A study of cattle infected with Brucella abortus and which showed aberrant serological reactions

SUMMARY Sixty cows, 48 of which had been vaccinated with live Brucella abortus strain 19 (S19) or with killed B. abortus strain 45/20 (S45/20) and 12 of which were unvaccinated animals, were challenged with B. abortus strain 544. Ten of the 27 cattle found to be infected after challenge showed aberrant serological reactions to the Rose Bengal Plate test, serum agglutination test and/or complement fixation test. These 10 cattle were all previously vaccinated with S19 or S45/20. It was concluded that infection in cattle vaccinated with S19 or S45/20 may be more difficult to detect than infection in animals that have no history of vaccination.     

An evaluation of the anamnestic test for brucellosis in cattle of the northern pastoral area

SUMMARY An investigation of the anamnestic test for brucellosis using Brucella abortus 45/20 vaccine was carried out in 3 groups of weaner cattle on 2 farms in western Queensland. Each group originally consisted of about 500 cattle. They were bled before and at 6 or 10 weeks after vaccination and again in the following year. The serums were tested by the complement fixation (CFT), Rose Bengal (RBT) and indirect haemolysis tests (IHLT). Most of the cattle reacting to one or more of the tests were killed and selected tissues were subjected to bacteriological examination for B. abortus. B. abortus was isolated from 19 of 30 (63%) pre-vaccinal reactors, 23 (24%) of 96 cattle reacting at 6 or 10 weeks after vaccination (the anamnestic test) and 1 (2%) of 50 cattle reacting one year after vaccination. The reactor found to be infected the year after vaccination had high serological titres in each of the 3 serological tests: RBT of 3, CFT of 128 and IHLT of 256. A subsequent test showed the group to be brucellosis-free. The CFT was the most efficient test. In the pre-vaccination tests 17 of 19 infected animals were positive in the CFT compared with 11 positive in the IHLT and 17 in the RBT. In post vaccination tests 22 of 23 infected animals were positive in the CFT compared with 18 in the IHLT and 19 in the RBT. At the pre-vaccinal and anamnestic tests (6 or 10 weeks after vaccination) 19 of 57 (33%) cattle with CF titre of 4 or 8 yielded B. abortus on culture compared with none of 26 cattle with similar titres in the year after vaccination. The interpretation of CF titres in cattle following 45/20 vaccination needs to be re-examined.     

Evaluation of the enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay in the detection of cattle infected with Brucella abortus

One group of 51 cattle was vaccinated with B. abortus S19 (S19) and a further 51 cattle were vaccinated with B. abortus S45/20 (S45/20). Forty-eight cattle (24 from each group) and a control group of 12 cattle were subsequently challenged with B. abortus S544. The enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) was used to detect specific IgG and IgM antibodies in these groups. All cattle vaccinated with S19 had high levels of IgG and IgM, but the S45/20 vaccine produced detectable antibody in only a few cattle. In those cattle where the challenge induced infection, the mean levels of IgG and IgM were much higher than those of the uninfected cattle in the same groups. When the isolation of B. abortus was compared at slaughter with the serological results, the ELISA, when used to detect specific IgG, was more sensitive but less specific than the serum agglutination test, complement fixation test and indirect haemolysis test, and more sensitive and more specific than the Rose Bengal test.     

THE INDIRECT HAEMOLYSIS TEST (IHLT) FOR BOVINE BRUCELLOSIS—COMPARISONS WITH THE COMPLEMENT FIXATION TEST (CFT) IN VACCINATED AND EXPERIMENTALLY INFECTED CATTLE

SUMMARY Cattle were vaccinated with Brucella abortus strain 19 subcutaneously in doses ranging from the normal (2.0 ml) dose of standard vaccine down to 1/400 of the normal dose, and via the conjunctival sac with 1/2 or 1/20 of the normal dose. Under all vaccination regimes serum antibody titres in the complement fixation test (CFT) rose more rapidly, reached higher levels, declined more slowly and involved a greater proportion of animals, than titres in the indirect haemolysis test (IHLT). The interval between the first positive serological test and parturition was determined for 54 pregnant cows infected with a virulent field strain (VRI 3) of B. abortus. On average the CFT titre rose to 1/4 43 days, and 1/8 33 days, before parturition, while the IHLT reached a 2/8 reaction 31 days before parturition.     

