Greenhouse gas emissions from farmed organic soils: a review

Abstract. The large boreal peatland ecosystems sequester carbon and nitrogen from the atmosphere due to a low oxygen pressure in waterlogged peat. Consequently they are sinks for CO₂ and strong emitters of CH₄. Drainage and cultivation of peatlands allows oxygen to enter the soil, which initiates decomposition of the stored organic material, and in turn CO₂ and N₂O emissions increase while CH₄ emissions decrease. Compared to undrained peat, draining of organic soils for agricultural purposes increases the emissions of greenhouse gases (CO₂, CH₄, and N₂O) by roughly 1t CO₂ equivalents/ha per year. Although farmed organic soils in most European countries represent a minor part of the total agricultural area, these soils contribute significantly to national greenhouse gas budgets. Consequently, farmed organic soils are potential targets for policy makers in search of socially acceptable and economically cost-efficient measures to mitigate climate gas emissions from agriculture. Despite a scarcity of knowledge about greenhouse gas emissions from these soils, this paper addresses the emissions and possible control of the three greenhouse gases by different managements of organic soils. More precise information is needed regarding the present trace gas fluxes from these soils, as well as predictions of future emissions under alternative management regimes, before any definite policies can be devised.     

Methane and nitrous oxide fluxes from a farmed Swedish Histosol

Fluxes of the greenhouse gases methane (CH₄) and nitrous oxide (N₂O) from histosolic soils (which account for approximately 10% of Swedish agricultural soils) supporting grassley and barley production in Sweden were measured over 3 years using static chambers. Emissions varied both over area and time. Methane was both produced and oxidized in the soil: fluxes were small, with an average emission of 0.12 g CH₄ m⁻² year⁻¹ at the grassley site and net uptake of −0.01 g CH₄ m⁻² year⁻¹ at the barley field. Methane emission was related to soil water, with more emission when wet. Nitrous oxide emissions varied, with peaks of emission after soil cultivation, ploughing and harrowing. On average, the grassley and barley field had emissions of 0.20 and 1.51 g N₂O m⁻² year⁻¹, respectively. We found no correlation between N₂O and soil factors, but the greatest N₂O emission was associated with the driest areas, with < 60% average water-filled pore space. We suggest that the best management option to mitigate emissions is to keep the soil moderately wet with permanent grass production, which restricts N₂O emissions whilst minimizing those of CH₄.     

Mitigation of greenhouse gas emissions from soil under silage production by use of organic manures or slow-release fertilizer

Abstract. Grassland is a major source of nitrous oxide (N₂O) and methane (CH₄) emissions in the UK, resulting from high rates of fertilizer application. We studied the effects of substituting mineral fertilizer by organic manures and a slow-release fertilizer in silage grass production on greenhouse gas emissions and soil mineral N content in a three-year field experiment. The organic manures investigated were sewage sludge pellets and composted sewage sludge (dry materials), and digested sewage sludge and cattle slurry (liquid materials). The organic manures produced N₂O and carbon dioxide (CO₂) consistently from time of application up to harvest. However, they mitigated N₂O emissions by around 90% when aggregate emissions of 15.7 kg N ha⁻¹ from NPK fertilizer were caused by a flux of up to 4.9 kg N ha⁻¹ d⁻¹ during the first 4 days after heavy rainfall subsequent to the NPK fertilizer application. CH₄ was emitted only for 2 or 3 days after application of the liquid manures. CH₄ and CO₂ fluxes were not significantly mitigated. Composting and dried pellets were useful methods of conserving nutrients in organic wastes, enabling slow and sustained release of nitrogen. NPK slow-release fertilizer also maintained grass yields and was the most effective substitute for the conventional NPK fertilizer for mitigation of N₂O fluxes.     

