origin to the microbial community in the soil after plant residues enter the soil.     

Carbon fluxes in soil food webs of increasing complexity revealed by C labelling and C natural abundance

Soil food webs are mainly based on three primary carbon (C) sources: root exudates, litter, and recalcitrant soil organic matter (SOM). These C sources vary in their availability and accessibility to soil organisms, which could lead to different pathways in soil food webs. The presence of three C isotopes (¹²C, ¹³C and ¹⁴C) offers an unique opportunity to investigate all three C sources simultaneously. In a microcosm experiment we studied the effect of food web complexity on the utilization of the three carbon sources. We choose an incomplete three factorial design with (i) living plants, (ii) litter and (iii) food web complexity. The most complex food web consisted of autochthonous microorganisms, nematodes, collembola, predatory mites, endogeic and anecic earthworms. We traced C from all three sources in soil, in CO₂ efflux and in individual organism groups by using maize grown on soil developed under C₃ vegetation and application of ¹⁴C labelled ryegrass shoots as a litter layer. The presence of living plants had a much greater effect on C pathways than food web complexity. Litter decomposition, measured as ¹⁴CO₂ efflux, was decreased in the presence of living plants from 71% to 33%. However, living plants increased the incorporation of litter C into microbial biomass and arrested carbon in the litter layer and in the upper soil layer. The only significant effect of food web complexity was on the litter C distribution in the soil layers. In treatments with fungivorous microarthropods (Collembola) the incorporation of litter carbon into mineral soil was reduced. Root exudates as C source were passed through rhizosphere microorganisms to the predator level (at least to the third trophic level). We conclude that living plants strongly affected C flows, directly by being a source of additional C, and indirectly by modifying the existing C flows within the food web including CO₂ efflux from the soil and litter decomposition.     

Compound-specific δC and δH analyses of plant and soil organic matter: A preliminary assessment of the effects of vegetation change on ecosystem hydrology

Here we present δ¹³C and δ²H data of long-chained, even-numbered (C₂₇-C₃₁) n-alkanes from C3 (trees) and C4 (grasses) plants and from the corresponding soils from a grassland-woodland vegetation sequence in central Queensland, Australia. Our data show that δ¹³C values of the C4 grassland species were heavier relative to those of C3 tree species from the woodland (Acacia leaves) and woody grassland (Atalaya leaves). However, n-alkanes from the C4 grasses had lighter δ²H values relative to the Acacia leaves, but showed no significant difference in δ²H values when compared with C3 Atalaya leaves. These results differ from those of previous studies, showing that C4 grasses had heavier δ²H values relative to C3 grasses and trees. Those observations have been explained by C4 plants accessing the more evaporation-influenced and isotopically heavier surface water and tree roots sourcing deeper, isotopically lighter soil water (“Two-layered soil-water system”). By comparison, our data suggest that ecosystem changes (vegetation “thickening”) can significantly alter the soil hydrological characteristics. This is shown by the heavier δ²H values in the woodland soil compared with lighter δ²H values in the grassland soil, implying that the recent vegetation change (increased tree biomass) in the woodland had altered soil hydrological conditions. Estimated δ²H values of the source-water for vegetation in the grassland and woodland showed that both trees and grasses in open settings accessed water with lighter δ²H values (avg. −46‰) compared with water accessed by trees in the woodland vegetation (avg. −7‰). These data suggest that in semi-arid environments the “two-layer” soil water concept might not apply. Furthermore, our data indicate that compound-specific δ²H and δ¹³C analyses of n-alkanes from soil organic matter can be used to successfully differentiate between water sources of different vegetation types (grasses versus trees) in natural ecosystems.     