IMMUNOGLOBULIN CLASSES IN SERUM ANTIBODY REACTIONS IN CATTLE FOLLOWING VACCINATION WITH BRUCELLA ABORTUS STRAIN 19 AND KILLED 45/20 VACCINES

SUMMARY A group of 4 cows was vaccinated with Brucella abortus strain 19, followed 8 weeks later by a single dose of B. abortus 45/20 vaccine. A similar group received 2 doses of B. abortus 45/20 vaccine 8 weeks apart. The antibody responses of the groups were compared by testing whole serums and separated IgM and IgG fractions by the Rose Bengal Plate (RBP) agglutination and the complement fixation tests (CFT) using rough and smooth B. abortus antigens. Animals that had received B. abortus strain 19 responded to the 45/20 vaccine with increased titres to the smooth antigen. These relevant antibodies were predominantly of the IgG class. Standard CFT and RBP test antibodies could be detected in IgM and IgG fractions after the primary inoculation with B. abortus strain 19 vaccine.     

Comparison of an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay using monoclonal antibodies and a complement fixation test for cattle vaccinated and infected with Brucella abortus

A competitive enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) using a monoclonal antibody conjugated to horseradish peroxidase MA(A) and a complement fixation test (CFT) were applied to sera collected over a two-year period from 60 cattle challenged with Brucella abortus strain 544. Forty-eight of the cattle were previously vaccinated with B. abortus strain 19 (S19) or B. abortus strain 45/20 (45/20). After challenge 33 of the cattle remained uninfected and nine of the 27 infected cattle showed aberrant reactions by the CFT. The performance of the MA(A) ELISA was as follows: after vaccination, the MA(A) ELISA, like the CFT, was unable to differentiate infected cattle from those recently vaccinated with S19. After challenge the MA(A) ELISA gave results comparable with the CFT for those cattle with aberrant reactions. For the non-infected cattle there was a similar number of weeks after challenge when both tests were negative. It is suggested that the main advantage of the MA(A) ELISA when compared with the CFT lies in its relatively simple test procedure.     

THE EFFECT OF CHALLENGE WITH VIRULENT BRUCELLA ABORTUS ON BEEF CATTLE VACCINATED AS CALVES OR ADULTS WITH EITHER BRUCELLA ABORTUS STRAIN 19 OR 45/20

SUMMARY Groups of female calves were vaccinated subcutaneously with the standard dose of Brucella abortus strain 19 (S19) or with B. abortus 45/20 (S45/20). These calves and non-vaccinated control calves were mated at 15 months of age and challenged by way of the conjunctival sac with B. abortus strain 544 (S544). The incidence of abortion, stillbirths, weakling calves and healthy calves was observed after challenge and specimens were collected for culture at parturition and slaughter. Fifteen healthy calves were born to 18 animals vaccinated with S19, 12 were born to 18 animals vaccinated with S45/20 and 2 were born to 8 animals that were not vaccinated. B. abortus was isolated from 5 of the animals vaccinated with S19, 13 of the animals vaccinated with S45/20 and 9 of the 12 animals that were not vaccinated. Only one of the 5 infected animals vaccinated with S19 was vaccinated as an adult.     

Assessment of an intradermal test for the detection of bovine brucellosis

Forty-eight cattle were sensitised toBrucella antigens either by vaccination withBrucella abortus strain 19 (S19) orB. abortus 45/20 (S45/20) and 24 of these and 12 unvaccinated cattle were subsequently challenged with virulentB. abortus strain 544 (S544). All these cattle (n=60), together with 12 control cattle which were neither vaccinated nor challenged, were subsequently subjected to an intradermal test using a S45/20 protein antigen. Reactions were interpreted subjectively by observation and palpation and were measured to the nearest mm with calipers at 48 and 72 hours after injection of protein antigen. Ten weeks later the cattle were slaughtered and tissues cultured for the presence ofB. abortus. Two of the 48 vaccinated cattle died, 40 of the remaining 46 gave a positive response to the intradermal test at 48 hours and 36 were positive at 72 hours. In the controls any increase in the skin thickness had disappeared by 72 hours. An increase in skin thickness was still present at 72 hours in all other cattle except those vaccinated with S19 only. The intradermal test was found to be sensitive but not specific in detecting infected cattle and both sensitive and highly specific if used (with the exception of S19) to detect exposure toBrucella antigen.     