Carbon sequestration and saving potential associated with changes to the management of agricultural soils in England

Abstract. The potential for soil organic carbon sequestration, energy savings and the reduction of the emission of greenhouse gases were investigated for a range of changes in the management of tilled land and managed grassland. These parameters were modelled on a regional basis, according to local soils and crop rotations in England, and avoided the use of soil related indices. The largest carbon sequestration and saving contribution possible comes from an increase in the proportion of permanent woodland, such that a 10% change in land use could amount to 9 Mt C yr⁻¹ in the initial years (arable and grassland). Changes in arable management could make a significant contribution to an abatement strategy if carried out in concert with greater use of permanent conservation field margins, increased returns of crop residues and reduced tillage systems, contributing 1.3 Mt C yr⁻¹ in the initial years. It should be noted, however, that true soil carbon sequestration would be only a minor component of this (125 kt C yr⁻¹), the main part being savings on CO₂ emissions from reduced energy use, and lower N₂O emissions from reduced use of inorganic nitrogen fertilizer.     

Spatial variations in nitrous oxide and nitric oxide emission potential on a slope of Japanese cedar (Cryptomeria japonica) forest

To quantify the spatial variation and spatial structure of nitrous oxide (N₂O) and nitric oxide (NO) emission from forest soils, we measured N₂O and NO emission rates from surface soil cores taken at 1 m intervals on a cross-line transect (65 m × 20 m) on a slope of Japanese cedar ( Cryptomeria japonica ) forest in a temperate region of central Japan and analyzed the spatial dependency of N oxide gas emissions using geostatistics. We divided N₂O emission into N₂O from denitrification and N₂O from nitrification using the acetylene inhibition method. According to the geostatistical analysis, N₂O emission rates on the slope had large spatial variation and weak spatial dependency. This weak spatial dependency was caused by the inordinately high N₂O emissions on the slope, which were derived mainly from denitrification. In contrast, NO emission rate on the slope had large spatial variation, but strong spatial dependency and a distinct spatial distribution related to slope position, that is, high in the middle of the slope and low in the shoulder and the foot of the slope. The CN ratio and water-filled pore space were the dominant factors controlling NO emission rate on a slope. Our results suggest that spatial information about topographic factors helps to improve the estimation of both N₂O emission and NO emission from forest soils.     

Nitrous oxide and carbon dioxide emissions from grassland amended with sewage sludge

Abstract. Land disposal of sewage sludge in the UK is set to increase markedly in the next few years and much of this will be applied to grassland. Here we applied high rates of digested sludge cake (1–1.5×10³ kg total N ha⁻¹) to grassland and incorporated it prior to reseeding. Using automated chambers, nitrous oxide (N₂O) and carbon dioxide (CO₂) fluxes from the soil were monitored 2–4 times per day, for 6 months after sludge incorporation. Peaks of N₂O emission were up to 1.4 kg N ha⁻¹ d⁻¹ soon after incorporation, and thereafter were regularly detected following significant rainfalls. Gas emissions reflected diurnal temperature variations, though N₂O emissions were also strongly affected by rainfall. Although emissions decreased in the winter, temperatures below 4 °C stimulated short, sharp fluxes of both CO₂ and N₂O as temperature increased. The aggregate loss of nitrogen and carbon over the measurement period was up to 23 kg N ha⁻¹ and 5.1 t C ha⁻¹. Losses of N₂O in the sludge-amended soil were associated with good microbial conditions for N mineralization, and with high carbon and water contents. Since grassland is an important source of greenhouse gases, application of sewage sludge can be at least as significant as fertilizer in enhancing these emissions.     

Mineralization of Nitrogen and N2O Production Potentials in Acid Forest Soils under Controlled Aerobic Conditions

Some acid surface mineral soils from different forest vegetations and sites in central Japan were taken during April and October in 2003 to study the net N mineralization and N₂O production potentials in the laboratory. Under the controlled aerobic conditions, 50 Pa C₂H₂ in the headspace can be used to study total gaseous-N losses during the aerobic mineralization and heterotrophic N₂O production in acid forest soils. The net N mineralization of these acid forest soils and N₂O-N production was variable with forest stands and with seasons, probably because of the quality of the litters and the variations of soil attributes. Three deciduous forest soils during two sampling reveal a higher potential for the total gaseous-N loss during the aerobic mineralization as compared with two coniferous forest soils. Heterotrophic nitrification among these acid forest soils accounted for the range from 37.0 to 76.3% of the total N₂O production under the experimental conditions, and was variable with forest stands and with seasons. Some factors regulating the net N mineralization and N₂O-N production were discussed in these acid forest soils.     