Use of C abundance to study short-term pig slurry decomposition in the field

Applying pig slurry (PS) on agricultural soils is a common practice. However, its impact on soil organic C dynamics is not clear. This experiment investigated the use of natural ¹³C abundance to study the short-term C mineralization of anaerobically stored PS under field conditions. Measurements of δ¹³C-CO₂ were made on soil air samples obtained from a bare sandy loam during 22 d following incorporation of either PS alone, PS+barley straw, or barley straw alone; an unamended treatment was used as a control. Slurry C was enriched in ¹³C (−20.0‰) because of the high corn (Zea mays L.) content of the animal diet. This value contrasted with δ¹³C of −28.4‰ for the soil organic matter and of −29.0‰ for the barley straw. A peak of high δ¹³CO₂ values (average of −9.2‰) was observed on the day of PS application and was attributed to the dissociation of PS carbonates when mixed with the relatively acidic soil. After this initial burst, 36% of the evolved CO₂ originated from the decomposing PS. After 22 d of incubation, approx. 20% of the PS-C had been lost as CO₂. This short-term field study did not show any priming effect of PS on the mineralization of straw or native soil C. Due to its heterogeneity, the use of the isotopic composition of the evolved CO₂ for estimating PS decomposition requires precaution either through the use of a specific experimental design involving comparable C3 and C4 treatments, or calculations to account for the presence of ¹³C-enriched inorganic C in the PS.     

Net ecosystem carbon exchange for Bermuda grass growing in mesocosms as affected by irrigation frequency

Intensification of grazed grasslands following conversion from dryland to irrigated farming has the potential to alter ecosystem carbon (C) cycling and affect components of carbon dioxide (CO₂) exchange that could lead to either net accumulation or loss of soil C. While there are many studies on the effect of water availability on biomass production and soil C stocks, much less is known about the effect of the frequency of water inputs on the components of CO₂ exchange. We grew Bermuda grass (Cynodon dactylon L.) in mesocosms under irrigation frequencies of every day (I₁ treatment, 30 d), every two days (I₂ treatment, 12 d), every three days (I₃ treatment, 30 d), and every six days (I₆ treatment, 18 d, after I₂ treatment). Rates of CO₂ exchange for estimating net ecosystem CO₂ exchange (F_N), ecosystem respiration (R_E), and soil respiration (R_S) were measured, and gross C uptake by plants (F_G) and respiration from leaves (R_L) were calculated during two periods, 1–12 and 13–30 d, of the 30-d experiment. During the first 12 d, there were no significant differences in cumulative F_N (mean ±standard deviation, 61 ±30 g C m^-2, n = 4). During the subsequent 18 d, cumulative F_N decreased with decreasing irrigation frequency and increasing cumulative soil water deficit (W), with values of 70 ±22, 60 ±16, and 18 ±12 g C m^-2 for the I₁, I₃, and I₆ treatments, respectively. There were similar decreases in F_G, R_E, and R_L with increasing W, but differences in R_S were not significant. Use of the C₄ grass growing in a C₃-derived soil enabled partitioning of R_S into its autotrophic (R_A) and heterotrophic (R_H) components using a ¹³C natural abundance isotopic technique at the end of the experiment when differences in cumulative W between the treatments were the greatest. The values of R_H and its percentage contributions to R_S (43% ±8%, 42% ±8%, and 8% ±5% for the I₁, I₃, and I₆ treatments, respectively) suggested that R_H remained unaffected across a wide range of W and then decreased under extreme W. There were no significant differences in aboveground biomass between the treatments. Nitrous oxide (N₂O) emission was measured to determine if there was a trade-off effect between irrigation frequency and increasing W on net greenhouse gas emission, but no significant differences were found between the treatments. These findings suggest that over short periods in well-drained soil, irrigation frequency could be managed to manipulate soil water deficit in order to reduce net belowground respiratory C losses, particularly those from the microbial decomposition of soil organic matter, with no significant effect on biomass production and N₂O emission.     

Plant biomass influences rhizosphere priming effects on soil organic matter decomposition in two differently managed soils