The anamnestic response to Brucella abortus-infected and vaccinated cattle

Fifty-four cattle were sensitised to Brucella antigens either by vaccination with Brucella abortus strain 19 (S19) or B. abortus 45/20 (S45/20) and 24 of these were challenged 12 weeks after mating with virulent B. abortus strain 544 (S544). A further 12 cattle which were not vaccinated were exposed to S544. After 40 weeks, all these cattle (66), together with 5 cattle which were not sensitised by vaccination or challenge were subsequently inoculated with one dose of S45/20 and the anamnestic response was measured by the complement fixation test. Ten to 15 weeks later the cattle were slaughtered and tissues cultured. Of the 52 (2 died) vaccinated cattle, 35 gave a positive anamnestic response and 20 of these were not challenged. Of the 17 unvaccinated cattle, one gave a positive response and this animal had been exposed to S544 prior to the inoculation with S45/20. The results indicated that the method had a level of sensitivity of 75% and specificity of 100% in serologically negative cattle that had been exposed previously to Brucella antigens. An evaluation of the method for detecting serologically negative, but infected cattle was not possible as the number of cattle suitable for examination in this study was too low.     

Use of an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay in a bovine brucellosis eradication program

An enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) was developed and was compared with the complement fixation test (CFT) in a bovine brucellosis eradication program. The ELISA detected significantly more reactors than the CFT in both strain 19 vaccinated infected herds (1.79% versus 1.14%) and non-vaccinated infected herds (4.2% versus 3.59%) but not in either vaccinated or non-vaccinated brucella-free herds. The specificity for both tests in brucella-free herds was greater than 0.998. The specificity and sensitivity of the ELISA were compared with those of 3 other tests (the Rose Bengal test; the indirect haemolysis test [IHLT] and the CFT) on serum from 151 animals cultured at slaughter. The calculated specificity of the ELISA in this infected group was lower than for both the CFT and the IHLT (0.58 versus 0.67 versus 0.75). The sensitivity however was much greater (1.0 versus 0.73 versus 0.71). The value of the ELISA when used in an eradication program is discussed.     

A comparative study of ELISA and other methods for the detection of Brucella antibodies in bovine sera

Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA), using β-galactosidase and a fluorigenic substrate, was used for the detection of antibodies to Brucella abortus in bovine sera.Among 677 animals from 9 brucellosis-free herds, none reacted in the ELISA. Among 785 animals from 23 brucellosis-infected herds, 336 were positive in ELISA, 229 in the slow agglutination test (SAT), 185 in the complement fixation test (CFT), and 165 in the Rose-Bengal test (RBT).Experimental infections were conducted with two B. abortus strains. At slaughter on day 101, after intraconjunctival infection of heifers with B. abortus strain 19 organisms, 3 animals were positive in the SAT, 3 in the CFT, 4 in the RBT and 11 in the ELISA, and Brucella organisms could be cultivated from 10 animals; among these, 2 scored positive in the SAT, 3 in the CFT, 3 in the RBT and 8 in the ELISA test. Seventeen heifers were infected with organisms of B. abortus strain 2308. On day 101, 11 heifers were found to be carriers, all of which yielded positive results in the CFT, RBT and ELISA tests, but not in the SAT.     

Serological crossreactivity between Brucella abortus and Yersinia enterocolitica 0:9 III. Specificity of the in vitro antigen-specific gamma interferon test for bovine brucellosis diagnosis in experimentally Yersinia enterocolitica 0:9-infected cattle

The course of immunological reaction in 10 Yersinia enterocolitica 0:9 experimentally-infected heifers was followed using the conventional brucellosis tests complement fixation test (CFT), serum agglutination test (SAT) and brucella card test (BCT), and a recently developed Brucella antigen-specific gamma interferon (IFN-γ) test. Initially, the animals were exposed orally to 10¹⁰ colony-forming units (CFU) of Y. enterocolitica 0:9. Four weeks later, they were inoculated intravenously with 10⁸ CFU of Y. enterocolitica 0:9 cells. After oral inoculation, the response in the conventional brucellosis tests was minimal. Only after intravenous inoculation were CFT and SAT titres and BCT reactions comparable to natural, false positive brucellosis reactors. After oral exposure the Brucellergen-stimulated release of IFN-γ peaked at values above the cut-off stimulation index of 2.5 in 80% of the heifers. After intravenous inoculation, stimulation indices above 2.5 were present in only 10% of the animals. Two B. abortus infected control cattle showed stimulation indices of 3.1 and 3.4, and a negative control animal exhibited a stimulation index of 1.0. These findings show, in contrast to a previous study, that the Brucellergen-specific IFN-γ assay cannot be used as a specific and discriminatory test for B. abortus infections.     