Effects of Plant Species on CH4 and N2O Fluxes from a Volcanic Grassland Soil in Nasu, Japan

To investigate the effects of plant species in grassland on methane (CH₄) and nitrous oxide (N₂O) fluxes from soil, fluxes from an orchardgrass ( Dactylis glomerata L.) grassland, white clover ( Trifolium repens L.) grassland and orchardgrass/white clover mixed grassland were measured weekly from April 2001 to March 2002 using a vented closed chamber method. Related environmental parameters (soil inorganic N content, soil pH (H₂O) value, soil moisture content, soil temperature, grass yield, and the number of soil microorganisms) were also regularly monitored. On an annual basis, CH₄ consumption in the soil of the orchardgrass grassland, white clover grassland and orchardgrass/white clover mixed grassland was 1.8, 2.4, and 1.8 kg C ha⁻¹ year⁻¹, respectively. The soil bulk density of the white clover grassland was lower than that of the other grasslands. Fluxes of CH₄ were positively correlated with the soil moisture content. White clover increased the CH₄ consumption by improving soil aeration. Nitrogen supply to the soil by white clover did not decrease the CH₄ consumption in the soil of our grasslands. On the other hand, annual N₂O emissions from the orchardgrass grassland, white clover grassland, and orchardgrass/white clover mixed grassland were 0.39, 1.59, and 0.67 kg N ha⁻¹ year⁻¹, respectively. Fluxes of N₂O were correlated with the NO₃⁻ content in soil and soil temperature. White clover increased the N₂O emissions by increasing the inorganic N content derived from degrading white clover in soil in summer.     

The effect of soil texture and soil drainage on emissions of nitric oxide and nitrous oxide

Abstract. Agricultural soils are important sources of the tropospheric ozone precursor NO and the greenhouse gas N₂O. Emissions are controlled primarily by parameters that vary the soil mineral N supply, temperature and soil aeration. In this field experiment, the importance of soil physical properties on emissions of NO and N₂O are identified. Fluxes were measured from 13 soils which belonged to 11 different soil series, ranging from poorly drained silty clay loams to freely drained sandy loams. All soils were under the same soil management regime and crop type (winter barley) and in the same maritime climate zone. Despite this, emissions of NO and N₂O ranged over two orders of magnitude on all three measurement occasions, in spring before and after fertilizer application, and in autumn after harvest. NO emissions ranged from 0.3 to 215 μg NO-N m^–2 h^–1, with maximum emissions always from the most sandy, freely drained soil. Nitrous oxide emissions ranged from 0 to 193 μg N₂O-N m^–2 h^–1. Seasonal shifts in soil aeration caused maximum N₂O emissions to switch from freely drained sandy soils in spring to imperfectly drained soils with high clay contents in autumn. Although effects of soil type on emissions were not consistent, N₂O emission was best related to a combination of bulk density and clay content and the NO/N₂O ratio decreased logarithmically with increasing water filled pore space.     

Methane fluxes on agricultural and forested boreal organic soils

Abstract. Annual methane fluxes from an organic soil in eastern Finland, originally drained and planted with birch ( Betula pendula ) and then later cultivated, were studied for two years using a chamber technique. The agricultural soils growing grass or barley or without vegetation, generally acted as sinks for CH₄. Surprisingly, the agricultural soils emitted CH₄ during a warm dry summer. The CH₄ oxidation capacity and CH₄ uptake rate of the forested site was three times that of agricultural soils. Also, the forest soil better retained its capacity to take up CH₄ during a dry summer. Despite periods of CH₄ emission, the agricultural soils were annual sinks for CH₄, with uptake rate of CH₄-C varying from 0.1 to 3.7 kg ha⁻¹ yr⁻¹. The forested soil had a methane uptake rate of 3.9 kg CH₄-C ha⁻¹ yr⁻¹. All the soils acted as sinks for CH₄ during winter, which contributed up to half of the annual CH₄ uptake. The capacity of soils to transport gases did not explain the larger CH₄ uptake rate in the forest soil. At the same gas filled porosity, the forest soil had a much larger CH₄ uptake rate than the agricultural soil. Neither the soil acidity (pH 4.5 and 6.0) nor high ammonium content appeared to limit CH₄ uptake. The results suggest that CH₄ oxidation in agricultural organic soil is more sensitive to soil drying than CH₄ oxidation in forested organic soil.     