We used a continuous labeling method of naturally ¹³C-depleted CO₂ in a growth chamber to test for rhizosphere effects on soil organic matter (SOM) decomposition. Two C3 plant species, soybean (Glycine max) and sunflower (Helianthus annus), were grown in two previously differently managed soils, an organically farmed soil and a soil from an annual grassland. We maintained a constant atmospheric CO₂ concentration at 400±5 ppm and δ¹³C signature at −24.4‰ by regulating the flow of naturally ¹³C-depleted CO₂ and CO₂-free air into the growth chamber, which allowed us to separate new plant-derived CO₂-C from original soil-derived CO₂-C in soil respiration. Rhizosphere priming effects on SOM decomposition, i.e., differences in soil-derived CO₂-C between planted and non-planted treatments, were significantly different between the two soils, but not between the two plant species. Soil-derived CO₂-C efflux in the organically farmed soil increased up to 61% compared to the no-plant control, while the annual grassland soil showed a negligible increase (up to 5% increase), despite an overall larger efflux of soil-derived CO₂-C and total soil C content. Differences in rhizosphere priming effects on SOM decomposition between the two soils could be largely explained by differences in plant biomass, and in particular leaf biomass, explaining 49% and 74% of the variation in primed soil C among soils and plant species, respectively. Nitrogen uptake rates by soybean and sunflower was relatively high compared to soil C respiration and associated N mineralization, while inorganic N pools were significantly depleted in the organic farm soil by the end of the experiment. Despite relatively large increases in SOM decomposition caused by rhizosphere effects in the organic farm soil, the fast-growing soybean and sunflower plants gained little extra N from the increase in SOM decomposition caused by rhizosphere effects. We conclude that rhizosphere priming effects of annual plants on SOM decomposition are largely driven by plant biomass, especially in soils of high fertility that can sustain high plant productivity.     

A new technique to measure soil CO2 efflux at constant CO2 concentration

A new principle for measuring soil CO₂ efflux at constant ambient concentration is introduced. The measuring principle relies on the continuous absorption of CO₂ within the system to achieve a constant CO₂ concentration inside the soil chamber at ambient level, thus balancing the amount of CO₂ entering the soil chamber by diffusion from the soil. We report results that show reliable soil CO₂ efflux measurements with the new system. The novel measuring principle does not disturb the natural gradient of CO₂ within the soil, while allowing for continuous capture of the CO₂ released from the soil. It therefore holds great potential for application in simultaneous measurements of soil CO₂ efflux and its δ¹³C, since both variables show sensitivity to a distortion of the soil CO₂ profile commonly found in conventional chamber techniques.     

Isotopic analysis of respired CO2 during decomposition of separated soil organic matter pools

A detailed understanding of the processes that contribute to the δ¹³C value of respired CO₂ is necessary to make links between the isotopic signature of CO₂ efflux from the soil surface and various sources within the soil profile. We used density fractionation to divide soils from two forested sites that are a part of an ongoing detrital manipulation experiment (the Detrital Input and Removal Treatments, or DIRT project) into two soil organic matter pools, each of which contributes differently to total soil CO₂ efflux. In both sites, distinct biological pools resulted from density fractionation; however, our results do not always support the concept that the light fraction is readily decomposable whereas the heavy fraction is recalcitrant. In a laboratory incubation following density fractionation we found that cumulative respiration over the course of the incubation period was greater from the light fraction than from the heavy fraction for the deciduous site, while the opposite was true for the coniferous site.Use of stable isotopes yielded insight as to the nature of the density fractions, with the heavy fraction solids from both forests isotopically enriched relative to those of the light fraction. The isotopic signature of respired CO₂, however, was more complicated. During incubation of the fractions there was an initial isotopic depletion of the respired CO₂ compared to the substrate for both soil fractions from both forests. Over time for both fractions of both soils the respired δ¹³C reflected more closely the initial substrate value; however, the transition from depleted to enriched respiration relative to substrate occurs at a different stage of decomposition depending on site and substrate recalcitrance. We found a relationship between cumulative respiration during the incubation period and the duration of the transition from isotopically depleted to enriched respiration in the coniferous site but not the deciduous site. Our results suggest that a shift in microbial community or to dead microbial biomass as a substrate could be responsible for the transition in the isotopic signature of respired CO₂ during decomposition. It is likely that a combination of organic matter quality and isotopic discrimination by microbes, in addition to differences in microbial community composition, contribute to the isotopic signature of different organic matter fractions. It is apparent that respired δ¹³CO₂ cannot be assumed to be a direct representation of the substrate δ¹³C. Detailed knowledge of the soil characteristics at a particular site is necessary to interpret relationships between the isotopic values of a substrate and respired CO₂.