The effect of immaturity of the calf on immunological responses to strain 19 and killed 45/20 adjuvant vaccines.

Thirty brucellosis free calves with zero titres to the serum agglutination test (SAT), complement fixation test (CFT) and antiglobulin test (ABGT) were vaccinated with strain 19 at ages from seven hours to 198 days. Calves 75 days of age and older responded with normal serological patterns, developing high titres to all three tests. At 45 days and younger most calves responded with much reduced titres, some were negative to the SAT and CFT but all develped titres to the ABGT. Two of the younger group were subjected to an anamnestic test at about a year old and gave a positive response, indicating that the calf may be effectively primed with S19 as early as the first day of life. Three of the group were colostrumdeprived yet the patterns of their responses were similar to those of the colostrum-fed calves. Seventy-four zero titres calves were vaccinated with killed 45/20 adjuvant vaccine at ages from 60 to 320 days. Up to 200 days of age only seven of 33 calves gave positive response. From 200 to 280 days 18 of 29 responded and from 280 days of age all calves a positive response. The late development of competence to respond to this adjuvant vaccine is somewhat unusual and is discussed. It is suggested that the rough strain 45/20 may be a very weak antigen in cattle.     

A comparison of the potency of several Brucella allergens used to detect brucellosis in cattle

The potency of Brucella allergens prepared from a smooth Brucella abortus strain S-99, mucoid strain Leewarden, rough strain 45/20, and rough Brucella melitensis strain B-115 was assessed. The potency of these allergens was compared with that of a standard allergen prepared from smooth Brucella abortus S-99 that efficiently detected bovine brucellosis in other studies. Eight cattle experimentally inoculated with Brucella abortus 544 were tested with the allergens 4 and 10 weeks after infection, and again 8 months after infection. All the allergens effectively detected infection but there was a clear distinction in the mean skin reactions 48 and 72 h after injection of the allergens. The skin reactions provoked by the allergens prepared from smooth or mucoid strains of Brucella were most pronounced 48 h after injection. Skin reactions provoked by allergens prepared from rough strains of Brucella were strongest 72 h after injection. Allergens prepared from smooth or mucoid Brucella strains were more potent in detecting brucellosis than those prepared from rough strains of Brucella.Abbreviations Bruc/OCB Brucellergen OCB - cfu colony-forming units - CFT complement fixation test - ID-DLO Institute voor Dierhouderij en Diergezondheid-Dienst Landbouwkundig Onderzoek - ICFTU international complement fixation units - IU international units - LPS lipopolysaccharide - SAT serum agglutination test - SDTH skin delayed-type hypersensitivity     

The role of the differential complement fixation test, using rough and smooth brucella antigens, in the anamnestic test

To assess the ability of the differential complement fixation test to distinguish vaccinal reactors from infected cattle, approximately 1,000 heifers were tested by the complement fixation test (CFT) using rough and smooth brucella antigens, before the injection of 45/20 vaccine and at 3 and 6 or 10 weeks after vaccination. Before vaccination 91.5% of heifers were negative to the rough antigen but 0.6% were positive with high titre (greater than or equal to 128). By 10 weeks after injection of 45/20 vaccine 97.6% of heifers were positive to the rough CF antigen, at greater than or equal to 8, a majority reaching greater than or equal to 128. Nineteen pre-vaccinal reactors to the standard CFT were killed and Brucella abortus was isolated from the tissues of 14. Twenty-six post-vaccinal reactors were killed and B. abortus was isolated from the tissues of 8. In the 22 B. abortus infected animals the differential CFT classified 9 correctly as infected, 5 incorrectly as vaccination reactions and 8 as inconclusive. The differential CF was ineffective in distinguishing titres resulting from vaccination with 45/20 vaccine from those due to infection.     

A competition enzyme immunoassay for brucellosis diagnosis

Two monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) conjugated with horseradish peroxidase were used independently in a competitive enzyme immunoassay (cEIA) to detect Brucella specific antibodies in 1120 sera from Brucella-free cattle, 61 from cattle known to be infected with B. abortus, and 207 sera from vaccinated calves. The results were compared to those obtained in the complement fixation test (CFT). The cEIA with both MAbs proved to be more sensitive than the CFT because no false-negative results were obtained. In addition, discrimination between sera from infected and vaccinated animals was more evident.     