Emission of NH3 and N2O after spreading of pig slurry by broadcasting or band spreading

Abstract. The recommended method of reducing the emission of NH₃ while spreading manure is to plough or harrow the manure into the soil. This in turn increases the possibility of N₂O emission. At two sites in southern Sweden emissions of NH₃ and N₂O were measured after spreading pig slurry by broadcasting and band spreading. The band spreading technique can be used in growing crops i.e. when nitrogen is most needed, and it is thought that the NH₃ emission is smaller with this technique compared to broadcasting. The average NH₃ loss was 50% of applied NH₄⁺ during warm/dry conditions and 10% during cold/wet conditions. The N₂O emission was always less than 1% of applied NH₄⁺. When the NH₃ emission decreased, the direct N₂O emission increased. However, when taking into account the indirect N₂O emission due to deposition of NH₃ outside the field, the spreading techniques all produced similar total N₂O emissions. The ammonia emission was not much lower for the band spreading technique compared to broadcasting, when compared on seven occasions.     

Including trace gas fluxes in estimates of the carbon mitigation potential of UK agricultural land

Abstract. A number of changes in agricultural land-management show some potential as carbon mitigation options. However, research has focused on CO₂-carbon mitigation and has largely ignored potential effects of land management change on trace gas fluxes. In this paper, we attempt for the first time, to assess the impact of these changes on fluxes of the important agricultural greenhouse gases, methane and nitrous oxide, in the UK.
The estimates presented here are based on limited evidence and have a great (unquantifiable) uncertainty associated with them, but they show that the relative importance of trace gas fluxes varies enormously among the scenarlos. In some, such as the application of sewage sludge, woodland regeneration and bioenergy production scenarios, the inclusion of estimates for trace gas fluxes makes only a small (<10%) difference to the CO₂-C mitigation potential. In the animal manure and agricultural extensification scenarios, including estimates of trace gas fluxes has a large impact, increasing the CO₂-C mitigation potential by up to 50%. In the no-till scenario, the carbon mitigation potential decreases significantly due to a sharp increase in N₂O emissions under no-till.
When these land-management options are combined for the whole agricultural land area of the UK, including trace gases has an impact on estimated mitigation potentials, and depending upon assumptions for the animal manure scenario, the total mitigation potential either decreases by about 10% or increases by about 30%, potentially shifting the mitigation potential of the scenario closer to the EU's 8% Kyoto target for reduction of CO₂-carbon emissions (12.52 Tg C yr⁻¹ for the UK).     

Relationship between N2O and NO emission potentials and soil properties in Japanese forest soils

To determine the relationship between nitrous oxide (N₂O) and nitric oxide (NO) emission rates and soil properties in forest soils, N₂O and NO emission rates in soils were measured in incubation experiments under standardized temperature and water conditions (water content at a water-holding capacity of 60%) using soils packed into a cylindrical core, and variations in the soil properties were also determined. The N₂O emission rates from nitrification and from denitrification were determined separately using a nitrification inhibitor (10 Pa acetylene). Soil samples were taken from 25 forest stands in a central temperate area of Japan. The N₂O and NO emission rates were highly variable, even under the standardized temperature and water-holding capacity (60%) conditions. According to a partial least squared regression model analysis, the C:N ratio and pH strongly affected the N₂O emission rate, whereas     , water-soluble Al and the C:N ratio strongly affected the NO emission rate. The C:N ratio negatively affected the emission rate of both N oxide gases, suggesting that N mineralization is an important factor in the rates of N oxide gas emission. The acetylene inhibition experiment showed that N₂O emission from denitrification was positively affected by pH, water-filled pore space and filling density, and negatively affected by the C:N ratio, total carbon and total nitrogen.     