Applied serology in the latter stages of the eradication of bovine brucellosis

Late in the program to eradicate bovine brucellosis from Western Australia, Rose Bengal test (RBT) and complement fixation test (CFT) results on the serums from 2,307 cattle (from herds where infection was still present after a minimum of 3 complete herd tests) showed that 327 were positive in the CFT and 246 were positive in the RBT (p less than 0.001). Subsequent testing by the RBT, CFT and the indirect haemolysis test (IHLT) of 722 serums from cattle slaughtered as part of infected herds showed that of 177 cattle positive on culture, 138 were positive in all 3 tests, 9 were negative in all 3 tests and no animal positive on culture had a reaction only in the RBT. In the 177 cattle from which B. abortus was isolated, positive reactions in the CFT occurred in the serums of 159 of them. Application of the RBT as a screening test followed by a confirmatory CFT would have resulted in 149 of the 177 cattle being positive and application of the CFT/IHLT (double test) on the serums of all cattle in the herds would have resulted in 168 or the 177 being regarded as positive.     

Bovine leptospirosis: the effects of vaccination on serological responses as determined by complement fixation and microscopic agglutination tests

Fifty-one calves were divided into six trial groups of seven to eleven animals and vaccinated with a commercial leptospiral vaccine containing serovars pomona and hardjo. Vaccinations were given at 6,7,14 or 21 months of age and animals in various groups were vaccinated on one to four occasions. Antibody responses were determined by the microscopic agglutination test (MAT) and the complement fixation test (CFT) at one to four weeks intervals until 66 weeks after the start of the trial. Fifty percent or greater agglutination in serum diluted 1:100 or more and 50% or greater fixation of complement in serum diluted 1:20 or more were considered positive titres in the MAT or CFI respectively. Positive titres were still present in some animals six weeks after vaccination at 21 months of age. In other cases MAT titres (range 1:100-1:3000) persisted for 7-23 weeks and CFI titres (range 1:20-1540) persisted for 1-14 weeks. Marked individual variation in serological findings occurred using either test. In general the number of animals producing a positive titre, and the magnitude and persistence of titres was related to the number of doses of vaccine given. It was concluded that for diagnostic purposes neither the CFT nor the MAT could reliably differentiate titres due to vaccination from those following natural infections.     

Antibody isotype response in adult cattle vaccinated with Brucella abortus S19

In a chronological study of sera collected from eight adult cattle vaccinated with 3 X 10(-10) cfu of Brucella abortus S19, antibody of each of the four major isotypes was measured by indirect enzyme immunoassay (ELISA) and by direct and modified complement fixation tests (CFT). Six of the cattle gave antibody responses to the vaccine strain that commenced between days 5 and 8 for all the isotypes in the ELISA, peaked by 1 to 4 months and then declined to low levels by 10 months. Direct CFT and modified CFT titers were measurable by 7 or 8 days post-vaccination, and peaked by 1 month; direct CFT titers disappeared by 5 months while the modified CFT titers lingered for 10 months. Two animals gave cyclical direct CFT and modified CFT antibody responses, a cyclical IgG1 response, a low IgG2 and an elevated IgA response. The amplitude of the cycles was uniform over three cycles while the wavelength increased with time. A year post-vaccination, B. abortus S19 was isolated twice from milk from one of the animals (no attempt was made to culture B. abortus from the other). Sera from B. abortus naturally infected cattle were analysed for comparison.     

Myopathy of dogs resembling white muscle disease of sheep

Automation of the complement fixation test for diagnosing Brucella abortus infection in cattle has allowed this difficult, time-consuming and labour-intensive hut most specific test to he used for large scale serodiagnosis in New Zealand's Brucellosis Eradication Scheme. The automated test has the advantages of eliminating much human error, of improving accuracy and of reducing the costs of labour and reagents.

The Auto-Analyzer performs a warm complement fixation test at a single serum dilution. Each batch of 39 serum samples is compared with a standard positive control serum with a complement fixing antibody activity equivalent to 1/30 of the second International Standard Ani-Brucella abortus Serum. All sera with an antibody level equal to, or greater than, the standard serum are regarded as positive to the test. A titre for serum tested by the automated method is not obtained, and positive sera that prozone strongly may be recorded as negative. Where necessary, the semi-automated microtitre complement fixation test is used to delineate titres and the status of doubtful automated CFT results. The automated and microtitre complement fixation tests use the same reagents; only relative concentrations differ.