Carbon cycling and sequestration opportunities in temperate grasslands

Abstract. Temperate grasslands account for c. 20% of the land area in Europe. Carbon accumulation in grassland ecosystems occurs mostly below ground and changes in soil organic carbon stocks may result from land use changes (e.g. conversion of arable land to grassland) and grassland management. Grasslands also contribute to the biosphere–atmosphere exchange of non-CO₂ radiatively active trace gases, with fluxes intimately linked to management practices. In this article, we discuss the current knowledge on carbon cycling and carbon sequestration opportunities in temperate grasslands. First, from a simple two-parameter exponential model fitted to literature data, we assess soil organic carbon fluxes resulting from land use change (e.g. between arable and grassland) and from grassland management. Second, we discuss carbon fluxes within the context of farming systems, including crop–grass rotations and farm manure applications. Third, using a grassland ecosystem model (PaSim), we provide estimates of the greenhouse gas balance, in CO₂ equivalents, of pastures for a range of stocking rates and of N fertilizer applications. Finally, we consider carbon sequestration opportunities for France resulting from the restoration of grasslands and from the de-intensification of intensive livestock breeding systems. We emphasize major uncertainties concerning the magnitude and non-linearity of soil carbon stock changes in agricultural grasslands as well as the emissions of N₂O from soil and of CH₄ from grazing livestock.     

Methane oxidation kinetics differ in European beech and Norway spruce soils

Coniferous forest soils often consume less of the greenhouse gas methane (CH₄) than deciduous forest soils. The reasons for this phenomenon have not been resolved. It might be caused by differences in the diffusive flux of CH₄ through the organic layer, pH or different concentrations of potentially inhibitory compounds. Soil samples were investigated from three adjacent European beech ( Fagus sylvatica ) and Norway spruce ( Picea abies ) stands in Germany. Maximal CH₄ oxidation velocities (V_max(app)) and Michaelis Menten constants (K_M(app)), retrieved from intact soil cores at constant CH₄ concentrations, temperature and matric potential, were twice as great in beech as in spruce soils. Also atmospheric CH₄ oxidation rates measured in homogenized soil samples displayed the same trend. Greatest atmospheric CH₄ oxidation rates were detected in the O_a horizon or in the upper 5 cm of the mineral soil. In contrast to the beech soils, the O_a horizon of the spruce soils consumed no CH₄. A differential effect due to divergent diffusive flux through the litter layer was not found. pH and ammonium concentration were similar in samples from both forest soil types. Ethylene accumulation in all soils was negligible under oxic conditions. These collective results suggest that the different atmospheric CH₄ uptake by beech and spruce soils is caused by different CH₄ oxidizing capacities of methanotrophic communities in the O_a horizon and top mineral soil.     

Fluxes of methane from rice fields and potential for mitigation

Abstract. Methane (CH₄) is an important greenhouse gas. Flooded rice fields (paddies) are a significant source of atmospheric CH₄; estimates of the annual emission from paddies range from less than 20 to 100 million Tg, with best estimates of 50 × 20 Tg. The emission is the net result of opposing bacterial processes: production in anaerobic microenvironments, and consumption and oxidation in aerobic microenvironments, both of which occur sequentially and concurrently in flooded rice soils. With current technologies, CH₄ emission from rice fields will increase as production increases. Over the next 25 years rice production will have to increase by 65% from the present 460 Mt/y to 760 Mt/y in 2020. The current understanding of the processes controlling CH₄ fluxes, rice growth and rice production is sufficient to develop mitigation technologies. Promising candidates are changes in water management, rice cultivars, fertilization, and cultural practices. A significant reduction of CH₄ emission from rice fields, at the same time that rice production and productivity increase at the farm level, is feasible, although the regions where particular practices can be applied, and the trade-offs that are possible, have still to be identified.     

Nitrous oxide emission from soils after incorporating crop residues

Abstract. Emissions of N₂O were measured from different agricultural systems in SE Scotland. N₂O emissions increased temporarily after fertilization of arable crops, cultivation of bare soil, ploughing up of grassland and incorporation of arable and horticultural crop residues, but the effect was short-lived. Most of the emission occurred during the first two weeks, returning to 'background' levels after 30–40 days. The highest flux was from N-rich lettuce residues, 1100 g N₂O-N ha⁻¹ being emitted over the first 14 days after incorporation by rotary tillage. The magnitude and pattern of emissions was strongly influenced by rainfall, soil mineral N, cultivation technique and C:N ratio of the residue. Comparatively large emissions were measured after incorporation of material with low C:N ratios. Management practices are recommended that would increase N-use efficiency and reduce N₂O emissions from agricultural soils.     

Production and Emission of Nitrous Oxide and Responsible Microorganisms in Upland Acid Soil in Indonesia

Incubation and field experiments were conducted to determine emission and production of nitrous oxide (N₂O) and responsible microorganisms in an upland acid soil of Indonesia. The results showed that N₂O productions in the soil samples were affected by ammonium and urea amendments compared with control. N₂O production reached the highest peak at the first week then decreased until 4 weeks incubation in the potato and tea soil samples. However, more N₂O production was found in tea soil than potato soil. Pine forest soil produced N₂O more at second week incubation than first week, then decreased until 4 weeks. These results further confirmed that the N₂O emitted in the field, which was higher in tea garden than other fields. The both ammonium and nitrate contents in the tea soil were higher than potato and pine soils. The number of ammonium oxidizers in the pine and potato soils was not significantly different, but it was lower in the tea soil. Number of nitrite oxidizers was almost the same in the potato and tea soils, however it was lower in the pine soil. The number of denitrifiers was 1–3 orders magnitude higher in the tea soil than the potato and pine soils.     

Effect of nitrite accumulation on nitrous oxide emission and total nitrogen loss during swine manure composting

The present study investigated the nitrogen balance in swine manure composting to evaluate the effect of nitrite (     ) accumulation, which induces nitrogenous emissions, such as N₂O, during compost maturation. During active composting, most N losses result from NH₃ emission, which was 9.5% of the initial total nitrogen (TN_initial), after which,     began to accumulate as only ammonia-oxidizing bacteria proliferated. After active composting, the addition of mature swine compost (MSC), including nitrite-oxidizing bacteria (NOB), could prevent     accumulation and reduce N₂O emission by 70% compared with the control in which     accumulated as a result of delayed growth of indigenous NOB. Total N₂O emissions in the control and in the treatment of MSC addition (MA) were 9.3% and 3.0% of TN_initial, respectively, whereas N losses as the sum total of NH₃ and N₂O over the whole period were 19.0% (control) and 12.8% (MA) of TN_initial, respectively. However, the difference in total N losses was markedly greater than that measured as NH₃ and N₂O, which were 27.8% (control) and 13.3% (MA) of TN_initial, respectively. These results demonstrated that the magnitude of nitrogen losses induced by     accumulation is too large to ignore in the composting of swine manure.     

The influence of tillage on NO and N2O fluxes under spring and winter barley

Abstract. There is a lack of information about the influence of tillage and time of sowing on N₂O and NO emission in cereal production. Both factors influence crop growth and soil conditions and thereby can affect trace gas emissions from soils. We measured fluxes of NO and N₂O in a tillage experiment where grassland on clay loam soil was converted to arable by either direct drilling or ploughing to 30 cm depth. We made measurements in spring for 20 days after fertilizer application to spring-sown and to winter-sown barley. Both were the second barley crop after grass. Direct drilling enhanced N₂O emission primarily as a result of restricted gas diffusivity causing poor aeration after rainfall. Deep ploughing enhanced NO emission, because of the large air-filled porosity in the topsoil. NO and N₂O emissions were smaller from winter sown crops than from spring sown crops.   The three rates of N fertilizer application (40, 80 or 120 kg N ha^–1) did not produce the expected linear response in either soil available N concentrations or in NO and N₂O fluxes. We attributed this to the lack of rainfall in the ten-day period after fertilizer application and therefore very slow incorporation and movement of fertilizer into and through the soil.